36 of 51 criteria have a sourced finding; 29 were also cross-checked by a second agent. Every comparison that includes multi-agent-shogun links here for scope, limitations, atomic answers and sources.
Humans approve the rubric, templates and prototype; they do not review every finding. An agent source cross-check is not a hands-on product test. A missing sourced finding is not evidence that a capability is absent.
Terminal workflow runs on Linux/macOS and WSL2; Android companion monitors and commands the remote formation. A supplied Python browser dashboard renders dashboard.md, including a phone-sized viewport. Windows execution requires WSL2 rather than a native Windows build.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation, Shogun Android companion · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps.
9 atomic answers
Desktop os [unknown] Desktop os remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Mobile apps [supported] Android companion APK via SSH; no iOS app. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Browser [supported] The supplied dashboard-viewer.py serves an auto-refreshing read-only browser work dashboard. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard.
Mobile browser [supported] The same dashboard declares a device-width viewport and serves the work dashboard over HTTP. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard.
Cross device continuity [unknown] Cross device continuity remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
The v5.1.0 release supports five named coding CLIs in formation roles. Antigravity and Cursor appear in newer main-branch documentation; a released integration was not established.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e Antigravity source pass: v5.1.0 (bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919). · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-10
Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open.
Antigravity and Cursor are main-branch additions in the checked documentation; their released harness support remains unknown.
5 atomic answers
Harnesses [supported] The v5.1.0 release supports Claude Code, Codex, Copilot, Kimi Code and OpenCode. Released Antigravity and Cursor support is unknown; their documented integrations occur on a later main revision. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:agy-release-1.
Model providers [unknown] Model providers remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Custom adapters [unknown] Custom adapters remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
CLI subscriptions are an explicit billing route; provider credentials stay with the CLI.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-08
Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open.
7 atomic answers
Agent subscriptions [supported] README discusses flat-rate coding-agent subscriptions and cost_group plan routing. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Api accounts [supported] OpenCode may use provider API keys configured in its own account. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Vendor credits [unknown] Vendor credits remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Local models [unknown] Local models remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Account switching [unknown] Account switching remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Vendor account requirement [unknown] Vendor account requirement remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Provider restrictions [supported] Provider auth is outside settings.yaml; no claim of unlimited subscription usage. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Setup requires tmux, Bash 4+ and at least one authenticated coding CLI.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-08
Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open.
7 atomic answers
First task setup [supported] Clone, first_setup.sh, provider sign-in and launch script; no measured first task. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
No git [unknown] No git remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Local git without remote [unknown] Local git without remote remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Hosted git [unknown] Hosted git remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Prerequisite guidance [supported] Requirements and Windows WSL2 setup are stated. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Managed cloud setup [unknown] Managed cloud setup remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Byo vps onboarding [unknown] Byo vps onboarding remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Edit [unknown] Edit remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Discuss [unknown] Discuss remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Prioritize [supported] SayTask parses dates/priorities for personal tasks; separate from coding dispatch. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Label [unknown] Label remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Assign [unknown] Assign remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Search [unknown] Search remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Filter [unknown] Filter remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Archive [unknown] Archive remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Reopen [unknown] Reopen remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Project epic views [unknown] Project epic views remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Idea parking [unknown] Idea parking remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Explicit dispatch [unknown] Explicit dispatch remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Task session separation [supported] Stable subtask records are assigned to worker panes. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Metadata [unknown] Metadata remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Durable states [supported] YAML task status and dashboard aggregation. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
External tracker requirement [unknown] External tracker requirement remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Karo routes tasks and owns dashboard aggregation; routing is not a verified exclusive work claim.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-08
Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open.
7 atomic answers
Human assignment [unknown] Human assignment remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Agent assignment [supported] Karo assigns tasks to available Ashigaru or Gunshi. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Claims [unknown] Claims remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Queues [unknown] Queues remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Routing [supported] Capability tiers route task complexity to models covered by configured subscriptions. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Duplicate prevention [supported] Separate task/report ownership conventions and mailbox locks; no duplicate-work test. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Ownership enforcement [unknown] Ownership enforcement remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Orchestration owner [supported] Shogun shell scripts and generated role instructions, not provider-native children. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Activation [unknown] Activation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Authentication [unknown] Authentication remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Live progress [supported] Visible tmux panes and status summaries. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Recurring tasks [unknown] Recurring tasks remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Completion conditions [unknown] Completion conditions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Formation and per-agent CLI/model selection are configurable.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-08
Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open.
10 atomic answers
Quick task [unknown] Quick task remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Growing epic [unknown] Growing epic remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Presets [unknown] Presets remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Natural language [supported] Human gives an order to Shogun; Karo decomposes it. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Agent configuration [supported] settings.yaml specifies CLI and model per role. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
In run changes [unknown] In run changes remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Live roles [supported] Named panes identify role/model and current task. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Retained relationships [unknown] Retained relationships remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Discoverability [unknown] Discoverability remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Auth friction [unknown] Auth friction remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
The scoped formation launches separate tmux processes in host directories. It does not create Git worktrees or per-agent containers/VMs. Coding-harness sandbox modes are separate from formation isolation.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-13 (9 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps.
12 atomic answers
Checkout [unknown] Checkout remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Branch [unknown] Branch remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Worktree [unsupported] The inspected formation launcher and script/lib runtime do not provision worktree isolation. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch.
Container [unsupported] The inspected formation launcher and script/lib runtime do not provision container isolation. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch.
Vm [unsupported] The inspected formation launcher and script/lib runtime do not provision vm isolation. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch.
Os sandbox [unknown] Os sandbox remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Filesystem [unknown] Filesystem remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Process [unknown] Process remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Network [unknown] Network remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Secrets [unknown] Secrets remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Code separation [unknown] Code separation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Security boundary [unknown] Security boundary remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Project stats [unknown] Project stats remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Time stats [unknown] Time stats remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Failure status [supported] ntfy failure notices and status checks are documented. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Approval status [unknown] Approval status remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Reconnect consistency [unknown] Reconnect consistency remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Performance method [unknown] Performance method remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Responsiveness [unknown] Responsiveness remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
The scoped formation has a single human Lord workflow and local terminal/SSH or ntfy command input. It supplies no native multi-user workspace, per-human membership or shared-prompting interface.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-13 (9 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps.
11 atomic answers
Visibility [unknown] Visibility remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Discussion [unknown] Discussion remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Comments [unknown] Comments remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Presence [unknown] Presence remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
The scoped formation is operated through the host OS, terminal/SSH and optional ntfy credentials. Agent hierarchy roles are prompts for agents; the formation has no named human workspace roles or enterprise SSO implementation.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-13 (9 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps.
Cross user persistence [unknown] Cross user persistence remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Cross session persistence [unknown] Cross session persistence remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Task reports and artifacts remain in local files. The supplied browser dashboard displays Markdown task/report status, without a proposed-code diff review interface.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps.
13 atomic answers
Diffs [unsupported] The scoped dashboard renders dashboard.md and refresh status, without a code-diff review component. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard.
Documents [supported] dashboard.md and project/context Markdown/YAML. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Screenshots [unknown] Screenshots remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Recordings [unknown] Recordings remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Previews [unknown] Previews remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Test outputs [unknown] Test outputs remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Spec checks [unknown] Spec checks remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Required checks [unknown] Required checks remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Failure blocking [unknown] Failure blocking remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Requirement conflicts [unknown] Requirement conflicts remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Configured policy [supported] Karo reviews plans and makes final E2E judgment. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
Enforced policy [supported] Instructional role policy, not an observed product delivery gate. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:readme.
The formation supplies Git branch-policy and short-lived branch auto-merge helpers. The inspected scripts have no native pull-request creation or management; agent guidance can discuss external PR review.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-13 (9 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps.
Worktrees [unknown] Worktrees remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Commits [unknown] Commits remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Pull requests [unsupported] The supplied branch scripts use Git merge/push without a PR API or PR management interface. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:gap39-branch.
Comments [unknown] Comments remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Ci response [unknown] Ci response remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Rebase [unknown] Rebase remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Conflicts [unknown] Conflicts remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Product state [unknown] Product state remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
The scoped configuration and runtime scripts expose no product telemetry emitter or telemetry-disable setting. Optional ntfy traffic is task notification/command transport; coding-harness privacy and telemetry remain separate.
Scope
Surfaces: Shogun tmux formation · Version: aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-13 (9 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps.
15 atomic answers
Code data [unknown] Code data remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Prompts [unknown] Prompts remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Credentials [unknown] Credentials remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Logs [unknown] Logs remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Artifacts [unknown] Artifacts remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Retention [unknown] Retention remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Deletion [unknown] Deletion remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Training [unknown] Training remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Residency [unknown] Residency remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Subprocessors [unknown] Subprocessors remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Telemetry disclosure [unknown] Telemetry disclosure remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Telemetry defaults [supported] No product telemetry emitter was found in the bounded configuration/lib/scripts inspection. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry.
Telemetry controls [unsupported] No documented product telemetry-disable control is implemented in the inspected configuration and runtime. Sources: multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry.
Consent prompt [unknown] Consent prompt remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Provider separation [unknown] Provider separation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.
Shell/tmux agents coordinate through YAML queues and mailbox events. Shogun delegates to Karo, seven Ashigaru workers and Gunshi strategist. Android app connects over SSH; Windows needs WSL2.
Kind
documented
Locator
Quick Start; What is this; Multi-CLI Support; Mobile Access; Key Features
The supplied Python HTTP server renders dashboard.md in a browser with auto-refresh and a device-width viewport. It is a read-only task/report dashboard; its scoped routes and rendering do not provide proposed-code diff review or prompt submission.
Kind
source-inspected
Locator
HTML_TEMPLATE viewport; do_GET; /api/dashboard and /api/mtime
The latest release v5.1.0 documents Claude Code, Codex, Copilot, Kimi and OpenCode. Antigravity appears in newer main-branch documentation, but was not established in this released snapshot.
The scoped launcher creates detached tmux sessions/panes and starts installed coding CLIs in the host working directory. Inspection of launcher, lib and scripts found no product-created worktrees, per-agent containers or VMs, vendor-runtime provisioner, or human workspace-role/SSO system.
Kind
source-inspected
Locator
tmux creation, working-directory setup and CLI launch; lib/cli_adapter.sh
The product supplies Git branch policy and short-lived branch merge helpers. The inspected scripts do not create or manage pull requests; pull-request review appears as agent prompt guidance, not a product PR integration.