36 of 51 criteria have a sourced finding; 30 were also cross-checked by a second agent. Every comparison that includes scion links here for scope, limitations, atomic answers and sources.
Humans approve the rubric, templates and prototype; they do not review every finding. An agent source cross-check is not a hands-on product test. A missing sourced finding is not evidence that a capability is absent.
Scion provides native macOS/Linux CLI and Windows Hub-client CLI distributions, Workstation/hosted browser UI and mobile browser chat. There is no native phone app in the scoped distribution.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Targeted first-party source check 2026-11-13. New implementation findings are pinned to 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b. Unchanged atomic answers retain the individual source dates and revisions in their cited evidence. · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
This source pass establishes only the named atomic answers. Other parts retain their documented source gaps; no hands-on test was performed.
9 atomic answers
Desktop os [supported] Native macOS, Linux and Windows CLI builds; Windows is remote-Hub client only, with no local server or agent container lifecycle. Sources: scion:gaps41-desktop.
Mobile apps [unsupported] No native iOS or Android application entry point in the scoped distribution. Sources: scion:gaps41-clients.
Named harnesses include Claude Code, Codex, OpenCode and Antigravity; credential guide explicitly includes Gemini CLI. Scion v0.3.0-preview.7 ships an Antigravity container harness bundle, provisioning script and agy wrapper launch configuration.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Source documentation at 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b Antigravity source pass: v0.3.0-preview.7 (7035829be4f38efe1ef43faed34404fbd78141e4). · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-10
Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.
Antigravity support is in a published preview release and requires the harness image and compatible credentials.
5 atomic answers
Harnesses [supported] Claude Code, Codex, OpenCode, Antigravity, Gemini CLI. Scion v0.3.0-preview.7 ships an Antigravity container harness bundle, provisioning script and agy wrapper launch configuration. Sources: scion:readme, scion:credentials, scion:agy-release-1, scion:agy-release-2.
Model providers [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish model providers for this scoped product.
Sdk [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish sdk for this scoped product.
Mcp server [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish mcp server for this scoped product.
Webhooks [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish webhooks for this scoped product.
Operations [supported] Agent start/stop/resume/delete/list/logs/messages and projects. Sources: scion:readme, scion:api.
Authentication [supported] OAuth or Dev Auth user tokens, agent tokens issued at startup, and HMAC-signed broker requests. Sources: scion:readme, scion:api.
Stability [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish stability for this scoped product.
Scion passes tasks as agent instructions and integrates with external trackers. The scoped source has no persistent product-owned issue/backlog records separate from agent sessions.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Targeted first-party source check 2026-11-13. New implementation findings are pinned to 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b. Unchanged atomic answers retain the individual source dates and revisions in their cited evidence. · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-13 (9 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
This source pass establishes only the named atomic answers. Other parts retain their documented source gaps; no hands-on test was performed.
17 atomic answers
Create [unsupported] No separate issue creation API or model in the scoped schema and routes. Sources: scion:gaps41-issues.
Edit [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish edit for this scoped product.
Discuss [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish discuss for this scoped product.
Prioritize [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish prioritize for this scoped product.
Label [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish label for this scoped product.
Assign [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish assign for this scoped product.
Search [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish search for this scoped product.
Filter [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish filter for this scoped product.
Archive [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish archive for this scoped product.
Reopen [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish reopen for this scoped product.
Project epic views [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish project epic views for this scoped product.
Idea parking [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish idea parking for this scoped product.
Explicit dispatch [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish explicit dispatch for this scoped product.
Task session separation [unsupported] The task-file input is an agent prompt, not a separate persistent issue. Sources: scion:gaps41-issues.
Metadata [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish metadata for this scoped product.
Durable states [unsupported] No issue state model separate from agent lifecycle state in the inspected schema. Sources: scion:gaps41-issues.
External tracker requirement [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish external tracker requirement for this scoped product.
Scion supports local Workstation or user-operated durable hosted Hub/brokers on VM, Kubernetes or Cloud Run. This is not evidence of a vendor-run cloud subscription.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Source documentation at 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-08
Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.
Scion has container and Git worktree/clone separation. Its operator-configured Substrate backend also exposes a microVM sandbox class, requiring a compatible Substrate service.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Targeted first-party source check 2026-11-13. New implementation findings are pinned to 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b. Unchanged atomic answers retain the individual source dates and revisions in their cited evidence. · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
This source pass establishes only the named atomic answers. Other parts retain their documented source gaps; no hands-on test was performed.
Scion agents can use Git tools, but the scoped product source has no native pull-request creation or management workflow. A GitHub App permission display alone does not implement one.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Targeted first-party source check 2026-11-13. New implementation findings are pinned to 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b. Unchanged atomic answers retain the individual source dates and revisions in their cited evidence. · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-13 (9 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
This source pass establishes only the named atomic answers. Other parts retain their documented source gaps; no hands-on test was performed.
9 atomic answers
Branches [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish branches for this scoped product.
Worktrees [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish worktrees for this scoped product.
Commits [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish commits for this scoped product.
Pull requests [unsupported] No product PR create/manage operation in the inspected CLI, Hub API or UI. Sources: scion:gaps41-pr.
Comments [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish comments for this scoped product.
Ci response [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish ci response for this scoped product.
Rebase [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish rebase for this scoped product.
Conflicts [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish conflicts for this scoped product.
Product state [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish product state for this scoped product.
Scion supports explicit hosted credentials and optional workstation credential injection. Its agent telemetry collection can be disabled through telemetry.enabled, SCION_TELEMETRY_ENABLED or --disable-telemetry, subject to hosted project policy.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Targeted first-party source check 2026-11-13. New implementation findings are pinned to 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b. Unchanged atomic answers retain the individual source dates and revisions in their cited evidence. · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
This source pass establishes only the named atomic answers. Other parts retain their documented source gaps; no hands-on test was performed.
15 atomic answers
Code data [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish code data for this scoped product.
Prompts [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish prompts for this scoped product.
Scion is Apache-2.0 open source with no paid plan published; agents use your own model credentials, and any hosted Hub or Cloud Run/Kubernetes infrastructure is on your own account with no price given. Provider API-key setup explicitly accepts user-supplied model keys.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Targeted first-party source check 2026-11-13. New implementation findings are pinned to 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b. Unchanged atomic answers retain the individual source dates and revisions in their cited evidence. · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-10 (12 days old)
Agent cross-check
Not separately cross-checked
This source pass establishes only the named atomic answers. Other parts retain their documented source gaps; no hands-on test was performed.
12 atomic answers
Currency [unknown] No first-party source states currency for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Interval [unknown] No first-party source states interval for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Seats [unknown] No first-party source states seats for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Seat minimum [unknown] No first-party source states seat minimum for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Workspace fees [unknown] No first-party source states workspace fees for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Included usage [unknown] No first-party source states included usage for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Credits [unknown] No first-party source states credits for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Trial [unknown] No first-party source states trial for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Overages [unknown] No first-party source states overages for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Taxes [unknown] No first-party source states taxes for a paid plan. Checked: GoogleCloudPlatform/scion README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
Model cost [supported] Users provide their own provider API keys through local environment variables or explicit Hub secrets; model charges remain with the provider. Sources: scion:gaps41-byok.
Compute cost [partial] Agents can run on Docker, Kubernetes, Cloud Run or a hosted Hub that you operate. The README gives no price. Sources: scion:readme-nov10.
Current nightly November 8 and preview releases document pre-1.0 actively evolving platform. It is explicitly not an officially supported Google product.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Source documentation at 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-08 (14 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-08
Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.
Scion is Apache-2.0 open source installed free through a Homebrew tap or from source, with no paid plan shown. Model usage and any infrastructure the user runs it on are paid separately.
Scope
Surfaces: Scion Workstation and user-operated hosted Hub web/CLI · Version: Source documentation at 643a440722c9656f2ab4ad368511c57738643e3b · Plan: Not specified · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local, self-hosted · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-10 (12 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-10
Provider and cloud infrastructure free tiers, caps and card requirements were not checked. No installed-product test was run.
10 atomic answers
Ongoing free [supported] The scion CLI and embedded web UI are a free Apache-2.0 install from Homebrew or source. Sources: scion:src4-license, scion:src4-install.
Trial [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish trial for this scoped product.
Credits trial [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish credits trial for this scoped product.
Self host cost [partial] No Scion fee is shown; the user pays for the machines, Kubernetes or Cloud Run resources and model providers. Sources: scion:src4-install.
Paid only [unsupported] Not paid-only: Scion installs free of charge from public channels. Sources: scion:src4-install.
Early access [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish early access for this scoped product.
Free scenarios [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish free scenarios for this scoped product.
Card required [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish card required for this scoped product.
Usage caps [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish usage caps for this scoped product.
Paid evaluation [unknown] The checked first-party sources do not establish paid evaluation for this scoped product.
Pre-1.0 open-source agent orchestration runs independent harness processes with roles, delegation, messaging and parallel work. CLI/Workstation web UI and own hosted Hub, container/worktree/clone modes, APIs/skills/templates and runtime brokers are documented. Apache-2.0; not an officially supported Google product.
The shipped UI is the Vite browser dashboard embedded in the Go CLI/server. The scoped repository has no desktop GUI package or native iOS/Android application entry point. The CLI and browser are separate from native desktop and phone clients.
Kind
source-inspected
Locator
web/package.json; README.md Quick Start; repository inventory for Electron, Tauri, Xcode and Android entry points
Scion publishes native macOS, Linux and Windows CLI builds. Windows is a Hub client only; server, runtime broker and local container lifecycle commands are unsupported there. The macOS/Linux CLI includes the local server and embedded web frontend.
Kind
documented
Locator
Installation guide Windows and Older Linux distributions; .github/workflows/release.yml build matrix
Workstation can inject native Claude/Gemini login files and API credentials into agents. Hosted brokers require explicit Hub secrets/profile config and never read arbitrary host credential files.
Kind
documented
Locator
Workstation vs Hosted; Host credential files; Native login methods
--task-file reads a prompt into the agent task.md file. The scoped persistence schema and product routes contain agent/session/project records but no separate issue/backlog entity or issue CRUD/state workflow. README instead points to external GitHub Issues, Linear, Farmtable and Beads.
Kind
source-inspected
Locator
cmd/task_file.go lines 26-41; pkg/ent/schema; pkg/hub and web/src routes searched for issue, task, backlog, durable state
Hub-managed cron schedules can dispatch agents/messages with timezone rules and retained creator authority. Pause/resume and creator-deleted status reasons are explicit.
Every current mode requires a Hub. Local Workstation is single-user; hosted single-node SQLite or HA Postgres/object-storage may be multi-user, on user-operated VM/Cloud Run infrastructure.
Operator-configured Substrate runtimes accept sandbox_class: microvm and map it to SANDBOX_CLASS_MICROVM when constructing an actor template. The runtime factory instantiates this backend from an explicit operator profile; it requires a compatible user-operated Substrate service.
Kind
source-inspected
Locator
pkg/runtime/substrate_template.go lines 224-234; pkg/config/settings_v1.go lines 2920-2950; pkg/runtime/factory.go substrate case
Hosted Hub has admin/member/viewer roles, Google/GitHub OAuth and optional external OIDC federation, plus membership/suspension and session revocation controls.
Positive role bindings and narrowing access boundaries apply at system/project scope. Time windows, user active-state checks and transaction-bound boundary audit history are documented; deleting boundary deletes its history.
Google/GitHub OAuth, cookie sessions, agent JWT scopes, runtime broker HMAC and user revocation are documented. User/project role bindings and permission ceilings govern access.
Artifact publishing/retrieval/review is experimental hub.artifacts default off. Hub stores versioned file/folder bytes and grants independent of publisher filesystem. CLI/web views and immutable version references are documented.
GitHub App settings display pull-request permission status, while the scoped product code has no pull-request creation or management route/control. Agents may use their own tools, but that is not a native Scion PR workflow.
Kind
source-inspected
Locator
pkg/hub and cmd plus web/src inspected for pull_request, pull request, gh pr and GitHub routes; project-settings.ts GitHub App permissions
SCION_TELEMETRY_ENABLED controls collection entirely; telemetry.enabled and --disable-telemetry provide equivalent scoped controls. For Hub-dispatched agents project policy takes precedence over the requester and environment variables.
Kind
documented
Locator
Configuration hierarchy and environment variable table, lines 17-105
Describes Apache-2.0 open-source orchestration where you choose models and give each agent its own credentials. It runs on Docker, Kubernetes, Cloud Run or a hosted Hub you operate, with no price stated.
Kind
documented
Locator
Intro paragraphs; 'Open interfaces' bullet; runtime list
The guide explicitly lists user-supplied ANTHROPIC_API_KEY, GEMINI_API_KEY, GOOGLE_API_KEY, CODEX_API_KEY and OPENAI_API_KEY, with local environment and Hub secret setup examples.