---
schema_version: 7
rubric_version: "0.3"
canonical_url: "https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/ralph-orchestrator/"
data_url: "https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/ralph-orchestrator/data.json"
generated_at: 2026-11-22
oldest_checked_at: 2026-11-08
last_checked_at: 2026-11-13
publisher: "Podium"
---

# ralph-orchestrator: ADE findings

> Podium publishes this catalog and sells an agent development environment. Podium chooses the products, criteria, sources and wording, so treat these pages as vendor-authored research. Check important claims against the linked primary sources. Sourced findings follow the same evidence rules for Podium and its competitors. Facts labeled Podium team research come from Podium's own team and have no linked source. None of this removes the conflict of interest.

> Based on data from adecomparison.com by Podium (https://adecomparison.com; source repository https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison, snapshot 4322f0c of 2026-11-22), used under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Source links and check dates are kept. Podium arranges the findings into pairs, applies its publication checks, and added its own research where marked "Podium team research". Data license terms: https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison/blob/4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e/DATA-LICENSE.md

33 of 51 criteria have a sourced finding; 22 were also cross-checked by a second agent. Source checks: 2026-11-08 to 2026-11-13. A missing sourced finding is not evidence that a capability is absent.

- Website: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator
- Canonical HTML: https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/ralph-orchestrator/
- Machine-readable JSON: https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/ralph-orchestrator/data.json
- Rubric: https://podium.do/compare/agents/rubric/index.md
- Comparisons with ralph-orchestrator on podium.do: 1 (listed in the JSON and HTML)
- Compare ralph-orchestrator with any other product on adecomparison.com by Podium: https://adecomparison.com/compare/?products=ralph-orchestrator

## Access and agent choice

### ACC-01: Client access

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

Ralph supplies a native CLI/TUI on macOS, Linux and Windows plus an alpha browser dashboard and Telegram integration. It has no product-owned native phone app.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: mobile_browser, editor_extensions, notifications, cross_device_continuity.

- desktop_os — Desktop os [supported]: The first-party installation OS list is macOS, Linux and Windows. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-install.
- mobile_apps — Mobile apps [unsupported]: The product client inventory is CLI/TUI, alpha web and Telegram integration, without a native Ralph iOS/Android client. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary.
- browser — Browser [supported]: ralph web opens the alpha dashboard. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- mobile_browser — Mobile browser [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish mobile browser for this scoped product.
- cli — Cli [supported]: ralph commands run and manage loops. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- editor_extensions — Editor extensions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish editor extensions for this scoped product.
- task_actions — Task actions [supported]: Telegram supports status, tasks, restart and proactive guidance. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- notifications — Notifications [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish notifications for this scoped product.
- cross_device_continuity — Cross device continuity [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish cross device continuity for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-install, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary

### ACC-02: Agent and model choice

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Eleven named CLI backends and custom commands are documented, with different backends selectable per hat.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- harnesses — Harnesses [supported]: Claude Code, Codex, Gemini CLI, OpenCode, Pi, Kiro, Forge, Amp, Copilot CLI, Roo and OMP. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:backends.
- model_providers — Model providers [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish model providers for this scoped product.
- custom_adapters — Custom adapters [supported]: Custom command backend accepts argument or stdin prompts. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:backends.
- session_integration — Session integration [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish session integration for this scoped product.
- mixed_harness_operation — Mixed harness operation [supported]: Per-hat backend overrides allow a mixed-backend workflow. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:backends.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:backends

### ACC-03: Subscriptions, API keys and vendor credits

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Backend setup supports native Claude login and provider API credentials. Costs and account rights belong to the selected agent.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- agent_subscriptions — Agent subscriptions [partial]: Claude native login is documented; subscription entitlements depend on the underlying account. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:backends.
- api_accounts — Api accounts [supported]: Provider key configuration is documented for supported backends. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:backends.
- vendor_credits — Vendor credits [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish vendor credits for this scoped product.
- local_models — Local models [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish local models for this scoped product.
- account_switching — Account switching [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish account switching for this scoped product.
- vendor_account_requirement — Vendor account requirement [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish vendor account requirement for this scoped product.
- provider_restrictions — Provider restrictions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish provider restrictions for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:backends

### ACC-04: Onboarding and project prerequisites

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Install Ralph and a supported agent CLI, initialize a backend, then plan or run. Dashboard setup additionally needs Rust and Node.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- first_task_setup — First task setup [supported]: ralph init --backend claude, then ralph run -p. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- no_git — No git [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish no git for this scoped product.
- local_git_without_remote — Local git without remote [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish local git without remote for this scoped product.
- hosted_git — Hosted git [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish hosted git for this scoped product.
- prerequisite_guidance — Prerequisite guidance [supported]: README lists Rust, Node and installed coding CLI prerequisites. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- managed_cloud_setup — Managed cloud setup [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish managed cloud setup for this scoped product.
- byo_vps_onboarding — Byo vps onboarding [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish byo vps onboarding for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme

### ACC-05: Programmable access

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Ralph provides its CLI and a stdio MCP server scoped to one workspace.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- cli — Cli [supported]: ralph manages tasks, memories, loops and configuration. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- api — Api [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish api for this scoped product.
- sdk — Sdk [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish sdk for this scoped product.
- mcp_server — Mcp server [supported]: ralph mcp serve --workspace-root scopes one MCP instance per workspace. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- webhooks — Webhooks [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish webhooks for this scoped product.
- operations — Operations [supported]: Run, inspect, stop, resume, list tasks and emit events are documented. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- authentication — Authentication [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish authentication for this scoped product.
- stability — Stability [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish stability for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli

### ACC-06: External tools and extensions

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### ACC-07: Client implementation

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

## Planning and context

### PLAN-01: Intake and external tracker relationship

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Runtime tasks can be added, listed and inspected through product commands.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- local_creation — Local creation [supported]: ralph tools task add creates a task. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- prompt_intake — Prompt intake [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish prompt intake for this scoped product.
- external_import — External import [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish external import for this scoped product.
- chat_git_triggers — Chat git triggers [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish chat git triggers for this scoped product.
- authoritative_tracker — Authoritative tracker [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish authoritative tracker for this scoped product.
- stable_ids — Stable ids [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish stable ids for this scoped product.
- sync — Sync [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish sync for this scoped product.
- supported_edits — Supported edits [supported]: Task close and fail change state. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- external_roundtrips — External roundtrips [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish external roundtrips for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli

### PLAN-02: Durable task plans

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Interactive planning writes requirements, design and implementation-plan Markdown under .ralph/specs.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- plans — Plans [supported]: ralph plan creates an implementation-plan.md file. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- acceptance_criteria — Acceptance criteria [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish acceptance criteria for this scoped product.
- editors — Editors [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish editors for this scoped product.
- revisions — Revisions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish revisions for this scoped product.
- implementation_links — Implementation links [supported]: The run prompt can reference the generated spec directory. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- amendment — Amendment [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish amendment for this scoped product.
- restart_persistence — Restart persistence [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish restart persistence for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme

### PLAN-03: Hierarchy, dependencies and evolving scope

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### PLAN-04: Shared context and memory

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Persistent Markdown memory is shared across parallel loops; tools can search, add and delete entries.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- instructions — Instructions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish instructions for this scoped product.
- skills — Skills [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish skills for this scoped product.
- project_docs — Project docs [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish project docs for this scoped product.
- memory — Memory [supported]: Persistent .agent/memories.md. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:memory, ralph-orchestrator:cli, ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- scope — Scope [supported]: Parallel loops symlink shared memory but keep separate scratchpads. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:memory, ralph-orchestrator:cli, ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- provenance — Provenance [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish provenance for this scoped product.
- correction — Correction [partial]: Memory can be added and deleted; dedicated correction provenance remains unknown. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:memory, ralph-orchestrator:cli, ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- deletion — Deletion [supported]: ralph tools memory delete removes a named memory. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:memory, ralph-orchestrator:cli, ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- freshness — Freshness [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish freshness for this scoped product.
- takeover_continuity — Takeover continuity [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish takeover continuity for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:memory, ralph-orchestrator:cli, ralph-orchestrator:parallel

### PLAN-05: Architecture and API awareness

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### PLAN-06: Native issue management and idea backlog

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Ralph owns persistent runtime task records with ready, close and fail operations; a full issue backlog workflow is not established.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- create — Create [supported]: ralph tools task add. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- edit — Edit [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish edit for this scoped product.
- discuss — Discuss [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish discuss for this scoped product.
- prioritize — Prioritize [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish prioritize for this scoped product.
- label — Label [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish label for this scoped product.
- assign — Assign [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish assign for this scoped product.
- search — Search [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish search for this scoped product.
- filter — Filter [partial]: ready lists unblocked tasks. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- archive — Archive [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish archive for this scoped product.
- reopen — Reopen [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish reopen for this scoped product.
- project_epic_views — Project epic views [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish project epic views for this scoped product.
- idea_parking — Idea parking [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish idea parking for this scoped product.
- explicit_dispatch — Explicit dispatch [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish explicit dispatch for this scoped product.
- task_session_separation — Task session separation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish task session separation for this scoped product.
- metadata — Metadata [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish metadata for this scoped product.
- durable_states — Durable states [supported]: Task records can be closed or failed. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- external_tracker_requirement — External tracker requirement [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish external tracker requirement for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli

### PLAN-07: Agent-native issue operations

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Runtime task commands are exposed to agents as tools.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- shared_ids — Shared ids [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish shared ids for this scoped product.
- read — Read [supported]: task list and show. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- create — Create [supported]: task add. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- update — Update [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish update for this scoped product.
- claim — Claim [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish claim for this scoped product.
- assign — Assign [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish assign for this scoped product.
- state_changes — State changes [supported]: task close and fail. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- dependencies — Dependencies [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish dependencies for this scoped product.
- children — Children [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish children for this scoped product.
- results — Results [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish results for this scoped product.
- human_visibility — Human visibility [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish human visibility for this scoped product.
- attribution — Attribution [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish attribution for this scoped product.
- permissions — Permissions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish permissions for this scoped product.
- conflicts — Conflicts [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish conflicts for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli

### PLAN-08: Living product specifications

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Planning creates persistent requirements and design files; approval and drift gates remain unestablished.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- persistent_requirements — Persistent requirements [supported]: requirements.md under the generated spec directory. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- human_edits — Human edits [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish human edits for this scoped product.
- agent_edits — Agent edits [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish agent edits for this scoped product.
- revisions — Revisions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish revisions for this scoped product.
- approvals — Approvals [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish approvals for this scoped product.
- implementation_links — Implementation links [supported]: run references the spec directory. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- later_retrieval — Later retrieval [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish later retrieval for this scoped product.
- drift_detection — Drift detection [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish drift detection for this scoped product.
- review_integration — Review integration [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish review integration for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme

## Coordination and automation

### COORD-01: Parallel work

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Additional concurrent loops run in separate Git worktrees.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- concurrent_sessions — Concurrent sessions [supported]: Multiple loops run simultaneously. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- concurrent_tasks — Concurrent tasks [supported]: Separate prompts execute in separate loops. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- quotas — Quotas [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish quotas for this scoped product.
- observed_concurrency — Observed concurrency [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish observed concurrency for this scoped product.
- status_visibility — Status visibility [supported]: ralph loops lists running, queued, merged, crashed and needs-review states. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel

### COORD-02: Ownership and dispatch

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### COORD-03: Inspectable delegation and communication

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

The shipped Hatless Ralph coordinator delegates work through named hat events, receives their event results and can route hats to different coding-agent backends with fresh iteration context.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: results_return, activation, authentication, live_progress, retained_results, followup, invocation.

- roles — Roles [supported]: The product supplies a constant Ralph coordinator and named specialized hat-agent roles. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-hat-coordinator.
- model_harness_effort — Model harness effort [partial]: Per-hat backend overrides are documented. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:backends.
- messages — Messages [supported]: ralph emit routes delegation and result events between the coordinator and named hats. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-hat-coordinator.
- results_return — Results return [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish results return for this scoped product.
- cross_harness — Cross harness [supported]: Per-hat backend selection can route specialized work to different supported coding-agent CLIs. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-hat-coordinator.
- orchestration_owner — Orchestration owner [supported]: The coordinator prompt, event tools and hat dispatch belong to Ralph; provider-native subagents are separate. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-hat-coordinator.
- activation — Activation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish activation for this scoped product.
- authentication — Authentication [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish authentication for this scoped product.
- live_progress — Live progress [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish live progress for this scoped product.
- retained_results — Retained results [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish retained results for this scoped product.
- followup — Followup [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish followup for this scoped product.
- invocation — Invocation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish invocation for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:backends, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-hat-coordinator

### COORD-04: Unattended triggers

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

The alpha legacy Node API can start agent work from externally created unblocked tasks through its owned dispatcher, without a human initiating each execution.

Availability: beta
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=Alpha legacy Node web backend, enabled with --legacy-node-api; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: schedules, recurring_tasks, completion_conditions, overlaps, retries.

- schedules — Schedules [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish schedules for this scoped product.
- events — Events [supported]: POST /api/v1/tasks auto-enqueues unblocked work unless autoExecute is false; the owned dispatcher starts Ralph. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-api-dispatch.
- recurring_tasks — Recurring tasks [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish recurring tasks for this scoped product.
- completion_conditions — Completion conditions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish completion conditions for this scoped product.
- scheduler_location — Scheduler location [supported]: The dispatcher runs in the self-hosted alpha legacy Node web backend. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-api-dispatch.
- overlaps — Overlaps [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish overlaps for this scoped product.
- retries — Retries [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish retries for this scoped product.
- client_independence — Client independence [supported]: Dispatch is backend-owned rather than driven by a connected browser. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-api-dispatch.

Checked 2026-11-13 (9 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-api-dispatch, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-web-alpha-scope

### COORD-05: Intervention and attention

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Loops can be stopped/resumed; Telegram questions block until answered and proactive messages steer a run.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- pause — Pause [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish pause for this scoped product.
- stop — Stop [supported]: loops stop terminates a loop. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- resume — Resume [supported]: loops resume signals suspended work. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- steer — Steer [supported]: Telegram proactive guidance. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- notifications — Notifications [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish notifications for this scoped product.
- pending_decisions — Pending decisions [supported]: human.interact waits for human response or timeout. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- escalation — Escalation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish escalation for this scoped product.
- visible_errors — Visible errors [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish visible errors for this scoped product.
- chat_terminal_parity — Chat terminal parity [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish chat terminal parity for this scoped product.
- retained_history — Retained history [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish retained history for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli

### COORD-06: Fleet and epic management UI

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### COORD-07: Workflow flexibility and orchestration visibility

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

Five built-in workflows and direct prompts are documented.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- quick_task — Quick task [supported]: ralph run -p for direct work. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- growing_epic — Growing epic [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish growing epic for this scoped product.
- presets — Presets [supported]: code-assist, debug, research, review and pdd-to-code-assist. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- natural_language — Natural language [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish natural language for this scoped product.
- agent_configuration — Agent configuration [supported]: Backend selected at initialization or per hat. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:backends.
- in_run_changes — In run changes [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish in run changes for this scoped product.
- live_roles — Live roles [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish live roles for this scoped product.
- retained_relationships — Retained relationships [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish retained relationships for this scoped product.
- discoverability — Discoverability [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish discoverability for this scoped product.
- auth_friction — Auth friction [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish auth friction for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:backends

## Execution and reliability

### RUN-01: Laptop-independent execution

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

Ralph normally invokes installed agent CLIs on the current host. Its documented alpha legacy Node web mode also supplies an operator-hosted network server with detached agent processes independent of browser clients.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=Local CLI runtime; the operator-server path uses the alpha legacy Node backend with --legacy-node-api.; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: self_hosted, hybrid, provisioning, payer, resources, region, expiry, other_device_continuation.

- local — Local [supported]: User-installed ralph invokes local coding backends. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- byo_remote — Byo remote [supported]: The alpha legacy Node backend binds a network host and runs the installed Ralph process on that operator host. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-alpha-server, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary.
- self_hosted — Self hosted [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish self hosted for this scoped product.
- managed_cloud — Managed cloud [unsupported]: The inspected public runtime modes run installed CLIs on operator machines, without a Ralph-operated compute service. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-alpha-server, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary.
- hybrid — Hybrid [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish hybrid for this scoped product.
- provisioning — Provisioning [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish provisioning for this scoped product.
- payer — Payer [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish payer for this scoped product.
- resources — Resources [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish resources for this scoped product.
- region — Region [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish region for this scoped product.
- expiry — Expiry [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish expiry for this scoped product.
- client_disconnect — Client disconnect [supported]: ProcessSupervisor starts detached/unref processes with persisted PID/status/logs; browser disconnect does not own their lifetime. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-alpha-server, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary.
- other_device_continuation — Other device continuation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish other device continuation for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-alpha-server, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-web-alpha-scope

### RUN-02: Workspace and process isolation

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

Ralph separates parallel loop checkouts with Git worktrees and runs native host CLI processes; it provides no built-in container or VM isolation.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: checkout, branch, os_sandbox, filesystem, process, network, secrets, security_boundary.

- checkout — Checkout [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish checkout for this scoped product.
- branch — Branch [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish branch for this scoped product.
- worktree — Worktree [supported]: Additional loops use a separate Git working directory named for the loop ID. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- container — Container [unsupported]: No product-managed container provisioning is present in the inspected runtime paths. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary.
- vm — Vm [unsupported]: No product-managed VM provisioning is present in the inspected runtime paths. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary.
- os_sandbox — Os sandbox [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish os sandbox for this scoped product.
- filesystem — Filesystem [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish filesystem for this scoped product.
- process — Process [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish process for this scoped product.
- network — Network [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish network for this scoped product.
- secrets — Secrets [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish secrets for this scoped product.
- code_separation — Code separation [supported]: Loop events, tasks and scratchpad are isolated by worktree. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- security_boundary — Security boundary [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish security boundary for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary

### RUN-03: Recovery, expiry and continuity

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Existing loop state can be continued and suspended loops resumed; no crash recovery experiment was run.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- client_disconnect — Client disconnect [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish client disconnect for this scoped product.
- worker_crash — Worker crash [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish worker crash for this scoped product.
- service_restart — Service restart [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish service restart for this scoped product.
- expiry — Expiry [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish expiry for this scoped product.
- transcript_reload — Transcript reload [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish transcript reload for this scoped product.
- process_reconnect — Process reconnect [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish process reconnect for this scoped product.
- task_resume — Task resume [supported]: ralph run --continue and loops resume are documented. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli, ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- state_reconstruction — State reconstruction [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish state reconstruction for this scoped product.
- context_loss — Context loss [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish context loss for this scoped product.
- duplicate_actions — Duplicate actions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish duplicate actions for this scoped product.
- manual_repair — Manual repair [supported]: Failed rebase conflicts require git rebase --continue or --abort. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli, ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- multi_day_continuity — Multi day continuity [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish multi day continuity for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:cli, ralph-orchestrator:parallel

### RUN-04: Development environment reliability

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### RUN-05: Limits and failure handling

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Current configuration bounds iterations and total runtime, with adapter inactivity timeouts and per-hat activation caps.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- time_limits — Time limits [supported]: max_runtime_seconds bounds a loop. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:config.
- turn_limits — Turn limits [partial]: max_iterations bounds loop iterations, not every tool call. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:config.
- token_limits — Token limits [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish token limits for this scoped product.
- spend_limits — Spend limits [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish spend limits for this scoped product.
- timeouts — Timeouts [supported]: Adapter inactivity and hook timeouts are configurable. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:config.
- retries — Retries [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish retries for this scoped product.
- provider_failures — Provider failures [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish provider failures for this scoped product.
- enforcement — Enforcement [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish enforcement for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:config

### RUN-06: Truthful status and operational statistics

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Loop logs and event history expose operational state and JSONL export.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- logs — Logs [supported]: loops logs supports follow. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- traces — Traces [partial]: loops history --json exports event history. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- failure_reasons — Failure reasons [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish failure reasons for this scoped product.
- usage_export — Usage export [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish usage export for this scoped product.
- task_stats — Task stats [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish task stats for this scoped product.
- agent_stats — Agent stats [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish agent stats for this scoped product.
- project_stats — Project stats [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish project stats for this scoped product.
- time_stats — Time stats [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish time stats for this scoped product.
- failure_status — Failure status [supported]: crashed and needs-review states are documented. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- approval_status — Approval status [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish approval status for this scoped product.
- reconnect_consistency — Reconnect consistency [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish reconnect consistency for this scoped product.
- performance_method — Performance method [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish performance method for this scoped product.
- responsiveness — Responsiveness [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish responsiveness for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:cli

### RUN-07: Per-task API and compute cost

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### RUN-08: Compute-aware scheduling and verification

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

## Human collaboration and control

### TEAM-01: Live human collaboration

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

The Telegram integration can route instructions from multiple humans reaching the bot into the same loop as human.guidance or human.response events.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=Opt-in Telegram integration; RObot.enabled=true; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: visibility, discussion, comments, presence, ordering, conflicts, permissions, plan_restrictions, owner_online.

- visibility — Visibility [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish visibility for this scoped product.
- discussion — Discussion [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish discussion for this scoped product.
- comments — Comments [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish comments for this scoped product.
- presence — Presence [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish presence for this scoped product.
- coprompting — Coprompting [supported]: The public Telegram polling/handler path accepts messages into the same loop without a single-sender identity restriction. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-telegram-guidance.
- ordering — Ordering [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish ordering for this scoped product.
- conflicts — Conflicts [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish conflicts for this scoped product.
- attribution — Attribution [partial]: Events retain guidance/response content and loop routing; distinct human attribution is not established. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-telegram-guidance.
- permissions — Permissions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish permissions for this scoped product.
- plan_restrictions — Plan restrictions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish plan restrictions for this scoped product.
- owner_online — Owner online [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish owner online for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-13 (9 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-telegram-guidance

### TEAM-02: Roles and access boundaries

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

The inspected Ralph runtime has agent hat roles and local/API control, without named human workspace roles or enterprise SSO.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: project_roles, task_roles, membership, provisioning, unauthorized_access, revocation, plan_scope.

- organization_roles — Organization roles [unsupported]: Agent hats are operational roles; no named human organization-role permission layer is implemented in the inspected runtime. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary.
- project_roles — Project roles [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish project roles for this scoped product.
- task_roles — Task roles [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish task roles for this scoped product.
- membership — Membership [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish membership for this scoped product.
- sso — Sso [unsupported]: No enterprise SAML/OIDC SSO path exists in the inspected runtime; provider and Telegram authentication are separate. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary.
- provisioning — Provisioning [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish provisioning for this scoped product.
- unauthorized_access — Unauthorized access [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish unauthorized access for this scoped product.
- revocation — Revocation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish revocation for this scoped product.
- plan_scope — Plan scope [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish plan scope for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-13 (9 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary

### TEAM-03: Approvals and temporary access

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### TEAM-04: Decision and activity history

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### TEAM-05: Review experience and guidance

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### TEAM-06: Colleague takeover and continuity

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

## Verification and delivery

### SHIP-01: Retained artifacts and outputs

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Planning documents and branch diffs can be retained, and publish-review writes a Markdown handoff.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- diffs — Diffs [supported]: loops diff compares to merge base. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- documents — Documents [supported]: Generated requirements/design/implementation plan. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- screenshots — Screenshots [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish screenshots for this scoped product.
- recordings — Recordings [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish recordings for this scoped product.
- previews — Previews [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish previews for this scoped product.
- test_outputs — Test outputs [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish test outputs for this scoped product.
- reviewer_outputs — Reviewer outputs [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish reviewer outputs for this scoped product.
- gallery — Gallery [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish gallery for this scoped product.
- task_links — Task links [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish task links for this scoped product.
- revision_links — Revision links [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish revision links for this scoped product.
- persistence — Persistence [supported]: publish-review writes .ralph/reviews/<id>.md. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- child_findings — Child findings [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish child findings for this scoped product.
- prompt_leakage — Prompt leakage [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish prompt leakage for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:readme

### SHIP-02: Verification and spec gates

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Backpressure workflows request test, lint and typecheck evidence; instruction examples do not prove that an external verifier enforced it.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- tests — Tests [partial]: Hat instructions request passing tests. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gates.
- lint — Lint [partial]: Lint evidence can be required by instructions. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gates.
- types — Types [partial]: Typecheck evidence can be requested. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gates.
- ci — Ci [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish ci for this scoped product.
- independent_review — Independent review [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish independent review for this scoped product.
- spec_checks — Spec checks [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish spec checks for this scoped product.
- required_checks — Required checks [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish required checks for this scoped product.
- failure_blocking — Failure blocking [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish failure blocking for this scoped product.
- requirement_conflicts — Requirement conflicts [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish requirement conflicts for this scoped product.
- configured_policy — Configured policy [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish configured policy for this scoped product.
- enforced_policy — Enforced policy [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish enforced policy for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gates

### SHIP-03: Git and pull request workflow

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

Ralph integrates worktree diff, branch publish/rebase and merge operations; publish-review writes a Markdown handoff and pushes the branch without creating a pull request.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: branches, commits, comments, ci_response, product_state.

- branches — Branches [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish branches for this scoped product.
- worktrees — Worktrees [supported]: Separate worktree branches. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- commits — Commits [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish commits for this scoped product.
- pull_requests — Pull requests [unsupported]: The native publish-review implementation uses Git branch publication and a handoff file without a PR creation/management operation. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary.
- comments — Comments [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish comments for this scoped product.
- ci_response — Ci response [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish ci response for this scoped product.
- rebase — Rebase [supported]: loops rebase targets a base ref. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- conflicts — Conflicts [supported]: Merge resolver hats or manual needs-review path. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- product_state — Product state [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish product state for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary

### SHIP-04: Merge and deployment authority

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Optional auto-merge uses merger, resolver and tester hats. Exact-revision authorization is unestablished.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- approve — Approve [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish approve for this scoped product.
- merge — Merge [supported]: Opt-in merge queue processes completed worktree loops. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel.
- release — Release [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish release for this scoped product.
- deploy — Deploy [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish deploy for this scoped product.
- exact_revision — Exact revision [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish exact revision for this scoped product.
- authority_enforcement — Authority enforcement [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish authority enforcement for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:parallel

### SHIP-05: Completion evidence and rollback

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### SHIP-06: Batch review and high-volume shipping

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

## Ownership, privacy and economics

### OWN-01: Source and license

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Ralph application source is MIT licensed.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- client_license — Client license [supported]: MIT. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:license.
- server_license — Server license [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish server license for this scoped product.
- hosted_extensions — Hosted extensions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish hosted extensions for this scoped product.
- source_visibility — Source visibility [supported]: Public application repository. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:license.
- source_revision — Source revision [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish source revision for this scoped product.
- hosted_parity — Hosted parity [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish hosted parity for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:license

### OWN-02: Hosting and exit

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

The core Ralph CLI and local web stack can run on user-controlled hardware.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- self_hosting — Self hosting [supported]: Install local Ralph with an installed coding CLI and optionally run ralph web. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- vendor_dependencies — Vendor dependencies [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish vendor dependencies for this scoped product.
- export — Export [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish export for this scoped product.
- import — Import [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish import for this scoped product.
- formats — Formats [supported]: Planning Markdown and JSONL session/event output. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli.
- cancellation — Cancellation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish cancellation for this scoped product.
- account_independence — Account independence [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish account independence for this scoped product.
- history_portability — History portability [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish history portability for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:readme, ralph-orchestrator:cli

### OWN-03: Data handling and telemetry

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

Ralph provides opt-in local diagnostic output controlled by RALPH_DIAGNOSTICS; leaving it unset disables those collectors. Coding-agent/provider telemetry is separate.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: code_data, prompts, credentials, logs, artifacts, retention, deletion, training, residency, subprocessors, consent_prompt, provider_separation.

- code_data — Code data [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish code data for this scoped product.
- prompts — Prompts [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish prompts for this scoped product.
- credentials — Credentials [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish credentials for this scoped product.
- logs — Logs [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish logs for this scoped product.
- artifacts — Artifacts [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish artifacts for this scoped product.
- retention — Retention [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish retention for this scoped product.
- deletion — Deletion [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish deletion for this scoped product.
- training — Training [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish training for this scoped product.
- residency — Residency [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish residency for this scoped product.
- subprocessors — Subprocessors [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish subprocessors for this scoped product.
- telemetry_disclosure — Telemetry disclosure [supported]: Diagnostics include local JSONL output, trace, hook-run telemetry and performance records. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-diagnostics-control.
- telemetry_defaults — Telemetry defaults [supported]: The collector is disabled unless RALPH_DIAGNOSTICS is exactly 1. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-diagnostics-control.
- telemetry_controls — Telemetry controls [supported]: Unset RALPH_DIAGNOSTICS or set it to 0 to disable the local diagnostic collectors. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-diagnostics-control.
- consent_prompt — Consent prompt [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish consent prompt for this scoped product.
- provider_separation — Provider separation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish provider separation for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-13 (9 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-diagnostics-control

### OWN-04: Price and included usage

Verification status: Sourced (sourced)
Support: partial

Ralph is free MIT software without a published paid Ralph plan. Its supported backend setup accepts the user provider API keys or native CLI logins, billed separately.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=First-party pricing sources read 2026-11-10; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.
- Other atomic questions remain unestablished: currency, interval, seats, seat_minimum, workspace_fees, included_usage, credits, trial, overages, taxes, compute_cost.

- currency — Currency [unknown]: No first-party source states currency for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- interval — Interval [unknown]: No first-party source states interval for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- seats — Seats [unknown]: No first-party source states seats for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- seat_minimum — Seat minimum [unknown]: No first-party source states seat minimum for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- workspace_fees — Workspace fees [unknown]: No first-party source states workspace fees for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- included_usage — Included usage [unknown]: No first-party source states included usage for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- credits — Credits [unknown]: No first-party source states credits for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- trial — Trial [unknown]: No first-party source states trial for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- overages — Overages [unknown]: No first-party source states overages for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- taxes — Taxes [unknown]: No first-party source states taxes for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.
- model_cost — Model cost [supported]: Backend setup documents user provider API keys and native CLI authentication; these provider bills are separate from Ralph. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:gaps-provider-keys, ralph-orchestrator:license-nov10, ralph-orchestrator:readme-nov10.
- compute_cost — Compute cost [unknown]: No first-party source states compute cost for a paid plan. Checked: mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator README and LICENSE. No pricing page or paid plan was found, but that does not prove none exists.

Checked 2026-11-10 (12 days old on 2026-11-22); not separately cross-checked.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:license-nov10, ralph-orchestrator:readme-nov10, ralph-orchestrator:gaps-provider-keys

### OWN-05: Scenario cost and controls

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### OWN-06: Availability and support

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

The latest listed release is 2.10.1, published June 23; current README labels the browser dashboard alpha.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Only the named facts are documented. Unanswered atomic questions remain unknown; no execution test was performed.

- release_stage — Release stage [partial]: Web dashboard explicitly alpha. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:release, ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- access_restrictions — Access restrictions [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish access restrictions for this scoped product.
- support — Support [supported]: README links documentation, Discord and issue tracker. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:release, ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- response_commitments — Response commitments [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish response commitments for this scoped product.
- release_activity — Release activity [supported]: 2.10.1 release published 2026-06-23. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:release, ralph-orchestrator:readme.
- status_history — Status history [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish status history for this scoped product.
- deprecation — Deprecation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish deprecation for this scoped product.
- export_options — Export options [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish export options for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-08 (14 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-08.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:release, ralph-orchestrator:readme

### OWN-07: Enterprise assurance

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

### OWN-08: Useful free tier and evaluation access

Verification status: Agent cross-checked (agent-cross-checked)
Support: partial

Ralph Orchestrator is a free MIT download from npm, Cargo or the GitHub Releases installer, with no paid plan shown; optional sponsorship is a donation. Agent and model costs are paid to their providers.

Availability: generally-available
Delivery: native
Scope: surfaces=Ralph CLI, TUI and alpha web dashboard; version=Source documentation at 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3; plan=not specified; os=not specified; execution_modes=local; region=not specified; harness=Configurable CLI backends.

Limitations:
- Free scenarios, usage caps and card requirements for the underlying agents were not checked. No installed-product test was run.

- ongoing_free — Ongoing free [supported]: The ralph CLI is a free MIT download from npm, Cargo or the release installer. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:src4-license, ralph-orchestrator:src4-install.
- trial — Trial [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish trial for this scoped product.
- credits_trial — Credits trial [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish credits trial for this scoped product.
- self_host_cost — Self host cost [partial]: Runs on the user's machine with no Ralph fee shown; agent provider charges remain separate. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:src4-install.
- paid_only — Paid only [unsupported]: Not paid-only: the application installs free of charge from public channels. Sources: ralph-orchestrator:src4-install.
- early_access — Early access [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish early access for this scoped product.
- free_scenarios — Free scenarios [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish free scenarios for this scoped product.
- card_required — Card required [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish card required for this scoped product.
- usage_caps — Usage caps [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish usage caps for this scoped product.
- paid_evaluation — Paid evaluation [unknown]: The checked first-party sources do not establish paid evaluation for this scoped product.

Checked 2026-11-10 (12 days old on 2026-11-22); agent cross-checked 2026-11-10.

Sources: ralph-orchestrator:src4-license, ralph-orchestrator:src4-install

### OWN-09: Pricing transparency

Verification status: No sourced public finding (not-published)
Support: not-published

No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.

## Sources

### ralph-orchestrator:readme

README.md. Ralph offers CLI/TUI loops, an alpha web dashboard, workspace-scoped MCP server, planning documents, backend selection and Telegram intervention.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/README.md
- Locator: Quick Start; Web Dashboard; MCP; RObot; FAQ
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-08

### ralph-orchestrator:gaps-install

ralph-orchestrator: docs/installation.md. The first-party installation guide explicitly supports macOS, Linux and Windows for the native Ralph CLI. These are terminal clients rather than desktop GUI applications.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/docs/installation.md
- Locator: Prerequisites OS; installation methods
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-13

### ralph-orchestrator:gaps-runtime-boundary

ralph-orchestrator: crates/ralph-cli/src/loops.rs. Bounded inspection of the native loop and alpha web runtime found installed host CLI processes and Git-worktree separation, without product-managed container/VM provisioning, enterprise human SSO or named human team permissions. Hat roles are agent operational roles. publish-review pushes a branch and writes a Markdown handoff; it does not create or manage a pull request.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/crates/ralph-cli/src/loops.rs
- Locator: Loop launch, diff and publish-review operations; core event loop; web backend routes and database schema
- Evidence kind: source-inspected
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-13
- Commit: 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3
- Path: crates/ralph-cli/src/loops.rs

### ralph-orchestrator:backends

docs/guide/backends.md. Names Claude Code, Codex, Gemini CLI, OpenCode and Pi among eleven backends, documents native Claude login and API keys, and per-hat backend overrides.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/docs/guide/backends.md
- Locator: Supported Backends; Backend Setup; Per-Hat Backend Override
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-08

### ralph-orchestrator:cli

docs/guide/cli-reference.md. CLI documents bounded iterations, headless execution, recording, continuation, loop logs/diff/rebase/resume, and memory/task operations.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/docs/guide/cli-reference.md
- Locator: ralph run; loops; tools memory; tools task
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-08

### ralph-orchestrator:parallel

docs/advanced/parallel-loops.md. Concurrent loops have worktrees, separate events/tasks and shared memories. Completed work can enter a merge queue or publish remote review branches; failed merges need review.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/docs/advanced/parallel-loops.md
- Locator: How It Works; Loop States; Auto-Merge Workflow; Remote Review Workflow
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-08

### ralph-orchestrator:memory

docs/advanced/memory-system.md. Memories persist across sessions in .agent/memories.md and include codebase patterns, decisions and recurring solutions.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/docs/advanced/memory-system.md
- Locator: Overview; Memory Types
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-08

### ralph-orchestrator:gaps-hat-coordinator

ralph-orchestrator: crates/ralph-core/src/hatless_ralph.rs. The product always supplies a Hatless Ralph coordinator role. Its shipped prompt instructs that coordinator to delegate through ralph emit events to named specialized hats, and event publishing starts a fresh iteration with clear context. Hats can select distinct coding-agent backends, publish results/events back into the product event loop and retain task/event state. This is product-supplied coordination, not merely display of provider-native subagents.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/crates/ralph-core/src/hatless_ralph.rs
- Locator: HatlessRalph coordinator, HatInfo::event_publishing_guide and workflow_section; docs/guide/backends.md per-hat backends; event_loop/mod.rs
- Evidence kind: source-inspected
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-13
- Commit: 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3
- Path: crates/ralph-core/src/hatless_ralph.rs

### ralph-orchestrator:gaps-api-dispatch

ralph-orchestrator: backend/ralph-web-server/src/api/rest.ts. The alpha legacy Node REST API is explicitly for external consumers. Creating an unblocked task auto-enqueues it unless autoExecute is false, and the product-owned Dispatcher executes it through RalphTaskHandler without a human click for each run. The backend service must remain running; no cron-schedule claim is established.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/backend/ralph-web-server/src/api/rest.ts
- Locator: POST /api/v1/tasks autoExecute; serve.ts Dispatcher setup; runner/RalphTaskHandler.ts
- Evidence kind: source-inspected
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-13
- Commit: 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3
- Path: backend/ralph-web-server/src/api/rest.ts

### ralph-orchestrator:gaps-web-alpha-scope

ralph-orchestrator: public preview availability. The first-party README explicitly labels the web dashboard Alpha, warns of breaking changes, and documents ralph web --legacy-node-api as the opt-in deprecated Node backend. The unattended task-dispatch path and operator-server mode inspected in that backend are publicly enableable experimental paths.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/README.md
- Locator: Web Dashboard (Alpha); ralph web --legacy-node-api opt-in; Development commands
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-13

### ralph-orchestrator:gaps-alpha-server

ralph-orchestrator: backend/ralph-web-server/src/runner/ProcessSupervisor.ts. The documented alpha web command can enable the legacy Node backend. That backend binds an operator-selected network host, starts detached native Ralph processes, persists PID/status/logs and can reconnect after server restarts. Agent work is owned by that server process tree rather than a browser connection. This is a self-hosted alpha mode; no managed Ralph cloud is supplied.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/backend/ralph-web-server/src/runner/ProcessSupervisor.ts
- Locator: spawn detached and unref; api/server.ts host binding; README ralph web --legacy-node-api
- Evidence kind: source-inspected
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-13
- Commit: 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3
- Path: backend/ralph-web-server/src/runner/ProcessSupervisor.ts

### ralph-orchestrator:config

docs/guide/configuration.md. Configuration defines iteration/runtime limits, inactivity timeouts, hook timeouts and per-hat activation limits.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/docs/guide/configuration.md
- Locator: Event Loop; adapters; hooks; hats
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-08

### ralph-orchestrator:gaps-telegram-guidance

ralph-orchestrator: crates/ralph-telegram/src/service.rs. The Telegram integration routes incoming human messages to the selected loop. The polling service passes message text and chat ID to the handler, which appends human.guidance or human.response events to that loop; messages are not restricted to one sender identity in the inspected handler path. Distinct humans can send messages from their separate Telegram accounts (including a shared group chat) to steer the same loop; they do not share an ADE owner bearer credential. Per-human attribution and team permissions are not supplied by this path.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/crates/ralph-telegram/src/service.rs
- Locator: Telegram update polling and MessageHandler::handle_message; handler.rs human.guidance and human.response
- Evidence kind: source-inspected
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-13
- Commit: 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3
- Path: crates/ralph-telegram/src/service.rs

### ralph-orchestrator:gates

docs/concepts/backpressure.md. Documents test/lint/typecheck evidence and reviewer hats, but warns that emitted evidence can be fake. Instructional examples are not proof of enforcement.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/docs/concepts/backpressure.md
- Locator: In Hat Instructions; Implementing Backpressure; Anti-Patterns
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-08

### ralph-orchestrator:license

LICENSE. The repository grants the application source under MIT.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/LICENSE
- Locator: MIT License grant
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-08

### ralph-orchestrator:gaps-diagnostics-control

ralph-orchestrator: crates/ralph-core/src/diagnostics/mod.rs. Ralph diagnostic collection is opt-in through RALPH_DIAGNOSTICS=1. When unset or another value, the collector creates no diagnostic directory or loggers. It controls local agent output, traces, hook-run telemetry and performance JSONL files; provider telemetry is separate.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/crates/ralph-core/src/diagnostics/mod.rs
- Locator: DiagnosticsCollector::new and RALPH_DIAGNOSTICS environment flag
- Evidence kind: source-inspected
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-13
- Commit: 64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3
- Path: crates/ralph-core/src/diagnostics/mod.rs

### ralph-orchestrator:readme-nov10

ralph-orchestrator README. Says the tool is MIT licensed and runs on a backend agent you choose, such as Claude. It mentions no paid plan or price.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/main/README.md
- Locator: Quick start (ralph init --backend); 'License'
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-10

### ralph-orchestrator:license-nov10

mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator LICENSE (MIT). The MIT License lets anyone obtain, use, copy and modify the software free of charge.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/main/LICENSE
- Locator: Permission grant, first paragraph
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-10

### ralph-orchestrator:gaps-provider-keys

ralph-orchestrator: docs/guide/backends.md. The first-party backend setup explicitly accepts user provider API credentials, including ANTHROPIC_API_KEY and GEMINI_API_KEY, as well as native CLI logins. Model usage is billed by the selected provider, separately from the free Ralph software.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/docs/guide/backends.md
- Locator: Backend setup and auth environment variables
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-13

### ralph-orchestrator:release

2.10.1 - 2026-06-22. 2.10.1 - 2026-06-22 was published 2026-06-23. Release notes describe the scoped changes; this is not a hands-on check.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/releases/tag/v2.10.1
- Locator: Release date and release notes
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: 2026-06-23
- Retrieved: 2026-11-08

### ralph-orchestrator:src4-license

Ralph Orchestrator LICENSE. The repository is MIT licensed, copyright Ralph Orchestrator Contributors.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/LICENSE#L1-L3
- Locator: LICENSE lines 1-3, commit 64040fd
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-10

### ralph-orchestrator:src4-install

Ralph Orchestrator README: Installation. Ralph installs free from npm (@ralph-orchestrator/ralph-cli), a GitHub Releases installer script or cargo install ralph-cli; the README names no price, account or paid plan. FUNDING.md asks only for optional GitHub Sponsors donations.

- URL: https://github.com/mikeyobrien/ralph-orchestrator/blob/64040fd0cda4d83386e4d1d1aa65571dadfe00b3/README.md#L19-L40
- Locator: README.md Installation section lines 19-40, commit 64040fd
- Evidence kind: documented
- Source date: Not stated
- Retrieved: 2026-11-10
