{"schemaVersion":7,"rubricVersion":"0.3","canonicalUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/multi-agent-shogun/","markdownUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/multi-agent-shogun/index.md","dataUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/multi-agent-shogun/data.json","rubricUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/rubric/","generatedAt":"2026-11-22","publisher":{"name":"Podium","url":"https://podium.do","marketParticipant":true,"editorialControl":"Podium selects the products, rubric, sources and wording, including for comparisons that do not include Podium, and may add labeled Podium team research without linked sources.","disclosure":"Podium publishes this catalog and sells an agent development environment. Podium chooses the products, criteria, sources and wording, so treat these pages as vendor-authored research. Check important claims against the linked primary sources. Sourced findings follow the same evidence rules for Podium and its competitors. Facts labeled Podium team research come from Podium's own team and have no linked source. None of this removes the conflict of interest."},"attribution":{"dataSource":{"name":"adecomparison.com by Podium","url":"https://adecomparison.com","repository":"https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison"},"license":{"name":"CC BY 4.0","url":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"dataLicenseUrl":"https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison/blob/4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e/DATA-LICENSE.md","snapshot":{"commit":"4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e","commitDate":"2026-11-22","url":"https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison/tree/4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e"},"podiumTeamLabel":"Podium team research","podiumTeamText":"Podium team research is a fact the Podium team added without a linked source. It is labeled wherever it appears, and any differing adecomparison.com finding stays visible beside it.","statement":"Based on data from adecomparison.com by Podium (https://adecomparison.com; source repository https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison, snapshot 4322f0c of 2026-11-22), used under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Source links and check dates are kept. Podium arranges the findings into pairs, applies its publication checks, and added its own research where marked \"Podium team research\"."},"product":{"id":"multi-agent-shogun","name":"multi-agent-shogun","website":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun","repository":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun","url":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/multi-agent-shogun/","lifecycle":{"status":"unknown","note":null},"sourcedClaimCount":36,"crossCheckedClaimCount":29,"sourcedOnlyClaimCount":7,"podiumTeamClaimCount":0,"oldestCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","lastCheckedAt":"2026-11-13","surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"},{"id":"android","name":"Shogun Android companion","type":"mobile"}]},"criteria":[{"id":"ACC-01","title":"Client access","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:ACC-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Terminal workflow runs on Linux/macOS and WSL2; Android companion monitors and commands the remote formation. A supplied Python browser dashboard renders dashboard.md, including a phone-sized viewport. Windows execution requires WSL2 rather than a native Windows build.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal","android"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"},{"id":"android","name":"Shogun Android companion","type":"mobile"}]},"questions":[{"id":"desktop_os","question":"Desktop os","support":"unknown","answer":"Desktop os remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"mobile_apps","question":"Mobile apps","support":"supported","answer":"Android companion APK via SSH; no iOS app.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"browser","question":"Browser","support":"supported","answer":"The supplied dashboard-viewer.py serves an auto-refreshing read-only browser work dashboard.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard"]},{"id":"mobile_browser","question":"Mobile browser","support":"supported","answer":"The same dashboard declares a device-width viewport and serves the work dashboard over HTTP.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard"]},{"id":"cli","question":"Cli","support":"supported","answer":"Bash scripts and tmux terminal clients.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"editor_extensions","question":"Editor extensions","support":"unknown","answer":"Editor extensions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_actions","question":"Task actions","support":"supported","answer":"Android terminal, agent grid and dashboard can monitor and send commands.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"notifications","question":"Notifications","support":"supported","answer":"ntfy progress notifications and incoming command listener.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"cross_device_continuity","question":"Cross device continuity","support":"unknown","answer":"Cross device continuity remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme","multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard"]}},{"id":"ACC-02","title":"Agent and model choice","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:ACC-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"The v5.1.0 release supports five named coding CLIs in formation roles. Antigravity and Cursor appear in newer main-branch documentation; a released integration was not established.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e Antigravity source pass: v5.1.0 (bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919).","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"harnesses","question":"Harnesses","support":"supported","answer":"The v5.1.0 release supports Claude Code, Codex, Copilot, Kimi Code and OpenCode. Released Antigravity and Cursor support is unknown; their documented integrations occur on a later main revision.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:agy-release-1"]},{"id":"model_providers","question":"Model providers","support":"unknown","answer":"Model providers remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"custom_adapters","question":"Custom adapters","support":"unknown","answer":"Custom adapters remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"session_integration","question":"Session integration","support":"supported","answer":"Independent CLI instances in tmux panes; shared templates generate role-specific instructions.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"mixed_harness_operation","question":"Mixed harness operation","support":"unknown","answer":"Per-agent settings select different CLIs and models; not observed in this pass.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open.","Antigravity and Cursor are main-branch additions in the checked documentation; their released harness support remains unknown."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-10","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme","multi-agent-shogun:agy-release-1"]}},{"id":"ACC-03","title":"Subscriptions, API keys and vendor credits","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:ACC-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"CLI subscriptions are an explicit billing route; provider credentials stay with the CLI.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"agent_subscriptions","question":"Agent subscriptions","support":"supported","answer":"README discusses flat-rate coding-agent subscriptions and cost_group plan routing.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"api_accounts","question":"Api accounts","support":"supported","answer":"OpenCode may use provider API keys configured in its own account.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"vendor_credits","question":"Vendor credits","support":"unknown","answer":"Vendor credits remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"local_models","question":"Local models","support":"unknown","answer":"Local models remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"account_switching","question":"Account switching","support":"unknown","answer":"Account switching remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"vendor_account_requirement","question":"Vendor account requirement","support":"unknown","answer":"Vendor account requirement remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"provider_restrictions","question":"Provider restrictions","support":"supported","answer":"Provider auth is outside settings.yaml; no claim of unlimited subscription usage.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"ACC-04","title":"Onboarding and project prerequisites","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:ACC-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Setup requires tmux, Bash 4+ and at least one authenticated coding CLI.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"first_task_setup","question":"First task setup","support":"supported","answer":"Clone, first_setup.sh, provider sign-in and launch script; no measured first task.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"no_git","question":"No git","support":"unknown","answer":"No git remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"local_git_without_remote","question":"Local git without remote","support":"unknown","answer":"Local git without remote remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"hosted_git","question":"Hosted git","support":"unknown","answer":"Hosted git remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"prerequisite_guidance","question":"Prerequisite guidance","support":"supported","answer":"Requirements and Windows WSL2 setup are stated.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"managed_cloud_setup","question":"Managed cloud setup","support":"unknown","answer":"Managed cloud setup remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"byo_vps_onboarding","question":"Byo vps onboarding","support":"unknown","answer":"Byo vps onboarding remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"ACC-05","title":"Programmable access","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:ACC-05","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Shell scripts and YAML files expose formation control and status.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"cli","question":"Cli","support":"supported","answer":"Startup script, agent status script and mailbox tools.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"api","question":"Api","support":"unknown","answer":"Api remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"sdk","question":"Sdk","support":"unknown","answer":"Sdk remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"mcp_server","question":"Mcp server","support":"unknown","answer":"Mcp server remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"webhooks","question":"Webhooks","support":"unknown","answer":"Webhooks remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"operations","question":"Operations","support":"supported","answer":"Launch formation, inspect panes/status and send YAML mailbox messages.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"authentication","question":"Authentication","support":"supported","answer":"Provider CLI login and SSH for phone access.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"stability","question":"Stability","support":"unknown","answer":"Stability remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"ACC-06","title":"External tools and extensions","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:ACC-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Memory MCP and generated instruction files extend the formation.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"mcp_client","question":"Mcp client","support":"supported","answer":"Memory MCP through the coding-agent configuration.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"plugins","question":"Plugins","support":"supported","answer":"Workers propose reusable skills for human approval.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"custom_tools","question":"Custom tools","support":"unknown","answer":"Custom tools remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"instructions_import","question":"Instructions import","support":"supported","answer":"Shared templates build CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md, Copilot and Cursor instructions.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"authentication","question":"Authentication","support":"unknown","answer":"Authentication remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"permission_scope","question":"Permission scope","support":"unknown","answer":"Permission scope remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"integration_owner","question":"Integration owner","support":"supported","answer":"Coding CLI executes external tools; formation scripts configure instructions.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"ACC-07","title":"Client implementation","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:ACC-07","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"PLAN-01","title":"Intake and external tracker relationship","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:PLAN-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Human commands become local YAML queue records and dashboard summaries.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"local_creation","question":"Local creation","support":"unknown","answer":"Local creation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"prompt_intake","question":"Prompt intake","support":"supported","answer":"Natural-language command to Shogun pane.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"external_import","question":"External import","support":"unknown","answer":"External import remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"chat_git_triggers","question":"Chat git triggers","support":"unknown","answer":"Chat git triggers remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"authoritative_tracker","question":"Authoritative tracker","support":"supported","answer":"Local YAML task/command/report files.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"stable_ids","question":"Stable ids","support":"supported","answer":"cmd and subtask identifiers appear in queue files and dashboard.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"sync","question":"Sync","support":"unknown","answer":"Sync remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"supported_edits","question":"Supported edits","support":"unknown","answer":"Supported edits remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"external_roundtrips","question":"External roundtrips","support":"unknown","answer":"External roundtrips remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"PLAN-02","title":"Durable task plans","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:PLAN-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Tasks and reports are structured local files; plan revision guarantees remain untested.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"plans","question":"Plans","support":"supported","answer":"Karo breaks orders into YAML tasks and aggregates reports.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"acceptance_criteria","question":"Acceptance criteria","support":"unknown","answer":"Acceptance criteria remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"editors","question":"Editors","support":"unknown","answer":"Editors remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"revisions","question":"Revisions","support":"unknown","answer":"Revisions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"implementation_links","question":"Implementation links","support":"unknown","answer":"Implementation links remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"amendment","question":"Amendment","support":"unknown","answer":"Amendment remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"restart_persistence","question":"Restart persistence","support":"supported","answer":"Task/report files survive process restarts.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"PLAN-03","title":"Hierarchy, dependencies and evolving scope","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:PLAN-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Task blockedBy dependencies and role hierarchy are documented.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"epics","question":"Epics","support":"unknown","answer":"Epics remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"hierarchy","question":"Hierarchy","support":"supported","answer":"Shogun > Karo > workers, with Gunshi strategist.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"blockers","question":"Blockers","support":"supported","answer":"Tasks list blockedBy subtask IDs.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"readiness","question":"Readiness","support":"supported","answer":"Karo unblocks and assigns tasks after dependencies complete.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"enforcement","question":"Enforcement","support":"supported","answer":"Documented behavior, not a tested dispatch guarantee.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"state_propagation","question":"State propagation","support":"unknown","answer":"State propagation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_to_epic","question":"Task to epic","support":"unknown","answer":"Task to epic remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"identity_retention","question":"Identity retention","support":"unknown","answer":"Identity retention remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"workflow_constraints","question":"Workflow constraints","support":"unknown","answer":"Workflow constraints remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"PLAN-04","title":"Shared context and memory","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:PLAN-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Layered file context and Memory MCP persist across clear/new sessions.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"instructions","question":"Instructions","support":"supported","answer":"Shared role instructions generated per CLI.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"skills","question":"Skills","support":"unknown","answer":"Skills remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"project_docs","question":"Project docs","support":"supported","answer":"Project context files and progress reports.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"memory","question":"Memory","support":"supported","answer":"Memory MCP stores user preferences.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"scope","question":"Scope","support":"supported","answer":"Four-layer file/context structure; live session context can be cleared.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"provenance","question":"Provenance","support":"unknown","answer":"Provenance remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"correction","question":"Correction","support":"unknown","answer":"Correction remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"deletion","question":"Deletion","support":"unknown","answer":"Deletion remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"freshness","question":"Freshness","support":"supported","answer":"File layers are reread after session clear.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"takeover_continuity","question":"Takeover continuity","support":"unknown","answer":"Takeover continuity remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"PLAN-05","title":"Architecture and API awareness","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:PLAN-05","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"PLAN-06","title":"Native issue management and idea backlog","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:PLAN-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Native YAML tasks persist separately from CLI sessions; UI is terminal/Markdown rather than a rich tracker.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"create","question":"Create","support":"supported","answer":"Shogun/Karo generate local tasks.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"edit","question":"Edit","support":"unknown","answer":"Edit remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"discuss","question":"Discuss","support":"unknown","answer":"Discuss remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"prioritize","question":"Prioritize","support":"supported","answer":"SayTask parses dates/priorities for personal tasks; separate from coding dispatch.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"label","question":"Label","support":"unknown","answer":"Label remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"assign","question":"Assign","support":"unknown","answer":"Assign remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"search","question":"Search","support":"unknown","answer":"Search remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"filter","question":"Filter","support":"unknown","answer":"Filter remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"archive","question":"Archive","support":"unknown","answer":"Archive remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"reopen","question":"Reopen","support":"unknown","answer":"Reopen remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"project_epic_views","question":"Project epic views","support":"unknown","answer":"Project epic views remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"idea_parking","question":"Idea parking","support":"unknown","answer":"Idea parking remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"explicit_dispatch","question":"Explicit dispatch","support":"unknown","answer":"Explicit dispatch remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_session_separation","question":"Task session separation","support":"supported","answer":"Stable subtask records are assigned to worker panes.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"metadata","question":"Metadata","support":"unknown","answer":"Metadata remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"durable_states","question":"Durable states","support":"supported","answer":"YAML task status and dashboard aggregation.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"external_tracker_requirement","question":"External tracker requirement","support":"unknown","answer":"External tracker requirement remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"PLAN-07","title":"Agent-native issue operations","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:PLAN-07","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Agents write shared YAML task and report records, with serialized mailbox writes.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"shared_ids","question":"Shared ids","support":"unknown","answer":"Shared ids remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"read","question":"Read","support":"supported","answer":"Agents inspect queue/task/report files.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"create","question":"Create","support":"supported","answer":"Karo creates worker tasks.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"update","question":"Update","support":"supported","answer":"Workers write their own reports and task state.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"claim","question":"Claim","support":"unknown","answer":"Claim remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"assign","question":"Assign","support":"unknown","answer":"Assign remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"state_changes","question":"State changes","support":"unknown","answer":"State changes remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"dependencies","question":"Dependencies","support":"unknown","answer":"Dependencies remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"children","question":"Children","support":"unknown","answer":"Children remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"results","question":"Results","support":"unknown","answer":"Results remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"human_visibility","question":"Human visibility","support":"supported","answer":"dashboard.md and YAML are directly inspectable.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"attribution","question":"Attribution","support":"unknown","answer":"Attribution remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"permissions","question":"Permissions","support":"unknown","answer":"Permissions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"conflicts","question":"Conflicts","support":"supported","answer":"Mailbox writes use flock; dashboard has a single Karo writer.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"PLAN-08","title":"Living product specifications","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:PLAN-08","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"COORD-01","title":"Parallel work","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:COORD-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Multiple independent coding CLIs work concurrently in visible tmux panes.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"concurrent_sessions","question":"Concurrent sessions","support":"supported","answer":"Formation includes seven workers, strategist and coordinating roles.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"concurrent_tasks","question":"Concurrent tasks","support":"unknown","answer":"Concurrent tasks remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"quotas","question":"Quotas","support":"unknown","answer":"Quotas remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"observed_concurrency","question":"Observed concurrency","support":"unknown","answer":"Observed concurrency remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"status_visibility","question":"Status visibility","support":"supported","answer":"Live panes, status command and dashboard show progress.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"COORD-02","title":"Ownership and dispatch","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:COORD-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Karo routes tasks and owns dashboard aggregation; routing is not a verified exclusive work claim.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"human_assignment","question":"Human assignment","support":"unknown","answer":"Human assignment remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"agent_assignment","question":"Agent assignment","support":"supported","answer":"Karo assigns tasks to available Ashigaru or Gunshi.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"claims","question":"Claims","support":"unknown","answer":"Claims remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"queues","question":"Queues","support":"unknown","answer":"Queues remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"routing","question":"Routing","support":"supported","answer":"Capability tiers route task complexity to models covered by configured subscriptions.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"duplicate_prevention","question":"Duplicate prevention","support":"supported","answer":"Separate task/report ownership conventions and mailbox locks; no duplicate-work test.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"ownership_enforcement","question":"Ownership enforcement","support":"unknown","answer":"Ownership enforcement remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"COORD-03","title":"Inspectable delegation and communication","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:COORD-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Product scripts and role instructions coordinate independent CLIs through durable YAML mailboxes.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"roles","question":"Roles","support":"supported","answer":"Shogun, Karo, Ashigaru and Gunshi.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"model_harness_effort","question":"Model harness effort","support":"unknown","answer":"Model harness effort remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"messages","question":"Messages","support":"supported","answer":"YAML mailbox with inotify events and short tmux nudges.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"results_return","question":"Results return","support":"supported","answer":"Reports aggregate in dashboard.md.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"cross_harness","question":"Cross harness","support":"supported","answer":"Configured per-role coding CLIs.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"orchestration_owner","question":"Orchestration owner","support":"supported","answer":"Shogun shell scripts and generated role instructions, not provider-native children.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"activation","question":"Activation","support":"unknown","answer":"Activation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"authentication","question":"Authentication","support":"unknown","answer":"Authentication remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"live_progress","question":"Live progress","support":"supported","answer":"Visible tmux panes and status summaries.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"retained_results","question":"Retained results","support":"supported","answer":"Task/report YAML survives restarts.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"followup","question":"Followup","support":"unknown","answer":"Followup remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"invocation","question":"Invocation","support":"unknown","answer":"Invocation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"COORD-04","title":"Unattended triggers","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:COORD-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Incoming ntfy commands can trigger agent work through a background listener.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"schedules","question":"Schedules","support":"unknown","answer":"Schedules remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"events","question":"Events","support":"supported","answer":"Phone-to-Shogun ntfy command listener.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"recurring_tasks","question":"Recurring tasks","support":"unknown","answer":"Recurring tasks remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"completion_conditions","question":"Completion conditions","support":"unknown","answer":"Completion conditions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"scheduler_location","question":"Scheduler location","support":"supported","answer":"User-run background listener on formation host.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"overlaps","question":"Overlaps","support":"unknown","answer":"Overlaps remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retries","question":"Retries","support":"unknown","answer":"Retries remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"client_independence","question":"Client independence","support":"unknown","answer":"Client independence remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"COORD-05","title":"Intervention and attention","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:COORD-05","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Human commands and phone notifications support intervention; a pause/resume fixture was not run.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"pause","question":"Pause","support":"unknown","answer":"Pause remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"stop","question":"Stop","support":"unknown","answer":"Stop remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"resume","question":"Resume","support":"unknown","answer":"Resume remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"steer","question":"Steer","support":"supported","answer":"Send another order while workers run.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"notifications","question":"Notifications","support":"supported","answer":"Karo sends progress/failure updates through ntfy.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"pending_decisions","question":"Pending decisions","support":"unknown","answer":"Pending decisions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"escalation","question":"Escalation","support":"unknown","answer":"Escalation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"visible_errors","question":"Visible errors","support":"supported","answer":"Status checks show task/inbox state.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"chat_terminal_parity","question":"Chat terminal parity","support":"unknown","answer":"Chat terminal parity remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retained_history","question":"Retained history","support":"unknown","answer":"Retained history remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"COORD-06","title":"Fleet and epic management UI","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:COORD-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Live panes, Markdown dashboard and Android grid show formation work.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"fleet_fixture","question":"Fleet fixture","support":"unknown","answer":"Fleet fixture remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"parent_child","question":"Parent child","support":"supported","answer":"Fixed role hierarchy.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"dependencies","question":"Dependencies","support":"unknown","answer":"Dependencies remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"attention","question":"Attention","support":"supported","answer":"Dashboard progress and ntfy notifications.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"history","question":"History","support":"supported","answer":"Task/report YAML readable after work.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"workload","question":"Workload","support":"supported","answer":"Agent grid and task summaries.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"navigation_errors","question":"Navigation errors","support":"unknown","answer":"Navigation errors remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"fixture_mode","question":"Fixture mode","support":"unknown","answer":"Fixture mode remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"COORD-07","title":"Workflow flexibility and orchestration visibility","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:COORD-07","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Formation and per-agent CLI/model selection are configurable.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"quick_task","question":"Quick task","support":"unknown","answer":"Quick task remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"growing_epic","question":"Growing epic","support":"unknown","answer":"Growing epic remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"presets","question":"Presets","support":"unknown","answer":"Presets remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"natural_language","question":"Natural language","support":"supported","answer":"Human gives an order to Shogun; Karo decomposes it.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"agent_configuration","question":"Agent configuration","support":"supported","answer":"settings.yaml specifies CLI and model per role.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"in_run_changes","question":"In run changes","support":"unknown","answer":"In run changes remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"live_roles","question":"Live roles","support":"supported","answer":"Named panes identify role/model and current task.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"retained_relationships","question":"Retained relationships","support":"unknown","answer":"Retained relationships remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"discoverability","question":"Discoverability","support":"unknown","answer":"Discoverability remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"auth_friction","question":"Auth friction","support":"unknown","answer":"Auth friction remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"RUN-01","title":"Laptop-independent execution","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:RUN-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Formation runs on a user host; Android reaches a Linux/WSL server over SSH.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal","android"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"},{"id":"android","name":"Shogun Android companion","type":"mobile"}]},"questions":[{"id":"local","question":"Local","support":"supported","answer":"tmux and agent CLIs run on local host.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"byo_remote","question":"Byo remote","support":"supported","answer":"Android prerequisites explicitly include a Linux server with SSH.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"self_hosted","question":"Self hosted","support":"unknown","answer":"Self hosted remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"managed_cloud","question":"Managed cloud","support":"unknown","answer":"Managed cloud remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"hybrid","question":"Hybrid","support":"unknown","answer":"Hybrid remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"provisioning","question":"Provisioning","support":"unknown","answer":"Provisioning remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"payer","question":"Payer","support":"unknown","answer":"Payer remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"resources","question":"Resources","support":"unknown","answer":"Resources remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"region","question":"Region","support":"unknown","answer":"Region remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"expiry","question":"Expiry","support":"unknown","answer":"Expiry remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"client_disconnect","question":"Client disconnect","support":"unknown","answer":"Client disconnect remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"other_device_continuation","question":"Other device continuation","support":"supported","answer":"Phone monitors and commands server tmux sessions.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"RUN-02","title":"Workspace and process isolation","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:RUN-02","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The scoped formation launches separate tmux processes in host directories. It does not create Git worktrees or per-agent containers/VMs. Coding-harness sandbox modes are separate from formation isolation.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"checkout","question":"Checkout","support":"unknown","answer":"Checkout remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"branch","question":"Branch","support":"unknown","answer":"Branch remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"worktree","question":"Worktree","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected formation launcher and script/lib runtime do not provision worktree isolation.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch"]},{"id":"container","question":"Container","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected formation launcher and script/lib runtime do not provision container isolation.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch"]},{"id":"vm","question":"Vm","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected formation launcher and script/lib runtime do not provision vm isolation.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch"]},{"id":"os_sandbox","question":"Os sandbox","support":"unknown","answer":"Os sandbox remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"filesystem","question":"Filesystem","support":"unknown","answer":"Filesystem remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"process","question":"Process","support":"unknown","answer":"Process remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"network","question":"Network","support":"unknown","answer":"Network remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"secrets","question":"Secrets","support":"unknown","answer":"Secrets remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"code_separation","question":"Code separation","support":"unknown","answer":"Code separation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"security_boundary","question":"Security boundary","support":"unknown","answer":"Security boundary remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch"]}},{"id":"RUN-03","title":"Recovery, expiry and continuity","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:RUN-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Task/mailbox/context files persist independently of agent session memory.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"client_disconnect","question":"Client disconnect","support":"unknown","answer":"Client disconnect remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"worker_crash","question":"Worker crash","support":"unknown","answer":"Mailbox messages persist as files; successful worker recovery not tested.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"service_restart","question":"Service restart","support":"unknown","answer":"Service restart remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"expiry","question":"Expiry","support":"unknown","answer":"Expiry remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"transcript_reload","question":"Transcript reload","support":"unknown","answer":"Transcript reload remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"process_reconnect","question":"Process reconnect","support":"unknown","answer":"Process reconnect remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_resume","question":"Task resume","support":"unknown","answer":"Task resume remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"state_reconstruction","question":"State reconstruction","support":"supported","answer":"Layered context files can be reloaded after /clear.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"context_loss","question":"Context loss","support":"supported","answer":"Live session context clears; persistent file layers remain.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"duplicate_actions","question":"Duplicate actions","support":"unknown","answer":"Duplicate actions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"manual_repair","question":"Manual repair","support":"unknown","answer":"Manual repair remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"multi_day_continuity","question":"Multi day continuity","support":"unknown","answer":"Multi day continuity remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"RUN-04","title":"Development environment reliability","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:RUN-04","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"RUN-05","title":"Limits and failure handling","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:RUN-05","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"RUN-06","title":"Truthful status and operational statistics","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:RUN-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Status script and dashboard expose worker, task and inbox state.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"logs","question":"Logs","support":"supported","answer":"Visible CLI panes and report YAML.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"traces","question":"Traces","support":"unknown","answer":"Traces remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"failure_reasons","question":"Failure reasons","support":"unknown","answer":"Failure reasons remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"usage_export","question":"Usage export","support":"unknown","answer":"Usage export remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_stats","question":"Task stats","support":"supported","answer":"Task state in dashboard.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"agent_stats","question":"Agent stats","support":"supported","answer":"Agent identity/model/current task in pane borders.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"project_stats","question":"Project stats","support":"unknown","answer":"Project stats remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"time_stats","question":"Time stats","support":"unknown","answer":"Time stats remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"failure_status","question":"Failure status","support":"supported","answer":"ntfy failure notices and status checks are documented.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"approval_status","question":"Approval status","support":"unknown","answer":"Approval status remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"reconnect_consistency","question":"Reconnect consistency","support":"unknown","answer":"Reconnect consistency remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"performance_method","question":"Performance method","support":"unknown","answer":"Performance method remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"responsiveness","question":"Responsiveness","support":"unknown","answer":"Responsiveness remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"RUN-07","title":"Per-task API and compute cost","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:RUN-07","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"RUN-08","title":"Compute-aware scheduling and verification","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:RUN-08","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"TEAM-01","title":"Live human collaboration","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:TEAM-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The scoped formation has a single human Lord workflow and local terminal/SSH or ntfy command input. It supplies no native multi-user workspace, per-human membership or shared-prompting interface.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"visibility","question":"Visibility","support":"unknown","answer":"Visibility remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"discussion","question":"Discussion","support":"unknown","answer":"Discussion remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"comments","question":"Comments","support":"unknown","answer":"Comments remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"presence","question":"Presence","support":"unknown","answer":"Presence remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"coprompting","question":"Coprompting","support":"unknown","answer":"The launcher/dashboard/communication paths provide a single operator identity or external OS/ntfy access; distinct human shared prompting is not established.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch","multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard"]},{"id":"ordering","question":"Ordering","support":"unknown","answer":"Ordering remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"conflicts","question":"Conflicts","support":"unknown","answer":"Conflicts remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"attribution","question":"Attribution","support":"unknown","answer":"Attribution remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"permissions","question":"Permissions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No per-person workspace membership/role system is implemented.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch"]},{"id":"plan_restrictions","question":"Plan restrictions","support":"unknown","answer":"Plan restrictions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"owner_online","question":"Owner online","support":"unknown","answer":"Owner online remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch","multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard"]}},{"id":"TEAM-02","title":"Roles and access boundaries","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:TEAM-02","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The scoped formation is operated through the host OS, terminal/SSH and optional ntfy credentials. Agent hierarchy roles are prompts for agents; the formation has no named human workspace roles or enterprise SSO implementation.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"organization_roles","question":"Organization roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No human organization roles system is implemented in the scoped launcher, configuration or communication scripts.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch","multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry"]},{"id":"project_roles","question":"Project roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No human project roles system is implemented in the scoped launcher, configuration or communication scripts.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch","multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry"]},{"id":"task_roles","question":"Task roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No human task roles system is implemented in the scoped launcher, configuration or communication scripts.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch","multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry"]},{"id":"membership","question":"Membership","support":"unknown","answer":"Membership remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"sso","question":"Sso","support":"unsupported","answer":"No human sso system is implemented in the scoped launcher, configuration or communication scripts.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch","multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry"]},{"id":"provisioning","question":"Provisioning","support":"unknown","answer":"Provisioning remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"unauthorized_access","question":"Unauthorized access","support":"unknown","answer":"Unauthorized access remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"revocation","question":"Revocation","support":"unknown","answer":"Revocation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"plan_scope","question":"Plan scope","support":"unknown","answer":"Plan scope remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch","multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry"]}},{"id":"TEAM-03","title":"Approvals and temporary access","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:TEAM-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Quick start explicitly launches Claude in bypass-permissions mode; role files are not a complete security sandbox.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"command","question":"Command","support":"unknown","answer":"Command remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"tool","question":"Tool","support":"unknown","answer":"Tool remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"network","question":"Network","support":"unknown","answer":"Network remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"secret","question":"Secret","support":"unknown","answer":"Secret remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"delivery","question":"Delivery","support":"unknown","answer":"Delivery remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"approver_identity","question":"Approver identity","support":"unknown","answer":"Approver identity remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"lifetime","question":"Lifetime","support":"unknown","answer":"Lifetime remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"allow","question":"Allow","support":"unknown","answer":"Allow remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"deny","question":"Deny","support":"unknown","answer":"Deny remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"revoke","question":"Revoke","support":"unknown","answer":"Revoke remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"tunnels","question":"Tunnels","support":"unknown","answer":"Tunnels remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"defaults","question":"Defaults","support":"supported","answer":"claude --dangerously-skip-permissions during first-run setup.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"safer_modes","question":"Safer modes","support":"supported","answer":"Some generated OpenCode roles restrict file tools; no uniform security guarantee across CLIs.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"enforcement","question":"Enforcement","support":"unknown","answer":"Enforcement remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"TEAM-04","title":"Decision and activity history","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:TEAM-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Instructions and reports remain plain files available for inspection and Git history.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"actions","question":"Actions","support":"supported","answer":"Task/command/report YAML.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"approvals","question":"Approvals","support":"unknown","answer":"Approvals remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"edits","question":"Edits","support":"unknown","answer":"Edits remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"discussion","question":"Discussion","support":"unknown","answer":"Discussion remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"decisions","question":"Decisions","support":"supported","answer":"Role reports and dashboard summaries.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"cross_user_persistence","question":"Cross user persistence","support":"unknown","answer":"Cross user persistence remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"cross_session_persistence","question":"Cross session persistence","support":"unknown","answer":"Cross session persistence remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"export","question":"Export","support":"supported","answer":"Standard Markdown/YAML files.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"mutability","question":"Mutability","support":"unknown","answer":"Mutability remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retention","question":"Retention","support":"unknown","answer":"Retention remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"integrity","question":"Integrity","support":"supported","answer":"No tamper-resistant audit model established.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"TEAM-05","title":"Review experience and guidance","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:TEAM-05","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"TEAM-06","title":"Colleague takeover and continuity","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:TEAM-06","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"SHIP-01","title":"Retained artifacts and outputs","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:SHIP-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Task reports and artifacts remain in local files. The supplied browser dashboard displays Markdown task/report status, without a proposed-code diff review interface.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"diffs","question":"Diffs","support":"unsupported","answer":"The scoped dashboard renders dashboard.md and refresh status, without a code-diff review component.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard"]},{"id":"documents","question":"Documents","support":"supported","answer":"dashboard.md and project/context Markdown/YAML.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"screenshots","question":"Screenshots","support":"unknown","answer":"Screenshots remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"recordings","question":"Recordings","support":"unknown","answer":"Recordings remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"previews","question":"Previews","support":"unknown","answer":"Previews remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"test_outputs","question":"Test outputs","support":"unknown","answer":"Test outputs remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"reviewer_outputs","question":"Reviewer outputs","support":"supported","answer":"Gunshi review and worker reports.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"gallery","question":"Gallery","support":"unknown","answer":"Gallery remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_links","question":"Task links","support":"unknown","answer":"Task links remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"revision_links","question":"Revision links","support":"unknown","answer":"Revision links remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"persistence","question":"Persistence","support":"supported","answer":"File records survive session clear/restarts.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"child_findings","question":"Child findings","support":"unknown","answer":"Child findings remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"prompt_leakage","question":"Prompt leakage","support":"unknown","answer":"Prompt leakage remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme","multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard"]}},{"id":"SHIP-02","title":"Verification and spec gates","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:SHIP-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Role guidance routes quality review to Gunshi and final judgment to Karo.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"tests","question":"Tests","support":"unknown","answer":"Tests remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"lint","question":"Lint","support":"unknown","answer":"Lint remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"types","question":"Types","support":"unknown","answer":"Types remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"ci","question":"Ci","support":"unknown","answer":"Ci remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"independent_review","question":"Independent review","support":"supported","answer":"Gunshi handles quality/evidence review and deploy blocker classification.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"spec_checks","question":"Spec checks","support":"unknown","answer":"Spec checks remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"required_checks","question":"Required checks","support":"unknown","answer":"Required checks remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"failure_blocking","question":"Failure blocking","support":"unknown","answer":"Failure blocking remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"requirement_conflicts","question":"Requirement conflicts","support":"unknown","answer":"Requirement conflicts remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"configured_policy","question":"Configured policy","support":"supported","answer":"Karo reviews plans and makes final E2E judgment.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"enforced_policy","question":"Enforced policy","support":"supported","answer":"Instructional role policy, not an observed product delivery gate.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"SHIP-03","title":"Git and pull request workflow","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:SHIP-03","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The formation supplies Git branch-policy and short-lived branch auto-merge helpers. The inspected scripts have no native pull-request creation or management; agent guidance can discuss external PR review.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"branches","question":"Branches","support":"supported","answer":"Branch policy lists monitored repositories and allowed long-lived branches.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-branch"]},{"id":"worktrees","question":"Worktrees","support":"unknown","answer":"Worktrees remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"commits","question":"Commits","support":"unknown","answer":"Commits remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"pull_requests","question":"Pull requests","support":"unsupported","answer":"The supplied branch scripts use Git merge/push without a PR API or PR management interface.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-branch"]},{"id":"comments","question":"Comments","support":"unknown","answer":"Comments remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"ci_response","question":"Ci response","support":"unknown","answer":"Ci response remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"rebase","question":"Rebase","support":"unknown","answer":"Rebase remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"conflicts","question":"Conflicts","support":"unknown","answer":"Conflicts remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"product_state","question":"Product state","support":"unknown","answer":"Product state remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-branch"]}},{"id":"SHIP-04","title":"Merge and deployment authority","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:SHIP-04","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"SHIP-05","title":"Completion evidence and rollback","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:SHIP-05","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"SHIP-06","title":"Batch review and high-volume shipping","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:SHIP-06","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"OWN-01","title":"Source and license","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:OWN-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Repository source is MIT licensed.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"client_license","question":"Client license","support":"supported","answer":"MIT.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:license"]},{"id":"server_license","question":"Server license","support":"unknown","answer":"Server license remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"hosted_extensions","question":"Hosted extensions","support":"unknown","answer":"Hosted extensions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"source_visibility","question":"Source visibility","support":"supported","answer":"Public source.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:license"]},{"id":"source_revision","question":"Source revision","support":"supported","answer":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:license"]},{"id":"hosted_parity","question":"Hosted parity","support":"unknown","answer":"Hosted parity remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:license"]}},{"id":"OWN-02","title":"Hosting and exit","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:OWN-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Shell/tmux formation and Android SSH companion run on user-controlled infrastructure.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"self_hosting","question":"Self hosting","support":"supported","answer":"Clone/run on Linux/macOS/WSL2 or Linux server.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"vendor_dependencies","question":"Vendor dependencies","support":"supported","answer":"Model-provider account and optional ntfy/Google speech services are separate.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"export","question":"Export","support":"unknown","answer":"Export remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"import","question":"Import","support":"unknown","answer":"Import remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"formats","question":"Formats","support":"supported","answer":"Tasks/reports in YAML and Markdown.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"cancellation","question":"Cancellation","support":"unknown","answer":"Cancellation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"account_independence","question":"Account independence","support":"unknown","answer":"Account independence remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"history_portability","question":"History portability","support":"unknown","answer":"History portability remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"OWN-03","title":"Data handling and telemetry","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:OWN-03","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The scoped configuration and runtime scripts expose no product telemetry emitter or telemetry-disable setting. Optional ntfy traffic is task notification/command transport; coding-harness privacy and telemetry remain separate.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"code_data","question":"Code data","support":"unknown","answer":"Code data remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"prompts","question":"Prompts","support":"unknown","answer":"Prompts remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"credentials","question":"Credentials","support":"unknown","answer":"Credentials remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"logs","question":"Logs","support":"unknown","answer":"Logs remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"artifacts","question":"Artifacts","support":"unknown","answer":"Artifacts remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retention","question":"Retention","support":"unknown","answer":"Retention remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"deletion","question":"Deletion","support":"unknown","answer":"Deletion remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"training","question":"Training","support":"unknown","answer":"Training remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"residency","question":"Residency","support":"unknown","answer":"Residency remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"subprocessors","question":"Subprocessors","support":"unknown","answer":"Subprocessors remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"telemetry_disclosure","question":"Telemetry disclosure","support":"unknown","answer":"Telemetry disclosure remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"telemetry_defaults","question":"Telemetry defaults","support":"supported","answer":"No product telemetry emitter was found in the bounded configuration/lib/scripts inspection.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry"]},{"id":"telemetry_controls","question":"Telemetry controls","support":"unsupported","answer":"No documented product telemetry-disable control is implemented in the inspected configuration and runtime.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry"]},{"id":"consent_prompt","question":"Consent prompt","support":"unknown","answer":"Consent prompt remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"provider_separation","question":"Provider separation","support":"unknown","answer":"Provider separation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Only the named atomic answers are established by this source pass. Remaining atomic answers retain their documented gaps."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry"]}},{"id":"OWN-04","title":"Price and included usage","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:OWN-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Software is free; existing coding-agent subscriptions/API usage and compute remain separate.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"currency","question":"Currency","support":"unknown","answer":"Currency remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"interval","question":"Interval","support":"unknown","answer":"Interval remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"seats","question":"Seats","support":"unknown","answer":"Seats remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"seat_minimum","question":"Seat minimum","support":"unknown","answer":"Seat minimum remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"workspace_fees","question":"Workspace fees","support":"unknown","answer":"Workspace fees remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"included_usage","question":"Included usage","support":"supported","answer":"Free open-source formation and companion.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"credits","question":"Credits","support":"unknown","answer":"Credits remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"trial","question":"Trial","support":"unknown","answer":"Trial remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"overages","question":"Overages","support":"unknown","answer":"Overages remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"taxes","question":"Taxes","support":"unknown","answer":"Taxes remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"model_cost","question":"Model cost","support":"supported","answer":"Coding-agent subscription or API charges remain external.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"compute_cost","question":"Compute cost","support":"supported","answer":"User host/remote server.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"OWN-05","title":"Scenario cost and controls","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:OWN-05","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"OWN-06","title":"Availability and support","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:OWN-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Author names a successor but explicitly says this project continues to work as-is.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"release_stage","question":"Release stage","support":"unknown","answer":"Release stage remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"access_restrictions","question":"Access restrictions","support":"unknown","answer":"Access restrictions remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"support","question":"Support","support":"supported","answer":"Public GitHub issues; no response commitment established.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme","multi-agent-shogun:release"]},{"id":"response_commitments","question":"Response commitments","support":"unknown","answer":"Response commitments remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"release_activity","question":"Release activity","support":"supported","answer":"v5.1.0 released 2026-05-23; pinned branch commit 2026-08-06.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme","multi-agent-shogun:release"]},{"id":"status_history","question":"Status history","support":"unknown","answer":"Status history remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"deprecation","question":"Deprecation","support":"supported","answer":"August successor note does not announce a shutdown or exact end date.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme","multi-agent-shogun:release"]},{"id":"export_options","question":"Export options","support":"unknown","answer":"Export options remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme","multi-agent-shogun:release"]}},{"id":"OWN-07","title":"Enterprise assurance","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:OWN-07","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"OWN-08","title":"Useful free tier and evaluation access","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:OWN-08","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Free source and Android companion support local evaluation; agent accounts are separate.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Shogun tmux formation","type":"terminal"}]},"questions":[{"id":"ongoing_free","question":"Ongoing free","support":"supported","answer":"README explicitly says everything is free and open source.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"trial","question":"Trial","support":"unknown","answer":"Trial remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"credits_trial","question":"Credits trial","support":"unknown","answer":"Credits trial remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"self_host_cost","question":"Self host cost","support":"supported","answer":"User machine/server and coding-agent costs remain separate.","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]},{"id":"paid_only","question":"Paid only","support":"unknown","answer":"Paid only remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"early_access","question":"Early access","support":"unknown","answer":"Early access remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"free_scenarios","question":"Free scenarios","support":"unknown","answer":"Free scenarios remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"card_required","question":"Card required","support":"unknown","answer":"Card required remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"usage_caps","question":"Usage caps","support":"unknown","answer":"Usage caps remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"paid_evaluation","question":"Paid evaluation","support":"unknown","answer":"Paid evaluation remains unknown after the first-party source pass; no direct statement or bounded test was found.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation establishes only the named facts. Unknown atomic questions and unrun scenarios remain open."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["multi-agent-shogun:readme"]}},{"id":"OWN-09","title":"Pricing transparency","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"multi-agent-shogun","claimId":"multi-agent-shogun:OWN-09","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}}],"sources":[{"id":"multi-agent-shogun:readme","productId":"multi-agent-shogun","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun/blob/aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e/README.md","title":"multi-agent-shogun README.md","locator":"Quick Start; What is this; Multi-CLI Support; Mobile Access; Key Features","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"Shell/tmux agents coordinate through YAML queues and mailbox events. Shogun delegates to Karo, seven Ashigaru workers and Gunshi strategist. Android app connects over SSH; Windows needs WSL2."},{"id":"multi-agent-shogun:gap39-dashboard","productId":"multi-agent-shogun","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun/blob/bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919/scripts/dashboard-viewer.py","title":"Shogun browser dashboard","locator":"HTML_TEMPLATE viewport; do_GET; /api/dashboard and /api/mtime","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"The supplied Python HTTP server renders dashboard.md in a browser with auto-refresh and a device-width viewport. It is a read-only task/report dashboard; its scoped routes and rendering do not provide proposed-code diff review or prompt submission.","commit":"bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919","path":"scripts/dashboard-viewer.py"},{"id":"multi-agent-shogun:agy-release-1","productId":"multi-agent-shogun","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun/blob/bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919/README.md#L126-L138","title":"multi-agent-shogun Antigravity support at v5.1.0","locator":"README.md lines 126-138, v5.1.0, commit bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919","sourceDate":"2026-05-23","retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"The latest release v5.1.0 documents Claude Code, Codex, Copilot, Kimi and OpenCode. Antigravity appears in newer main-branch documentation, but was not established in this released snapshot."},{"id":"multi-agent-shogun:gap39-launch","productId":"multi-agent-shogun","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun/blob/bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919/shutsujin_departure.sh","title":"Shogun formation launcher","locator":"tmux creation, working-directory setup and CLI launch; lib/cli_adapter.sh","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"The scoped launcher creates detached tmux sessions/panes and starts installed coding CLIs in the host working directory. Inspection of launcher, lib and scripts found no product-created worktrees, per-agent containers or VMs, vendor-runtime provisioner, or human workspace-role/SSO system.","commit":"bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919","path":"shutsujin_departure.sh"},{"id":"multi-agent-shogun:gap39-telemetry","productId":"multi-agent-shogun","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun/blob/bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919/first_setup.sh","title":"Shogun configuration and outbound communication","locator":"Generated settings template, lines 619-649; lib; scripts; search telemetry, analytics, PostHog, Sentry, SSO, SAML, OIDC","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"Bounded inspection found no product telemetry emitter/disable setting or enterprise SSO implementation. Optional ntfy sends task notifications or receives commands using topic token/basic authentication; coding-harness/provider telemetry remains separate.","commit":"bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919","path":"first_setup.sh"},{"id":"multi-agent-shogun:gap39-branch","productId":"multi-agent-shogun","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun/blob/bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919/scripts/auto_merge_short_lived.sh","title":"Shogun branch merge helper","locator":"merge_short_lived_branch; lib/branch_policy.sh; instructions/roles/shogun_role.md OSS Pull Request Review","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"The product supplies Git branch policy and short-lived branch merge helpers. The inspected scripts do not create or manage pull requests; pull-request review appears as agent prompt guidance, not a product PR integration.","commit":"bb1991539286dea65e9bb24ceaf83a346b099919","path":"scripts/auto_merge_short_lived.sh"},{"id":"multi-agent-shogun:license","productId":"multi-agent-shogun","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun/blob/aff8dc8495da26a2aad582257457655fa953b57e/LICENSE","title":"multi-agent-shogun LICENSE","locator":"MIT license grant","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"MIT grant covers the repository at pinned revision."},{"id":"multi-agent-shogun:release","productId":"multi-agent-shogun","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/yohey-w/multi-agent-shogun/releases/tag/v5.1.0","title":"multi-agent-shogun v5.1.0 release","locator":"v5.1.0 release","sourceDate":"2026-05-23","retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"Release published 23 May 2026. August README note points to kagemusha while saying multi-agent-shogun continues to work as-is."}],"comparisons":[{"slug":"multi-agent-shogun-vs-podium","productIds":["multi-agent-shogun","podium"],"canonicalUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/multi-agent-shogun-vs-podium/"}],"otherComparisonsUrl":"https://adecomparison.com/compare/?products=multi-agent-shogun"}
