{"schemaVersion":7,"rubricVersion":"0.3","canonicalUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/ralph-claude-code/","markdownUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/ralph-claude-code/index.md","dataUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/ralph-claude-code/data.json","rubricUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/rubric/","generatedAt":"2026-11-22","publisher":{"name":"Podium","url":"https://podium.do","marketParticipant":true,"editorialControl":"Podium selects the products, rubric, sources and wording, including for comparisons that do not include Podium, and may add labeled Podium team research without linked sources.","disclosure":"Podium publishes this catalog and sells an agent development environment. Podium chooses the products, criteria, sources and wording, so treat these pages as vendor-authored research. Check important claims against the linked primary sources. Sourced findings follow the same evidence rules for Podium and its competitors. Facts labeled Podium team research come from Podium's own team and have no linked source. None of this removes the conflict of interest."},"attribution":{"dataSource":{"name":"adecomparison.com by Podium","url":"https://adecomparison.com","repository":"https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison"},"license":{"name":"CC BY 4.0","url":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"dataLicenseUrl":"https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison/blob/4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e/DATA-LICENSE.md","snapshot":{"commit":"4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e","commitDate":"2026-11-22","url":"https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison/tree/4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e"},"podiumTeamLabel":"Podium team research","podiumTeamText":"Podium team research is a fact the Podium team added without a linked source. It is labeled wherever it appears, and any differing adecomparison.com finding stays visible beside it.","statement":"Based on data from adecomparison.com by Podium (https://adecomparison.com; source repository https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison, snapshot 4322f0c of 2026-11-22), used under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Source links and check dates are kept. Podium arranges the findings into pairs, applies its publication checks, and added its own research where marked \"Podium team research\"."},"product":{"id":"ralph-claude-code","name":"ralph-claude-code","website":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code","repository":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code","url":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/ralph-claude-code/","lifecycle":{"status":"unknown","note":null},"sourcedClaimCount":50,"crossCheckedClaimCount":0,"sourcedOnlyClaimCount":50,"podiumTeamClaimCount":0,"oldestCheckedAt":"2026-11-08","lastCheckedAt":"2026-11-16","surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"criteria":[{"id":"ACC-01","title":"Client access","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:ACC-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph for Claude Code supplies terminal CLI commands and a tmux status monitor on documented macOS/Linux installations, without a product browser or phone client.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"desktop_os","question":"Desktop os","support":"partial","answer":"Install hints cover Ubuntu/Debian, macOS and CentOS/RHEL and the checks branch only on Darwin; no Windows support statement exists (a closed Git Bash window-spawn issue is listed), so Windows is neither supported nor excluded.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-install","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"mobile_apps","question":"Mobile apps","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected product is a Bash CLI and terminal monitor without native iOS or Android apps.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"browser","question":"Browser","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected product is a Bash CLI and terminal monitor without a browser work interface.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"mobile_browser","question":"Mobile browser","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected product is a Bash CLI and terminal monitor without a phone-browser client.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"cli","question":"Cli","support":"supported","answer":"The installer provides ralph, ralph-monitor, ralph-queue, ralph-import and project setup commands.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"editor_extensions","question":"Editor extensions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No editor extensions in the inspected tree: no editor extension (vscode, jetbrains).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"task_actions","question":"Task actions","support":"partial","answer":"Start with ralph or ralph-queue, stop with Ctrl+C or loop termination, resume with --resume-queue and session flags; no approval or review actions.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"notifications","question":"Notifications","support":"supported","answer":"--notify enables macOS/Linux desktop notifications or terminal bell for loop events.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"cross_device_continuity","question":"Cross device continuity","support":"unsupported","answer":"State is local files; tmux detach keeps a loop running on the same host only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: desktop_os, editor_extensions, task_actions, cross_device_continuity."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","ralph-claude-code:rc-install","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]}},{"id":"ACC-02","title":"Agent and model choice","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:ACC-02","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The shipped loop runs Claude Code; multi-provider abstraction is still listed as in progress. Ralph invokes Claude Code repeatedly and uses explicit --resume session IDs for continuity.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"harnesses","question":"Harnesses","support":"supported","answer":"The shipped loop runs Claude Code; multi-provider abstraction is still listed as in progress.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:adapter-plan"]},{"id":"model_providers","question":"Model providers","support":"partial","answer":"The loop invokes Claude Code only; the Claude model is chosen by the CLI or a flag; multi-provider abstraction is listed as in progress.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-loop"]},{"id":"custom_adapters","question":"Custom adapters","support":"unsupported","answer":"No adapter interface; CLAUDE_CODE_CMD can point at another command line but responses are parsed as Claude output.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-loop","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"session_integration","question":"Session integration","support":"supported","answer":"Ralph invokes Claude Code repeatedly and uses explicit --resume session IDs for continuity.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"mixed_harness_operation","question":"Mixed harness operation","support":"unsupported","answer":"Only one harness (Claude Code) is driven.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-loop"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:adapter-plan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-loop","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"ACC-03","title":"Subscriptions, API keys and vendor credits","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:ACC-03","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Docker execution accepts ANTHROPIC_API_KEY or a scoped copy of existing Claude CLI credentials.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"agent_subscriptions","question":"Agent subscriptions","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph runs the installed claude CLI with its own sign-in on the host; the Docker sandbox copies the user's Claude CLI credentials file when no API key is set. Subscription plan terms were not checked; not tested.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:b4-credentials"]},{"id":"api_accounts","question":"Api accounts","support":"supported","answer":"Docker execution accepts ANTHROPIC_API_KEY or a scoped copy of existing Claude CLI credentials.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:docker"]},{"id":"vendor_credits","question":"Vendor credits","support":"unsupported","answer":"No credits or billing code; the tool is free and charges nothing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"local_models","question":"Local models","support":"unsupported","answer":"No local model support.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"account_switching","question":"Account switching","support":"unsupported","answer":"No multi-account switching.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"vendor_account_requirement","question":"Vendor account requirement","support":"supported","answer":"A Claude login or ANTHROPIC_API_KEY is required for Claude Code; Ralph needs no account of its own.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"provider_restrictions","question":"Provider restrictions","support":"partial","answer":"The Claude API five-hour usage limit is detected and the user is prompted to wait or exit.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:docker","ralph-claude-code:b4-credentials","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]}},{"id":"ACC-04","title":"Onboarding and project prerequisites","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:ACC-04","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Install once, enable or import a project, review .ralph files and run ralph --monitor. README lists Bash, Claude Code, jq, Git, GNU timeout and optional tmux prerequisites.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"first_task_setup","question":"First task setup","support":"supported","answer":"Install once, enable or import a project, review .ralph files and run ralph --monitor.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"no_git","question":"No git","support":"unsupported","answer":"Projects are initialized as git repositories and Git is a stated requirement.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"local_git_without_remote","question":"Local git without remote","support":"supported","answer":"Local git repos work; commits happen per queue item without a remote; only GitHub features need gh.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"hosted_git","question":"Hosted git","support":"supported","answer":"GitHub issue import and lifecycle through gh.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"prerequisite_guidance","question":"Prerequisite guidance","support":"supported","answer":"README lists Bash, Claude Code, jq, Git, GNU timeout and optional tmux prerequisites.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"managed_cloud_setup","question":"Managed cloud setup","support":"partial","answer":"The E2B sandbox needs an E2B key and pip package; there is no Ralph-managed cloud.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"byo_vps_onboarding","question":"Byo vps onboarding","support":"unsupported","answer":"No byo vps onboarding in the inspected tree: no installer or remote-host mode.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"ACC-05","title":"Programmable access","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:ACC-05","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The product CLI inspects state, manages queues, imports work and controls loop settings. ralph-queue add/status/next/reorder/validate/remove/clear/process manage persistent queued work.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"cli","question":"Cli","support":"supported","answer":"The product CLI inspects state, manages queues, imports work and controls loop settings.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:cli","ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"api","question":"Api","support":"unsupported","answer":"No network API; control is through CLI flags and files.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"sdk","question":"Sdk","support":"unsupported","answer":"No sdk in the inspected tree: Ralph is a single-user Bash loop and queue with no such capability.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"mcp_server","question":"Mcp server","support":"unsupported","answer":"No mcp server in the inspected tree: no MCP server.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"webhooks","question":"Webhooks","support":"unsupported","answer":"No webhooks in the inspected tree: no webhook endpoint.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"operations","question":"Operations","support":"supported","answer":"ralph-queue add/status/next/reorder/validate/remove/clear/process manage persistent queued work.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"authentication","question":"Authentication","support":"unsupported","answer":"No authentication layer; access is the local user.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"stability","question":"Stability","support":"unsupported","answer":"README marks the product active development with no stable interface promise.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:cli","ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"ACC-06","title":"External tools and extensions","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:ACC-06","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph has no MCP, plugin or tool layer; it passes an allowed-tools list to Claude Code and imports PRDs.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"mcp_client","question":"Mcp client","support":"unsupported","answer":"Ralph is not an MCP client; MCP belongs to Claude Code.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"plugins","question":"Plugins","support":"unsupported","answer":"No plugins in the inspected tree: no plugin host.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"custom_tools","question":"Custom tools","support":"partial","answer":"ALLOWED_TOOLS passes a tool allow list to Claude Code; there is no custom tool registry.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"instructions_import","question":"Instructions import","support":"supported","answer":"PRD imports populate .ralph prompt, specs and task checklist files.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:files","ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"authentication","question":"Authentication","support":"unsupported","answer":"No integration authentication beyond gh and Claude logins.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"permission_scope","question":"Permission scope","support":"partial","answer":"Allowed tools come from repository-controlled .ralphrc.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"integration_owner","question":"Integration owner","support":"supported","answer":"GitHub via gh and sandbox providers are product shell code; MCP and tools are inherited from Claude Code.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:files","ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]}},{"id":"ACC-07","title":"Client implementation","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:ACC-07","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph has no GUI client: it is Bash scripts with a tmux dashboard, so there is no desktop or mobile client implementation.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"desktop_implementation","question":"Desktop implementation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No desktop client; Bash scripts and a tmux dashboard.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-loop","ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]},{"id":"mobile_implementation","question":"Mobile implementation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No mobile client.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"hybrids","question":"Hybrids","support":"unsupported","answer":"No hybrid client.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"implementation_evidence","question":"Implementation evidence","support":"supported","answer":"Shell sources in the repository at the pinned commit.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-loop"]}],"limitations":["Partial: desktop_implementation (unsupported), mobile_implementation (unsupported), hybrids (unsupported). See each atomic answer for the limit and its evidence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-05-15","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-loop","ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"PLAN-01","title":"Intake and external tracker relationship","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:PLAN-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"A local PRD file can be added to the persistent queue without a GitHub issue. GitHub issues import with labels, priority, milestone and parsed dependencies. GitHub issue bodies are fetched again at processing time; this is not documented as bidirectional issue synchronization.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"local_creation","question":"Local creation","support":"supported","answer":"A local PRD file can be added to the persistent queue without a GitHub issue.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"prompt_intake","question":"Prompt intake","support":"supported","answer":"PROMPT.md and PRD import (md, txt, json) plus ralph-enable wizards.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"external_import","question":"External import","support":"supported","answer":"GitHub issues import with labels, priority, milestone and parsed dependencies.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"chat_git_triggers","question":"Chat git triggers","support":"unsupported","answer":"No chat or Git event trigger; GitHub issues are pulled by command.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"authoritative_tracker","question":"Authoritative tracker","support":"supported","answer":"GitHub is authoritative for imported issues; local PRD items are file-based.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"stable_ids","question":"Stable ids","support":"supported","answer":"Queue items keep GitHub issue numbers.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"sync","question":"Sync","support":"partial","answer":"GitHub issue bodies are fetched again at processing time; this is not documented as bidirectional issue synchronization.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"supported_edits","question":"Supported edits","support":"partial","answer":"Comments, labels, PR creation and close are written back; titles and fields are not edited.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"external_roundtrips","question":"External roundtrips","support":"supported","answer":"Creating or editing issues needs GitHub.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]}},{"id":"PLAN-02","title":"Durable task plans","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:PLAN-02","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"fix_plan.md holds prioritized checkbox tasks while specs holds detailed requirements. Users edit Markdown plans and specifications directly. The queue JSON persists across restarts; processing items from interrupted runs reset to pending on resume.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"plans","question":"Plans","support":"supported","answer":"fix_plan.md holds prioritized checkbox tasks while specs holds detailed requirements.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:files"]},{"id":"acceptance_criteria","question":"Acceptance criteria","support":"partial","answer":"Issue completeness assessment scores acceptance detail; no acceptance-criteria field.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"editors","question":"Editors","support":"supported","answer":"Users edit Markdown plans and specifications directly.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:files"]},{"id":"revisions","question":"Revisions","support":"partial","answer":"fix_plan.md and specs are plain files tracked by git; no plan revision feature.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"implementation_links","question":"Implementation links","support":"supported","answer":"Queue commits are named Fix #N and PRs link with Closes #N.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"amendment","question":"Amendment","support":"supported","answer":"The user edits fix_plan.md between or during loops.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"restart_persistence","question":"Restart persistence","support":"supported","answer":"The queue JSON persists across restarts; processing items from interrupted runs reset to pending on resume.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:files","ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]}},{"id":"PLAN-03","title":"Hierarchy, dependencies and evolving scope","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:PLAN-03","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"depends on, blocked by and requires references inside issue bodies become queue dependencies. A queued item becomes ready only after all referenced in-queue dependencies complete; circular dependencies are refused.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"epics","question":"Epics","support":"unsupported","answer":"No epic object; the queue is a flat list.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"hierarchy","question":"Hierarchy","support":"unsupported","answer":"No hierarchy; dependencies are between flat items.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"blockers","question":"Blockers","support":"supported","answer":"depends on, blocked by and requires references inside issue bodies become queue dependencies.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"readiness","question":"Readiness","support":"supported","answer":"An item is ready when all its in-queue dependencies are complete.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"enforcement","question":"Enforcement","support":"supported","answer":"A queued item becomes ready only after all referenced in-queue dependencies complete; circular dependencies are refused.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"state_propagation","question":"State propagation","support":"partial","answer":"Failure marks the item and either halts or skips; blocked dependents are not run.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"task_to_epic","question":"Task to epic","support":"unsupported","answer":"No growth path.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"identity_retention","question":"Identity retention","support":"unsupported","answer":"Not applicable.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"workflow_constraints","question":"Workflow constraints","support":"partial","answer":"The loop requires .ralph files; queue processing is serial.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"PLAN-04","title":"Shared context and memory","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:PLAN-04","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"PROMPT.md, AGENT.md and specs/ supply project requirements and build guidance. Explicit Claude session IDs preserve loop context until configured expiry or reset.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"instructions","question":"Instructions","support":"supported","answer":"PROMPT.md, AGENT.md and specs/ supply project requirements and build guidance.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:files"]},{"id":"skills","question":"Skills","support":"unsupported","answer":"No skills in the inspected tree: no skill installation or loader.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"project_docs","question":"Project docs","support":"supported","answer":"PROMPT.md, AGENT.md and specs/ are project docs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"memory","question":"Memory","support":"partial","answer":"Explicit Claude session IDs preserve loop context until configured expiry or reset.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"scope","question":"Scope","support":"partial","answer":"Project-scoped .ralph files; session id scope per project.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"provenance","question":"Provenance","support":"unsupported","answer":"No provenance for context.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"correction","question":"Correction","support":"supported","answer":"Users edit the files directly.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"deletion","question":"Deletion","support":"supported","answer":"Delete files or reset the session with a flag.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"freshness","question":"Freshness","support":"partial","answer":"Session expiry and reset controls.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"takeover_continuity","question":"Takeover continuity","support":"partial","answer":"Files and session id persist on disk; a colleague needs the same checkout.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:files","ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"PLAN-05","title":"Architecture and API awareness","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:PLAN-05","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"unsupported","answer":"No retrieval or architecture awareness beyond the instruction files.","availability":"unknown","delivery":"unknown","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"code_search","question":"Code search","support":"unsupported","answer":"No code search in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"indexing","question":"Indexing","support":"unsupported","answer":"No indexing in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"external_knowledge","question":"External knowledge","support":"unsupported","answer":"No external knowledge in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"multimodal_inputs","question":"Multimodal inputs","support":"unsupported","answer":"No multimodal inputs in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"freshness","question":"Freshness","support":"unsupported","answer":"No freshness in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"access_scope","question":"Access scope","support":"unsupported","answer":"No access scope in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"api_retrieval","question":"Api retrieval","support":"unsupported","answer":"No api retrieval in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"citations","question":"Citations","support":"unsupported","answer":"No citations in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"conflict_detection","question":"Conflict detection","support":"unsupported","answer":"No conflict detection in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"review_enforcement","question":"Review enforcement","support":"unsupported","answer":"No review enforcement in the inspected tree: no code index, retrieval or citation features (searched embedding, index, rag, openapi).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"PLAN-06","title":"Native issue management and idea backlog","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:PLAN-06","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"A persistent queue of tasks with priority, dependencies and state exists, and fix_plan.md holds task checklists; it lacks discussion, assignment, labels of its own, search and project views, and GitHub remains the issue tracker.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"create","question":"Create","support":"supported","answer":"Local PRD queue entries can exist before explicit processing starts.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"edit","question":"Edit","support":"partial","answer":"Edit markdown tasks directly.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"discuss","question":"Discuss","support":"unsupported","answer":"No discussion.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"prioritize","question":"Prioritize","support":"supported","answer":"Queue priorities come from labels and support persisted reorder.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"label","question":"Label","support":"partial","answer":"Priority labels P0-P9 are read from GitHub.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"assign","question":"Assign","support":"unsupported","answer":"No assignment.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"search","question":"Search","support":"partial","answer":"GitHub metadata filters at import time.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"filter","question":"Filter","support":"supported","answer":"Label, assignee, milestone and title filters.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"archive","question":"Archive","support":"partial","answer":"Completed items stay in queue state until cleared.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"reopen","question":"Reopen","support":"partial","answer":"Queue resume picks up pending items only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"project_epic_views","question":"Project epic views","support":"unsupported","answer":"No views.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"idea_parking","question":"Idea parking","support":"supported","answer":"Add items to the queue without processing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"explicit_dispatch","question":"Explicit dispatch","support":"supported","answer":"Adding an item is separate from --process-queue or --resume-queue.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"task_session_separation","question":"Task session separation","support":"partial","answer":"Queue items run in separate loop sessions.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"metadata","question":"Metadata","support":"partial","answer":"Priority, dependencies and issue number.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"durable_states","question":"Durable states","support":"supported","answer":"Queue items retain pending, processing, completed, failed and skipped states.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"external_tracker_requirement","question":"External tracker requirement","support":"partial","answer":"GitHub is needed for issue operations; local PRD items need no tracker.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]}},{"id":"PLAN-07","title":"Agent-native issue operations","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:PLAN-07","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"An agent can call ralph-queue commands like any shell user; there are no agent-specific issue APIs or attributed writes.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"shared_ids","question":"Shared ids","support":"supported","answer":"Queue ids and issue numbers are shared.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"read","question":"Read","support":"partial","answer":"Documented CLI reads persistent queue status and next ready item. Agent access to the same CLI is possible but no installed agent-write fixture was run.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"create","question":"Create","support":"partial","answer":"ralph-queue add by a shell user or agent.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"update","question":"Update","support":"unsupported","answer":"No item update command beyond reorder and remove.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"claim","question":"Claim","support":"unsupported","answer":"No claim.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"assign","question":"Assign","support":"unsupported","answer":"No assign.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"state_changes","question":"State changes","support":"partial","answer":"The loop marks items processing, completed or failed.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"dependencies","question":"Dependencies","support":"partial","answer":"Dependencies are parsed from issue bodies.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"children","question":"Children","support":"unsupported","answer":"No children.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"results","question":"Results","support":"partial","answer":"Results are logs and PR or comment text.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"human_visibility","question":"Human visibility","support":"supported","answer":"Queue status shows state.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"attribution","question":"Attribution","support":"unsupported","answer":"No attribution.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"permissions","question":"Permissions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No permissions.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"conflicts","question":"Conflicts","support":"unsupported","answer":"Duplicate IDs are skipped; no conflict handling.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]}},{"id":"PLAN-08","title":"Living product specifications","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:PLAN-08","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"No living specification system beyond specs/ files the user edits.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"persistent_requirements","question":"Persistent requirements","support":"partial","answer":"specs/ files persist across loops but are not managed requirements.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"human_edits","question":"Human edits","support":"partial","answer":"Edit specs files directly.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"agent_edits","question":"Agent edits","support":"unsupported","answer":"No agent edits in the inspected tree: specs are plain files with no revision, approval, retrieval or drift features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"revisions","question":"Revisions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No revisions in the inspected tree: specs are plain files with no revision, approval, retrieval or drift features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"approvals","question":"Approvals","support":"unsupported","answer":"No approvals in the inspected tree: specs are plain files with no revision, approval, retrieval or drift features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"implementation_links","question":"Implementation links","support":"unsupported","answer":"No implementation links in the inspected tree: specs are plain files with no revision, approval, retrieval or drift features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"later_retrieval","question":"Later retrieval","support":"unsupported","answer":"No later retrieval in the inspected tree: specs are plain files with no revision, approval, retrieval or drift features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"drift_detection","question":"Drift detection","support":"unsupported","answer":"No drift detection in the inspected tree: specs are plain files with no revision, approval, retrieval or drift features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"review_integration","question":"Review integration","support":"unsupported","answer":"No review integration in the inspected tree: specs are plain files with no revision, approval, retrieval or drift features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Partial: persistent_requirements (partial), human_edits (partial), agent_edits (unsupported), revisions (unsupported), approvals (unsupported), implementation_links (unsupported), later_retrieval (unsupported), drift_detection (unsupported), review_integration (unsupported). See each atomic answer for the limit and its evidence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"COORD-01","title":"Parallel work","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:COORD-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph queue processing is intentionally serial, with one item at a time on a single branch.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"concurrent_sessions","question":"Concurrent sessions","support":"unsupported","answer":"The first-party queue documentation explicitly excludes concurrent/parallel processing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-serial-queue"]},{"id":"concurrent_tasks","question":"Concurrent tasks","support":"unsupported","answer":"Queue items are processed one at a time.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-serial-queue"]},{"id":"quotas","question":"Quotas","support":"supported","answer":"MAX_CALLS_PER_HOUR (default 100) and optional token budget.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"observed_concurrency","question":"Observed concurrency","support":"partial","answer":"Queue processing is intentionally serial; no concurrency measured.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"status_visibility","question":"Status visibility","support":"supported","answer":"Monitor shows loop status, API usage and queue totals.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: quotas, observed_concurrency, status_visibility."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-serial-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]}},{"id":"COORD-02","title":"Ownership and dispatch","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:COORD-02","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"A serial queue orders ready items by priority; there is no assignment, routing or ownership model.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"human_assignment","question":"Human assignment","support":"unsupported","answer":"No assignment.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"agent_assignment","question":"Agent assignment","support":"unsupported","answer":"No assignment.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"claims","question":"Claims","support":"unsupported","answer":"No claims.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"queues","question":"Queues","support":"supported","answer":"Duplicate queue IDs are skipped; ready items run in priority/FIFO order.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"routing","question":"Routing","support":"unsupported","answer":"No routing; priority order only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"duplicate_prevention","question":"Duplicate prevention","support":"supported","answer":"Duplicate queue IDs are skipped.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"ownership_enforcement","question":"Ownership enforcement","support":"unsupported","answer":"No ownership enforcement.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]}},{"id":"COORD-03","title":"Inspectable delegation and communication","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:COORD-03","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph repeats one Claude Code loop without a product-supplied agent coordinator or independent agent-session delegation/message tools.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"roles","question":"Roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No roles in the inspected tree: one Claude Code loop with no delegation, child agents or messaging tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"model_harness_effort","question":"Model harness effort","support":"partial","answer":"A model can be named for plan generation; no per-agent effort control.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"messages","question":"Messages","support":"unsupported","answer":"No messages in the inspected tree: one Claude Code loop with no delegation, child agents or messaging tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"results_return","question":"Results return","support":"unsupported","answer":"No results return in the inspected tree: one Claude Code loop with no delegation, child agents or messaging tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"cross_harness","question":"Cross harness","support":"unsupported","answer":"No cross harness in the inspected tree: one Claude Code loop with no delegation, child agents or messaging tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"orchestration_owner","question":"Orchestration owner","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected product supplies a sequential host loop, not a coordinator-agent role with independent-worker delegation tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","ralph-claude-code:gaps-serial-queue"]},{"id":"activation","question":"Activation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No activation in the inspected tree: one Claude Code loop with no delegation, child agents or messaging tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"authentication","question":"Authentication","support":"unsupported","answer":"No authentication in the inspected tree: one Claude Code loop with no delegation, child agents or messaging tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"live_progress","question":"Live progress","support":"supported","answer":"Live output streams to .ralph/live.log and the monitor.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"retained_results","question":"Retained results","support":"unsupported","answer":"No retained results in the inspected tree: one Claude Code loop with no delegation, child agents or messaging tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"followup","question":"Followup","support":"unsupported","answer":"No followup in the inspected tree: one Claude Code loop with no delegation, child agents or messaging tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"invocation","question":"Invocation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No invocation in the inspected tree: one Claude Code loop with no delegation, child agents or messaging tools.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: roles, model_harness_effort, messages, results_return, cross_harness, activation, authentication, live_progress, retained_results, followup, invocation."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","ralph-claude-code:gaps-serial-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"COORD-04","title":"Unattended triggers","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:COORD-04","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph checks completion inside a manually started loop; the product has no schedule or external-event intake that starts new work.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"schedules","question":"Schedules","support":"unsupported","answer":"No schedule runner is implemented in the inspected CLI/runtime.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"events","question":"Events","support":"unsupported","answer":"Notifications are outgoing; there is no incoming event trigger for agent starts.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"recurring_tasks","question":"Recurring tasks","support":"unsupported","answer":"No recurring schedule; a loop is started manually.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"completion_conditions","question":"Completion conditions","support":"supported","answer":"Loop exit combines completion indicators with EXIT_SIGNAL; optional checklist sections do not block completion.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"scheduler_location","question":"Scheduler location","support":"unsupported","answer":"No scheduler.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"overlaps","question":"Overlaps","support":"unsupported","answer":"No overlaps; one loop at a time.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"retries","question":"Retries","support":"partial","answer":"Circuit breaker cooldown and auto-reset govern repeated failures; queue failures are skipped or halt.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"client_independence","question":"Client independence","support":"partial","answer":"A loop in tmux survives the terminal client on the same host.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: recurring_tasks, scheduler_location, overlaps, retries, client_independence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"COORD-05","title":"Intervention and attention","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:COORD-05","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ctrl+C interrupts the monitor; loop termination and session reset are separately documented. Open reports about SIGTERM waits were not resolved by this pass. --notify reports key loop events.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"pause","question":"Pause","support":"unsupported","answer":"No pause; stop with Ctrl+C.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"stop","question":"Stop","support":"partial","answer":"Ctrl+C interrupts the monitor; loop termination and session reset are separately documented. Open reports about SIGTERM waits were not resolved by this pass.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"resume","question":"Resume","support":"supported","answer":"--resume-queue and session continuity flags.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"steer","question":"Steer","support":"partial","answer":"Edit prompt or fix_plan files between loops; no live steering.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"notifications","question":"Notifications","support":"supported","answer":"--notify reports key loop events.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"pending_decisions","question":"Pending decisions","support":"partial","answer":"Prompts the user at the Claude usage limit.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"escalation","question":"Escalation","support":"partial","answer":"--notify reports key loop events.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"visible_errors","question":"Visible errors","support":"supported","answer":"Circuit breaker state and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"chat_terminal_parity","question":"Chat terminal parity","support":"supported","answer":"Terminal only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]},{"id":"retained_history","question":"Retained history","support":"supported","answer":"Logs and the last 50 session transitions persist.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]}},{"id":"COORD-06","title":"Fleet and epic management UI","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:COORD-06","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"A tmux status monitor and queue status show one loop and queue totals; there is no multi-epic fleet UI.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"fleet_fixture","question":"Fleet fixture","support":"unsupported","answer":"No fleet fixture in the inspected tree: monitor shows one loop and queue counts only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"parent_child","question":"Parent child","support":"unsupported","answer":"No parent child in the inspected tree: monitor shows one loop and queue counts only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"dependencies","question":"Dependencies","support":"unsupported","answer":"No dependencies in the inspected tree: monitor shows one loop and queue counts only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"attention","question":"Attention","support":"partial","answer":"Status line and --notify.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]},{"id":"history","question":"History","support":"partial","answer":"Monitor and logs show loop history.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]},{"id":"workload","question":"Workload","support":"unsupported","answer":"No workload in the inspected tree: monitor shows one loop and queue counts only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"navigation_errors","question":"Navigation errors","support":"unsupported","answer":"No navigation errors in the inspected tree: monitor shows one loop and queue counts only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"fixture_mode","question":"Fixture mode","support":"unsupported","answer":"No fixture mode in the inspected tree: monitor shows one loop and queue counts only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Partial: fleet_fixture (unsupported), parent_child (unsupported), dependencies (unsupported), attention (partial), history (partial), workload (unsupported), navigation_errors (unsupported), fixture_mode (unsupported). See each atomic answer for the limit and its evidence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]}},{"id":"COORD-07","title":"Workflow flexibility and orchestration visibility","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:COORD-07","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Quick use needs only ralph in a project; configuration is by files and flags rather than natural language.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"quick_task","question":"Quick task","support":"supported","answer":"ralph in a prepared project runs immediately.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"growing_epic","question":"Growing epic","support":"unsupported","answer":"No epics.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"presets","question":"Presets","support":"partial","answer":"Project templates and a setup wizard.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"natural_language","question":"Natural language","support":"unsupported","answer":"No natural-language configuration.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"agent_configuration","question":"Agent configuration","support":"partial","answer":"Flags for timeout, calls, tools, model for plan generation.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"in_run_changes","question":"In run changes","support":"partial","answer":"Edits to .ralph files affect later loops.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"live_roles","question":"Live roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No roles.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"retained_relationships","question":"Retained relationships","support":"unsupported","answer":"No relationships.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"discoverability","question":"Discoverability","support":"supported","answer":"ralph --help and README.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"auth_friction","question":"Auth friction","support":"supported","answer":"Only the Claude login.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Partial: growing_epic (unsupported), presets (partial), natural_language (unsupported), agent_configuration (partial), in_run_changes (partial), live_roles (unsupported), retained_relationships (unsupported). See each atomic answer for the limit and its evidence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"RUN-01","title":"Laptop-independent execution","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:RUN-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The loop and default Claude execution run on the current host. --sandbox e2b moves Claude execution to E2B while orchestration and file sync stay on the host. tmux detach keeps Ralph running on that same host; remote E2B execution does not move host orchestration.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"local","question":"Local","support":"supported","answer":"The loop and default Claude execution run on the current host.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"byo_remote","question":"Byo remote","support":"unsupported","answer":"No remote-host execution mode; Docker is local and E2B is a vendor sandbox.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"self_hosted","question":"Self hosted","support":"unsupported","answer":"No server component.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"managed_cloud","question":"Managed cloud","support":"supported","answer":"--sandbox e2b moves Claude execution to E2B while orchestration and file sync stay on the host.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:e2b"]},{"id":"hybrid","question":"Hybrid","support":"supported","answer":"With --sandbox e2b the loop stays on the host while Claude runs in the sandbox.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"provisioning","question":"Provisioning","support":"supported","answer":"E2B sandboxes are created automatically from a template; Docker containers from an image.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"payer","question":"Payer","support":"supported","answer":"The user pays E2B directly; Ralph is free.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"resources","question":"Resources","support":"supported","answer":"Docker memory and CPU flags; E2B template.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"region","question":"Region","support":"unsupported","answer":"No region control.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"expiry","question":"Expiry","support":"supported","answer":"E2B sandbox timeout (default configurable, expired sandboxes auto-recreate).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"client_disconnect","question":"Client disconnect","support":"partial","answer":"tmux detach keeps Ralph running on that same host; remote E2B execution does not move host orchestration.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:e2b"]},{"id":"other_device_continuation","question":"Other device continuation","support":"partial","answer":"A kept-alive E2B sandbox can be reused by id, but the host loop must run.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:e2b","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"RUN-02","title":"Workspace and process isolation","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:RUN-02","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph offers optional Docker execution and an E2B Linux-VM sandbox. The host loop retains orchestration and file sync; it does not provision Git worktrees.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"checkout","question":"Checkout","support":"supported","answer":"Runs in the project checkout (or synced copy in E2B).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"branch","question":"Branch","support":"supported","answer":"One branch; commits per item on the current branch.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"worktree","question":"Worktree","support":"unsupported","answer":"The loop uses the existing checkout and optional backup branches; there is no product-managed Git worktree creation.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"container","question":"Container","support":"supported","answer":"--sandbox docker uses a persistent container with the project bind-mounted read-write.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:docker"]},{"id":"vm","question":"Vm","support":"supported","answer":"The optional E2B adapter executes Claude in the E2B Sandbox object, which E2B documents as an isolated Linux VM.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-e2b-vm","ralph-claude-code:e2b"]},{"id":"os_sandbox","question":"Os sandbox","support":"unsupported","answer":"No OS sandbox; Docker or E2B VM instead.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"filesystem","question":"Filesystem","support":"partial","answer":"Docker container filesystem or E2B VM; none on the host loop.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"process","question":"Process","support":"partial","answer":"Persistent container or sandbox process.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"network","question":"Network","support":"supported","answer":"Docker supports bridge, none or explicit host networking; repository config is restricted to safer stock choices.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:docker"]},{"id":"secrets","question":"Secrets","support":"supported","answer":"API key via 0600 env-file or scoped credentials copy.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"code_separation","question":"Code separation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No worktrees; one branch.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"security_boundary","question":"Security boundary","support":"partial","answer":"Docker network and resource flags; no hostile-code claim.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: checkout, branch, os_sandbox, filesystem, process, secrets, code_separation, security_boundary."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:docker","ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","ralph-claude-code:gaps-e2b-vm","ralph-claude-code:e2b","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]}},{"id":"RUN-03","title":"Recovery, expiry and continuity","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:RUN-03","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"E2B expiry can recreate the sandbox and upload project files again. This is distinct from preserving a live model process. Interrupted processing items reset to pending when the queue resumes; completed and failed items remain recorded. Claude sessions expire after 24 hours by default and support explicit reset.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"client_disconnect","question":"Client disconnect","support":"partial","answer":"A tmux session continues if the terminal closes.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"worker_crash","question":"Worker crash","support":"partial","answer":"Interrupted processing items reset to pending.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"service_restart","question":"Service restart","support":"unsupported","answer":"No service.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"expiry","question":"Expiry","support":"partial","answer":"E2B expiry can recreate the sandbox and upload project files again. This is distinct from preserving a live model process.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:e2b"]},{"id":"transcript_reload","question":"Transcript reload","support":"partial","answer":"Logs persist; Claude session id resumes context.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"process_reconnect","question":"Process reconnect","support":"partial","answer":"Reattach to the tmux session.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"task_resume","question":"Task resume","support":"supported","answer":"Interrupted processing items reset to pending when the queue resumes; completed and failed items remain recorded.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"state_reconstruction","question":"State reconstruction","support":"supported","answer":"Queue and session state in JSON files.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"context_loss","question":"Context loss","support":"supported","answer":"Claude sessions expire after 24 hours by default and support explicit reset.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"duplicate_actions","question":"Duplicate actions","support":"partial","answer":"Queue resume only picks up pending items.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"manual_repair","question":"Manual repair","support":"partial","answer":"Circuit breaker reset flags.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"multi_day_continuity","question":"Multi day continuity","support":"partial","answer":"Queue resume and sandbox re-creation allow it on the same host.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:e2b","ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]}},{"id":"RUN-04","title":"Development environment reliability","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:RUN-04","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"E2B bootstraps Claude CLI on the default template or accepts a prebuilt custom template. Docker scopes API-key files or copies native Claude credentials into a temporary per-run directory.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"dependencies","question":"Dependencies","support":"supported","answer":"E2B bootstraps Claude CLI on the default template or accepts a prebuilt custom template.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:e2b"]},{"id":"caches","question":"Caches","support":"unsupported","answer":"No cache management; sync filters can exclude node_modules.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"snapshots","question":"Snapshots","support":"partial","answer":"Git backup branches with --backup.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"services","question":"Services","support":"unsupported","answer":"No service provisioning.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"ports","question":"Ports","support":"unsupported","answer":"No port handling.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"secrets","question":"Secrets","support":"supported","answer":"Docker scopes API-key files or copies native Claude credentials into a temporary per-run directory.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:docker"]},{"id":"duplicate_installs","question":"Duplicate installs","support":"unsupported","answer":"No handling.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"collisions","question":"Collisions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No handling.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"remote_setup","question":"Remote setup","support":"supported","answer":"E2B bootstraps the Claude CLI on the default template.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"automatic_repair","question":"Automatic repair","support":"unsupported","answer":"No automatic environment repair.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:e2b","ralph-claude-code:docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"RUN-05","title":"Limits and failure handling","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:RUN-05","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Claude invocation timeouts are configurable from 1 to 120 minutes. Circuit-breaker cooldown and auto-reset controls bound repeated no-progress/error loops. Hourly call limits and dual-condition completion checks stop or delay loop work.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"time_limits","question":"Time limits","support":"supported","answer":"Claude invocation timeouts are configurable from 1 to 120 minutes.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"turn_limits","question":"Turn limits","support":"unsupported","answer":"No turn limit flag.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"token_limits","question":"Token limits","support":"supported","answer":"MAX_TOKENS_PER_HOUR budget (default off).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"spend_limits","question":"Spend limits","support":"partial","answer":"E2B --sandbox-max-cost stops on estimated sandbox cost; no model spend limit.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"timeouts","question":"Timeouts","support":"supported","answer":"Per-invocation timeout of 1 to 120 minutes.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"retries","question":"Retries","support":"supported","answer":"Circuit-breaker cooldown and auto-reset controls bound repeated no-progress/error loops.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"provider_failures","question":"Provider failures","support":"supported","answer":"API errors feed the circuit breaker and the five-hour limit prompt.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"enforcement","question":"Enforcement","support":"supported","answer":"Hourly call limits and dual-condition completion checks stop or delay loop work.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]}},{"id":"RUN-06","title":"Truthful status and operational statistics","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:RUN-06","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The monitor shows local logs, loop count, API-call usage and queue totals from JSON state. Queue monitor reports pending, active, completed and failed item totals.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"logs","question":"Logs","support":"supported","answer":"The monitor shows local logs, loop count, API-call usage and queue totals from JSON state.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:monitor"]},{"id":"traces","question":"Traces","support":"unsupported","answer":"No traces.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"failure_reasons","question":"Failure reasons","support":"supported","answer":"Circuit breaker records error causes and state history.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"usage_export","question":"Usage export","support":"partial","answer":"ralph --status prints JSON.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"task_stats","question":"Task stats","support":"partial","answer":"Queue totals.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]},{"id":"agent_stats","question":"Agent stats","support":"unsupported","answer":"No agent stats.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"project_stats","question":"Project stats","support":"partial","answer":"Loop and API usage for the project.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor"]},{"id":"time_stats","question":"Time stats","support":"partial","answer":"Hourly call and token counters.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"failure_status","question":"Failure status","support":"supported","answer":"Queue monitor reports pending, active, completed and failed item totals.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:monitor"]},{"id":"approval_status","question":"Approval status","support":"unsupported","answer":"No approvals.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"reconnect_consistency","question":"Reconnect consistency","support":"partial","answer":"State files are the source of truth after reattach.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"performance_method","question":"Performance method","support":"unsupported","answer":"None; ADEMark is the catalog source.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"responsiveness","question":"Responsiveness","support":"unsupported","answer":"No figures.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:monitor","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]}},{"id":"RUN-07","title":"Per-task API and compute cost","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:RUN-07","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Cost visibility is limited to hourly call and token counts and an E2B sandbox hourly estimate.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"task_cost","question":"Task cost","support":"unsupported","answer":"No per-task cost.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"session_cost","question":"Session cost","support":"unsupported","answer":"No session cost.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"child_cost","question":"Child cost","support":"unsupported","answer":"No child cost.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"epic_cost","question":"Epic cost","support":"unsupported","answer":"No epic cost.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"harness_aggregation","question":"Harness aggregation","support":"unsupported","answer":"One harness only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"billed_vs_estimated","question":"Billed vs estimated","support":"partial","answer":"E2B sandbox cost uses an estimated hourly rate, not a reconciled provider invoice.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:e2b"]},{"id":"tokens","question":"Tokens","support":"supported","answer":"input plus output tokens are summed per hour.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"subscription_allowance","question":"Subscription allowance","support":"partial","answer":"Five-hour limit detection.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"provider_reconciliation","question":"Provider reconciliation","support":"unsupported","answer":"E2B cost is an estimate, not reconciled.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"compute_cost","question":"Compute cost","support":"supported","answer":"E2B sandbox estimates, alerts and --sandbox-max-cost are documented separately from model spend.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:e2b"]},{"id":"refresh_delay","question":"Refresh delay","support":"partial","answer":"Counters update each loop.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"alerts","question":"Alerts","support":"supported","answer":"E2B --sandbox-cost-alert.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"export","question":"Export","support":"partial","answer":"ralph --status JSON.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"drilldown","question":"Drilldown","support":"unsupported","answer":"No drill-down.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:e2b","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]}},{"id":"RUN-08","title":"Compute-aware scheduling and verification","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:RUN-08","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The queue is sequential on one branch, not a documented parallel fleet scheduler. Docker defaults to 4g memory and 2 CPUs with explicit override flags.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"concurrency","question":"Concurrency","support":"supported","answer":"Serial by design: one loop and one queue item at a time.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"queues","question":"Queues","support":"partial","answer":"The queue is sequential on one branch, not a documented parallel fleet scheduler.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"cpu_ram","question":"Cpu ram","support":"supported","answer":"Docker defaults to 4g memory and 2 CPUs with explicit override flags.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:docker"]},{"id":"backpressure","question":"Backpressure","support":"partial","answer":"Hourly rate limits wait for reset.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"host_awareness","question":"Host awareness","support":"unsupported","answer":"No host resource awareness; Docker has fixed limits.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"check_reuse","question":"Check reuse","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"check_deduplication","question":"Check deduplication","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"bounded_tests","question":"Bounded tests","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"cancellation","question":"Cancellation","support":"partial","answer":"Ctrl+C stops the loop and cleans up sandboxes.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"fairness","question":"Fairness","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"recovery","question":"Recovery","support":"supported","answer":"Queue resume.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"shared_limits","question":"Shared limits","support":"unsupported","answer":"Limits are per project directory.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"TEAM-01","title":"Live human collaboration","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:TEAM-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"unsupported","answer":"Single local user; no shared sessions or presence.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"visibility","question":"Visibility","support":"unsupported","answer":"No visibility in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"discussion","question":"Discussion","support":"unsupported","answer":"No discussion in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"comments","question":"Comments","support":"unsupported","answer":"No comments in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"presence","question":"Presence","support":"unsupported","answer":"No presence in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"coprompting","question":"Coprompting","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected CLI/runtime exposes no multi-human prompting service or shared session input model.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"ordering","question":"Ordering","support":"unsupported","answer":"No ordering in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"conflicts","question":"Conflicts","support":"unsupported","answer":"No conflicts in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"attribution","question":"Attribution","support":"unsupported","answer":"No attribution in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"permissions","question":"Permissions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No permissions in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"plan_restrictions","question":"Plan restrictions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No plan restrictions in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"owner_online","question":"Owner online","support":"unsupported","answer":"No owner online in the inspected tree: a local single-user CLI with no sharing.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: visibility, discussion, comments, presence, ordering, conflicts, attribution, permissions, plan_restrictions, owner_online."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"TEAM-02","title":"Roles and access boundaries","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:TEAM-02","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph has no product-owned human identity service, named team roles or enterprise SSO.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"organization_roles","question":"Organization roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No human organization/workspace role-permission model exists in the inspected CLI.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"project_roles","question":"Project roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No project roles in the inspected tree: no accounts, roles or plans.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"task_roles","question":"Task roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No task roles in the inspected tree: no accounts, roles or plans.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"membership","question":"Membership","support":"unsupported","answer":"No membership in the inspected tree: no accounts, roles or plans.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"sso","question":"Sso","support":"unsupported","answer":"The product has no enterprise SSO implementation; Claude/provider logins remain separate.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"provisioning","question":"Provisioning","support":"unsupported","answer":"No provisioning in the inspected tree: no accounts, roles or plans.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"unauthorized_access","question":"Unauthorized access","support":"partial","answer":"Local filesystem permissions only; credentials files are 0600.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"revocation","question":"Revocation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No revocation in the inspected tree: no accounts, roles or plans.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"plan_scope","question":"Plan scope","support":"unsupported","answer":"No plan scope in the inspected tree: no accounts, roles or plans.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: project_roles, task_roles, membership, provisioning, unauthorized_access, revocation, plan_scope."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]}},{"id":"TEAM-03","title":"Approvals and temporary access","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:TEAM-03","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Tool permissions are an allow list passed to Claude Code from repository configuration; no product approval flow exists.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"command","question":"Command","support":"partial","answer":"ALLOWED_TOOLS limits Claude Code commands and is validated.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"tool","question":"Tool","support":"partial","answer":"ALLOWED_TOOLS comes from repository-controlled configuration and is not a boundary against that repository.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:cli"]},{"id":"network","question":"Network","support":"partial","answer":"Docker --sandbox-network flag.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"secret","question":"Secret","support":"partial","answer":"Secrets passed by env-file only into the sandbox.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"delivery","question":"Delivery","support":"partial","answer":"PR creation is opt-in by flag; draft PR option.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"approver_identity","question":"Approver identity","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"lifetime","question":"Lifetime","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"allow","question":"Allow","support":"partial","answer":"Allow list in config.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"deny","question":"Deny","support":"unsupported","answer":"No deny list.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"revoke","question":"Revoke","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"tunnels","question":"Tunnels","support":"unsupported","answer":"No tunnels.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"defaults","question":"Defaults","support":"supported","answer":"Default allowed tools come from the generated .ralphrc.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"safer_modes","question":"Safer modes","support":"partial","answer":"Docker or E2B sandbox modes.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"enforcement","question":"Enforcement","support":"unsupported","answer":"The allow list is repository-controlled and not a boundary against that repository.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:cli","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]}},{"id":"TEAM-04","title":"Decision and activity history","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:TEAM-04","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Local queue state, logs and the last 50 session transitions persist on disk.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"actions","question":"Actions","support":"partial","answer":"Logs and a status file record loop events; no user attribution.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"approvals","question":"Approvals","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"edits","question":"Edits","support":"partial","answer":"Git commits per item.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"discussion","question":"Discussion","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"decisions","question":"Decisions","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"cross_user_persistence","question":"Cross user persistence","support":"unsupported","answer":"Single user.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"cross_session_persistence","question":"Cross session persistence","support":"supported","answer":"Local queue state, logs and the last 50 session transitions persist on disk.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"export","question":"Export","support":"partial","answer":"ralph --status prints JSON.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"mutability","question":"Mutability","support":"supported","answer":"Local files are editable.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"retention","question":"Retention","support":"partial","answer":"Last 50 session transitions are kept.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"integrity","question":"Integrity","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]}},{"id":"TEAM-05","title":"Review experience and guidance","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:TEAM-05","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The monitor shows loop status and logs only; there is no review UI.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"pending_reviews","question":"Pending reviews","support":"unsupported","answer":"No pending reviews in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"change_understanding","question":"Change understanding","support":"unsupported","answer":"The monitor is display-only loop status/log output, with no code-diff review interface.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"evidence_navigation","question":"Evidence navigation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No evidence navigation in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"comments","question":"Comments","support":"unsupported","answer":"No comments in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"request_changes","question":"Request changes","support":"unsupported","answer":"No request changes in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"shipping_guidance","question":"Shipping guidance","support":"unsupported","answer":"No shipping guidance in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"effort","question":"Effort","support":"unsupported","answer":"No effort in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"missed_evidence","question":"Missed evidence","support":"unsupported","answer":"No missed evidence in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"keyboard","question":"Keyboard","support":"partial","answer":"tmux key controls for the monitor.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"narrow_screen","question":"Narrow screen","support":"unsupported","answer":"No narrow screen in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"context_switching","question":"Context switching","support":"unsupported","answer":"No context switching in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"roles","question":"Roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No roles in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"retained_context","question":"Retained context","support":"unsupported","answer":"No retained context in the inspected tree: no review UI beyond status and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: pending_reviews, evidence_navigation, comments, request_changes, shipping_guidance, effort, missed_evidence, keyboard, narrow_screen, context_switching, roles, retained_context."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"TEAM-06","title":"Colleague takeover and continuity","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:TEAM-06","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"unsupported","answer":"No colleague takeover; state lives in a local checkout.","availability":"unknown","delivery":"unknown","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"ongoing_takeover","question":"Ongoing takeover","support":"unsupported","answer":"No ongoing takeover in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"same_task","question":"Same task","support":"unsupported","answer":"No same task in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"session_history","question":"Session history","support":"unsupported","answer":"No session history in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"decisions","question":"Decisions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No decisions in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"artifacts","question":"Artifacts","support":"unsupported","answer":"No artifacts in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"permissions","question":"Permissions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No permissions in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"runtime_context","question":"Runtime context","support":"unsupported","answer":"No runtime context in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"owner_disconnect","question":"Owner disconnect","support":"unsupported","answer":"No owner disconnect in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"ownership","question":"Ownership","support":"unsupported","answer":"No ownership in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"attribution","question":"Attribution","support":"unsupported","answer":"No attribution in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"context_loss","question":"Context loss","support":"unsupported","answer":"No context loss in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"harness_transfer","question":"Harness transfer","support":"unsupported","answer":"No harness transfer in the inspected tree: no handover mechanism.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"SHIP-01","title":"Retained artifacts and outputs","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:SHIP-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph retains logs, plan and spec files, commits and PRs; it has no diff viewer, artifact gallery or recordings.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"diffs","question":"Diffs","support":"unsupported","answer":"No diff view; users use git.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"documents","question":"Documents","support":"partial","answer":"Specs and plan files in .ralph.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"screenshots","question":"Screenshots","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"recordings","question":"Recordings","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"previews","question":"Previews","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"test_outputs","question":"Test outputs","support":"partial","answer":"Logs capture loop output.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"reviewer_outputs","question":"Reviewer outputs","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"gallery","question":"Gallery","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"task_links","question":"Task links","support":"supported","answer":"Commits and PRs link to issue numbers.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"revision_links","question":"Revision links","support":"partial","answer":"Commit per item.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"persistence","question":"Persistence","support":"supported","answer":"Logs and git history persist.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"child_findings","question":"Child findings","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"prompt_leakage","question":"Prompt leakage","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Partial: diffs (unsupported), documents (partial), screenshots (unsupported), recordings (unsupported), previews (unsupported), test_outputs (partial), reviewer_outputs (unsupported), gallery (unsupported), revision_links (partial), child_findings (unsupported), prompt_leakage (unsupported). See each atomic answer for the limit and its evidence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]}},{"id":"SHIP-02","title":"Verification and spec gates","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:SHIP-02","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"No test, lint or CI gate; exit detection relies on Claude status output and task checkboxes.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"tests","question":"Tests","support":"partial","answer":"Loops that only run tests count toward exit detection; no enforced test gate.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"lint","question":"Lint","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"types","question":"Types","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"ci","question":"Ci","support":"unsupported","answer":"No CI integration for the user project (CI covers Ralph itself).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-ci"]},{"id":"independent_review","question":"Independent review","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"spec_checks","question":"Spec checks","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"required_checks","question":"Required checks","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"failure_blocking","question":"Failure blocking","support":"partial","answer":"Circuit breaker halts on repeated no-progress.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"requirement_conflicts","question":"Requirement conflicts","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"configured_policy","question":"Configured policy","support":"partial","answer":"Exit thresholds are configurable.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"enforced_policy","question":"Enforced policy","support":"partial","answer":"Dual-condition exit and breaker are enforced by the loop.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Partial: tests (partial), lint (unsupported), types (unsupported), ci (unsupported), independent_review (unsupported), spec_checks (unsupported), required_checks (unsupported), failure_blocking (partial), requirement_conflicts (unsupported), configured_policy (partial), enforced_policy (partial). See each atomic answer for the limit and its evidence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-ci"]}},{"id":"SHIP-03","title":"Git and pull request workflow","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:SHIP-03","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Queue processing commits one commit per issue on the current branch. With --github-issue and --create-pr, Ralph opens a pull request through the gh CLI on completion, optionally as a draft linked to the issue, and can comment on and close the issue.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"branches","question":"Branches","support":"partial","answer":"Queue processing uses a single current branch without per-issue branch creation.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"worktrees","question":"Worktrees","support":"unsupported","answer":"No worktrees; one branch.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"commits","question":"Commits","support":"supported","answer":"Successful Git queue items are committed once per issue on the current branch.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue"]},{"id":"pull_requests","question":"Pull requests","support":"supported","answer":"--create-pr opens a pull request through the gh CLI when the loop completes; --draft-pr and --link-issue set draft state and a Closes #N link.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:b4-github-pr"]},{"id":"comments","question":"Comments","support":"supported","answer":"Progress and summary comments on the GitHub issue.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"ci_response","question":"Ci response","support":"unsupported","answer":"No CI response.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"rebase","question":"Rebase","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"conflicts","question":"Conflicts","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"product_state","question":"Product state","support":"supported","answer":"Lifecycle state tracked in .ralph/.github_lifecycle_state.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:queue","ralph-claude-code:b4-github-pr","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"SHIP-04","title":"Merge and deployment authority","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:SHIP-04","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"unsupported","answer":"Ralph can create a draft or ready PR and close the issue; merge and deployment authority are outside it.","availability":"unknown","delivery":"unknown","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"approve","question":"Approve","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"merge","question":"Merge","support":"unsupported","answer":"None; PR is opened, not merged.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"release","question":"Release","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"deploy","question":"Deploy","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"exact_revision","question":"Exact revision","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"authority_enforcement","question":"Authority enforcement","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]}},{"id":"SHIP-05","title":"Completion evidence and rollback","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:SHIP-05","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"--backup creates Git backup branches and --rollback restores a selected backup.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"commit_links","question":"Commit links","support":"supported","answer":"Fix #N commits.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"pr_links","question":"Pr links","support":"supported","answer":"PR with Closes #N.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-gh"]},{"id":"build_links","question":"Build links","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"deployment_links","question":"Deployment links","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"delivery_status","question":"Delivery status","support":"partial","answer":"Queue completed state and issue closure.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"retained_evidence","question":"Retained evidence","support":"partial","answer":"Logs and commits.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"rollback","question":"Rollback","support":"supported","answer":"--backup creates Git backup branches and --rollback restores a selected backup.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"revert","question":"Revert","support":"supported","answer":"--rollback restores a backup branch.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"stale_approval_invalidation","question":"Stale approval invalidation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No approvals.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-12-08","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"SHIP-06","title":"Batch review and high-volume shipping","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:SHIP-06","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"A sequential queue with priority and dependencies exists; there is no batch review or merge queue.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"review_queue","question":"Review queue","support":"unsupported","answer":"No review queue in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"summaries","question":"Summaries","support":"unsupported","answer":"No summaries in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"grouping","question":"Grouping","support":"unsupported","answer":"No grouping in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"risk_size_filters","question":"Risk size filters","support":"unsupported","answer":"No risk size filters in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"findings","question":"Findings","support":"unsupported","answer":"No findings in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"artifacts","question":"Artifacts","support":"unsupported","answer":"No artifacts in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"request_changes","question":"Request changes","support":"unsupported","answer":"No request changes in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"exact_revision_approval","question":"Exact revision approval","support":"unsupported","answer":"No exact revision approval in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"dependency_queues","question":"Dependency queues","support":"partial","answer":"Dependency-ordered processing, not merge ordering.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]},{"id":"next_actions","question":"Next actions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No next actions in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"stale_approval_invalidation","question":"Stale approval invalidation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No stale approval invalidation in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"check_deduplication","question":"Check deduplication","support":"unsupported","answer":"No check deduplication in the inspected tree: no review queue features.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Partial: review_queue (unsupported), summaries (unsupported), grouping (unsupported), risk_size_filters (unsupported), findings (unsupported), artifacts (unsupported), request_changes (unsupported), exact_revision_approval (unsupported), dependency_queues (partial), next_actions (unsupported), stale_approval_invalidation (unsupported), check_deduplication (unsupported). See each atomic answer for the limit and its evidence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-queue"]}},{"id":"OWN-01","title":"Source and license","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:OWN-01","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The distributed shell application source is MIT licensed.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"client_license","question":"Client license","support":"supported","answer":"The distributed shell application source is MIT licensed.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:license"]},{"id":"server_license","question":"Server license","support":"unsupported","answer":"No server component.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"hosted_extensions","question":"Hosted extensions","support":"unsupported","answer":"No hosted service found in the repository.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"source_visibility","question":"Source visibility","support":"supported","answer":"Full source is public under MIT.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"source_revision","question":"Source revision","support":"supported","answer":"Pinned to default-branch commit 11f9df5becc8 (README v0.11.5; no release tags).","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"hosted_parity","question":"Hosted parity","support":"unsupported","answer":"No hosted counterpart.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-02-06","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:license","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-license","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"OWN-02","title":"Hosting and exit","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:OWN-02","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"supported","answer":"The loop, queue and monitor run locally from the public source distribution. Claude authentication is required; optional E2B adds separate cloud credentials and compute costs.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"self_hosting","question":"Self hosting","support":"supported","answer":"The loop, queue and monitor run locally from the public source distribution.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"vendor_dependencies","question":"Vendor dependencies","support":"supported","answer":"Claude authentication is required; optional E2B adds separate cloud credentials and compute costs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:e2b"]},{"id":"export","question":"Export","support":"supported","answer":"State is plain files and ralph --status JSON.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"import","question":"Import","support":"supported","answer":"PRD and GitHub issue import.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"formats","question":"Formats","support":"supported","answer":"Markdown, JSON and logs.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"cancellation","question":"Cancellation","support":"supported","answer":"No account exists.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"account_independence","question":"Account independence","support":"supported","answer":"No Ralph account; Claude login required for the agent.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"history_portability","question":"History portability","support":"supported","answer":"Git history and files copy with the repo.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:e2b","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"OWN-03","title":"Data handling and telemetry","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:OWN-03","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"The inspected Ralph CLI implements no ADE analytics reporter or telemetry opt-out switch. Selected-agent, GitHub, sandbox and user-configured notification traffic remain separate.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"code_data","question":"Code data","support":"supported","answer":"Code stays local, in Docker, or in an E2B sandbox if chosen.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"prompts","question":"Prompts","support":"partial","answer":"Prompts go to Claude Code (Anthropic) and E2B when used.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"credentials","question":"Credentials","support":"supported","answer":"API key via env-file or scoped credentials copy; E2B key file chmod 600.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"logs","question":"Logs","support":"supported","answer":"Logs stay local.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"artifacts","question":"Artifacts","support":"supported","answer":"Local files; E2B sync when chosen.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"retention","question":"Retention","support":"partial","answer":"Local logs persist until deleted.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"deletion","question":"Deletion","support":"supported","answer":"Delete local files; sandboxes removed on exit.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-docker"]},{"id":"training","question":"Training","support":"unknown","answer":"Provider training use: a business or hosted-service fact the public repository cannot answer.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"residency","question":"Residency","support":"unknown","answer":"Provider data residency: a business or hosted-service fact the public repository cannot answer.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"subprocessors","question":"Subprocessors","support":"unknown","answer":"Subprocessors: a business or hosted-service fact the public repository cannot answer.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"telemetry_disclosure","question":"Telemetry disclosure","support":"unsupported","answer":"No product analytics reporter is implemented in the inspected runtime/CLI.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"telemetry_defaults","question":"Telemetry defaults","support":"unsupported","answer":"No telemetry or analytics code exists.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"telemetry_controls","question":"Telemetry controls","support":"unsupported","answer":"There is no Ralph telemetry opt-out switch because the inspected product has no ADE telemetry subsystem.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface"]},{"id":"consent_prompt","question":"Consent prompt","support":"unsupported","answer":"No consent prompt because no telemetry exists.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"provider_separation","question":"Provider separation","support":"supported","answer":"Ralph sends no model traffic of its own; Claude Code and E2B do.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: code_data, prompts, credentials, logs, artifacts, retention, deletion, training, residency, subprocessors, telemetry_defaults, consent_prompt, provider_separation."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b","ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"OWN-04","title":"Price and included usage","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:OWN-04","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"ralph-claude-code is MIT open source with no paid plan; it uses your own Claude credentials or Anthropic API key, and optional E2B sandboxes are billed by E2B (the tool only estimates and caps that cost).","availability":"unknown","delivery":"unknown","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"First-party pricing sources read 2026-11-10","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"currency","question":"Currency","support":"unsupported","answer":"Nothing is priced.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"interval","question":"Interval","support":"unsupported","answer":"No billing interval.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"seats","question":"Seats","support":"unsupported","answer":"No seats.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"seat_minimum","question":"Seat minimum","support":"unsupported","answer":"No minimum.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"workspace_fees","question":"Workspace fees","support":"unsupported","answer":"No fees.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"included_usage","question":"Included usage","support":"unsupported","answer":"No usage included.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"credits","question":"Credits","support":"unsupported","answer":"No credits.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"trial","question":"Trial","support":"unsupported","answer":"No trial; free software.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"overages","question":"Overages","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"taxes","question":"Taxes","support":"unsupported","answer":"No charges to tax.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"model_cost","question":"Model cost","support":"supported","answer":"Claude runs on your own ANTHROPIC_API_KEY or Claude login credentials, so Anthropic bills for usage.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme-nov10"]},{"id":"compute_cost","question":"Compute cost","support":"partial","answer":"The optional E2B sandbox has its own cost, which the tool estimates from runtime times a user-set hourly rate and can cap. The README gives no E2B prices.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme-nov10"]}],"limitations":["First-party pricing pages, terms and licences read 2026-11-10; no purchase, billing or authenticated account test."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-10","ageDays":12,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-11-24","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:license-nov10","ralph-claude-code:readme-nov10","ralph-claude-code:rc-license","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}},{"id":"OWN-05","title":"Scenario cost and controls","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:OWN-05","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"ADE cost is zero for any team size; Claude and optional E2B costs are separate.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"one_person","question":"One person","support":"supported","answer":"Zero ADE cost.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"two_people","question":"Two people","support":"supported","answer":"Zero ADE cost per person.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"five_people","question":"Five people","support":"supported","answer":"Zero ADE cost per person.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"task_assumptions","question":"Task assumptions","support":"unknown","answer":"No ADE price to model.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"concurrency","question":"Concurrency","support":"supported","answer":"Serial by design, one loop per project.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"tokens","question":"Tokens","support":"unknown","answer":"Tokens are billed by Anthropic.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"compute_hours","question":"Compute hours","support":"partial","answer":"Local compute free; E2B runtime estimated hourly by the user-set rate.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]},{"id":"fixed_cost","question":"Fixed cost","support":"supported","answer":"Zero.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"variable_cost","question":"Variable cost","support":"unknown","answer":"Claude and E2B billing.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"included_cost","question":"Included cost","support":"supported","answer":"Nothing bundled.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"unknown_cost","question":"Unknown cost","support":"unknown","answer":"Provider prices unknown here.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Partial: task_assumptions (unknown), tokens (unknown), compute_hours (partial), variable_cost (unknown), unknown_cost (unknown). See each atomic answer for the limit and its evidence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b"]}},{"id":"OWN-06","title":"Availability and support","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:OWN-06","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"README reports active development at v0.11.5 with newer pinned-source changes described as unreleased. Public issues and contributor documentation are linked; no support response commitment is established.","availability":"beta","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"release_stage","question":"Release stage","support":"supported","answer":"README reports active development at v0.11.5 with newer pinned-source changes described as unreleased.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"access_restrictions","question":"Access restrictions","support":"supported","answer":"MIT, no sign-in.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"support","question":"Support","support":"partial","answer":"Public issues and contributor documentation are linked; no support response commitment is established.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme"]},{"id":"response_commitments","question":"Response commitments","support":"unsupported","answer":"None stated in CONTRIBUTING or README.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"release_activity","question":"Release activity","support":"partial","answer":"README v0.11.5; no release tags; recent commits to main.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"status_history","question":"Status history","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"deprecation","question":"Deprecation","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"export_options","question":"Export options","support":"supported","answer":"Plain files and JSON status.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}],"limitations":["Only the cited atomic findings are established. Remaining atomic requirements and the full rubric scenario remain unverified."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-08","ageDays":14,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-11-22","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:readme","ralph-claude-code:rc-license","ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"OWN-07","title":"Enterprise assurance","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:OWN-07","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"OWN-08","title":"Useful free tier and evaluation access","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:OWN-08","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"Ralph is a free MIT-licensed shell tool installed from the public repository; no paid plan is shown. Claude usage and optional E2B sandboxes are billed by their providers.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"ongoing_free","question":"Ongoing free","support":"supported","answer":"The tool is a free MIT-licensed install from the public repository.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:b4-license","ralph-claude-code:b4-install"]},{"id":"trial","question":"Trial","support":"unsupported","answer":"No trial; free software.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"credits_trial","question":"Credits trial","support":"unsupported","answer":"None.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"self_host_cost","question":"Self host cost","support":"supported","answer":"Runs locally at no cost beyond Claude.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"paid_only","question":"Paid only","support":"unsupported","answer":"Not paid-only: the tool installs free of charge from the public repository.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:b4-license","ralph-claude-code:b4-install"]},{"id":"early_access","question":"Early access","support":"partial","answer":"README labels active development.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"free_scenarios","question":"Free scenarios","support":"partial","answer":"Free: local loops, queue, GitHub import; BYO Claude subscription; no collaboration, mobile or review UI.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"card_required","question":"Card required","support":"unsupported","answer":"No payment is requested.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]},{"id":"usage_caps","question":"Usage caps","support":"partial","answer":"Self-set hourly limits only.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]},{"id":"paid_evaluation","question":"Paid evaluation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No payment needed.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-license"]}],"limitations":["Underlying Claude plan limits were not checked. No installed-product test was run."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-10","ageDays":12,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2026-11-24","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:b4-license","ralph-claude-code:b4-install","ralph-claude-code:rc-license","ralph-claude-code:rc-readme"]}},{"id":"OWN-09","title":"Pricing transparency","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"ralph-claude-code","claimId":"ralph-claude-code:OWN-09","verificationStatus":"sourced","support":"partial","answer":"No pricing exists to classify.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["terminal"],"version":"Repository 11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970; first-party source pass 2026-11-08. Pinned source includes features beyond README version 0.11.5. Multi-provider support remains in progress.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"terminal","name":"Ralph loop, queue CLI and tmux monitor","type":"cli"}]},"questions":[{"id":"units","question":"Units","support":"unsupported","answer":"No units in the inspected tree: nothing is priced.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"included_limits","question":"Included limits","support":"unsupported","answer":"No included limits in the inspected tree: nothing is priced.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"overages","question":"Overages","support":"unsupported","answer":"No overages in the inspected tree: nothing is priced.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"compute_markup","question":"Compute markup","support":"unsupported","answer":"No compute markup in the inspected tree: nothing is priced.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"model_markup","question":"Model markup","support":"unsupported","answer":"No model markup in the inspected tree: nothing is priced.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"minimum_commitment","question":"Minimum commitment","support":"unsupported","answer":"No minimum commitment in the inspected tree: nothing is priced.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"cancellation","question":"Cancellation","support":"unsupported","answer":"No cancellation in the inspected tree: nothing is priced.","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]},{"id":"sales_only_unknowns","question":"Sales only unknowns","support":"unknown","answer":"No sales-only offer is stated in the repository.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"transparency_classification","question":"Transparency classification","support":"unknown","answer":"Classification needs a priced offering; none exists.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Partial: units (unsupported), included_limits (unsupported), overages (unsupported), compute_markup (unsupported), model_markup (unsupported), minimum_commitment (unsupported), cancellation (unsupported), sales_only_unknowns (unknown), transparency_classification (unknown). See each atomic answer for the limit and its evidence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-16","ageDays":6,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":"2027-03-16","evidenceIds":["ralph-claude-code:rc-scan"]}}],"sources":[{"id":"ralph-claude-code:readme","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/README.md","title":"Ralph for Claude Code README.md","locator":"Current features; Setup; Session continuity; Monitoring; Roadmap","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"Ralph drives repeated Claude Code calls using local prompt/spec/task files. Product CLI commands, rate limits, circuit breakers, live output, session expiry, notifications and backup/rollback are documented."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:gaps-loop-surface","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/ralph_loop.sh","title":"ralph-claude-code: ralph_loop.sh","locator":"CLI options and main loop; install.sh; ralph_monitor.sh; lib and ralph_queue.sh","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"The product installs Bash CLI commands and a display-only terminal/tmux monitor. Bounded inspection of the CLI, monitor and lib tree found no browser/phone application, multi-human prompting service, named workspace roles, enterprise SSO, code-diff review UI, agent-session delegation tools or schedule/event intake. Network integrations are the selected agent, GitHub operations, optional sandboxes and explicitly configured notifications. No ADE analytics reporter or telemetry opt-out switch is implemented; provider telemetry is separate.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"ralph_loop.sh"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-readme","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/README.md#L300-L342,L516-L672,L713-L765,L915-L932","title":"README.md","locator":"How It Works, GitHub lifecycle, queue, sandboxes, rate limiting, requirements (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Ralph loops Claude Code with exit detection, GitHub issue import and lifecycle (progress comments, PR, close), a sequential persistent queue with priorities and dependencies, Docker and E2B sandboxes, hourly call and token limits, a circuit breaker with cooldown, and a Bash 4 / jq / git / coreutils requirement list."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-install","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/install.sh#L36-L80","title":"install.sh","locator":"dependency check (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Install script checks node/npx, jq, git and timeout; it branches only on Darwin versus other and prints install hints for Ubuntu/Debian, macOS and CentOS/RHEL.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"install.sh"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-queue","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/lib/queue_manager.sh#L1-L120","title":"lib/queue_manager.sh","locator":"queue state (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Persistent JSON queue of GitHub issue or PRD items with priority and dependency fields, validation of circular dependencies and sequential processing.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"lib/queue_manager.sh"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-scan","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/tree/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/.","title":"ralph-claude-code repository (bounded inspection)","locator":"whole-tree search (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Searched ralph_loop.sh, ralph_*.sh, lib, install.sh, docs, README, specs and templates at the pinned commit for: mcp, plugin, extension, vscode, webhook, openapi, sso/saml/oidc, role/permission/membership, presence/co-edit, worktree, cost per task/session, token stats export, diff review UI, merge/deploy, rollback beyond backup branches, soc 2/iso 27001, telemetry/analytics. No implementation exists beyond what the answers state; hits were unrelated or tests.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:adapter-plan","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/docs/adr/0001-multi-provider-agent-abstraction.md","title":"Ralph for Claude Code docs/adr/0001-multi-provider-agent-abstraction.md","locator":"Status and adapter architecture","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"Multi-provider abstraction is a planning item. It does not establish released Codex, Gemini or OpenCode support."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-loop","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/ralph_loop.sh","title":"ralph_loop.sh","locator":"main loop (3,673 lines) (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Single Bash loop that calls the Claude Code CLI with explicit session IDs, exit detection, rate and token limits, circuit breaker, optional tmux monitor, sandbox providers and queue processing.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"ralph_loop.sh"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:docker","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/docs/DOCKER_SANDBOX.md","title":"Ralph for Claude Code docs/DOCKER_SANDBOX.md","locator":"Architecture; Credentials; Network; CLI","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"Docker executes Claude inside a persistent container with a read-write project bind mount. Host orchestration remains local, CPU/memory/network are configurable, and credentials are scoped copies or API keys."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:b4-credentials","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/README.md#L636-L642","title":"Ralph README: how credentials reach the container","locator":"README.md lines 636-642, commit 11f9df5; default CLAUDE_CODE_CMD=claude at ralph_loop.sh line 124","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"On the host Ralph invokes the installed claude CLI (default command claude), which uses its own sign-in. In the Docker sandbox it passes ANTHROPIC_API_KEY when set, otherwise copies the user's ~/.claude/.credentials.json into a container-scoped home."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-docker","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/lib/sandbox_docker.sh","title":"lib/sandbox_docker.sh","locator":"Docker provider (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Runs Claude in a persistent local container with memory, CPU and network flags; credentials via a 0600 env-file or a scoped copy of ~/.claude credentials; removed on exit.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"lib/sandbox_docker.sh"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-gh","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/lib/github_lifecycle.sh","title":"lib/github_lifecycle.sh","locator":"GitHub lifecycle (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Uses the gh CLI to post progress comments, create a PR (optionally draft, with Closes #N), post a summary, add labels, close the issue and open follow-up issues; state in .ralph/.github_lifecycle_state.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"lib/github_lifecycle.sh"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-e2b","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/lib/sandbox_e2b.sh","title":"lib/sandbox_e2b.sh","locator":"E2B provider (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Runs Claude in an E2B cloud sandbox with timeout, keep-alive reuse, cost estimate, alert and max-cost controls and file sync; loop and monitor stay on the host.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"lib/sandbox_e2b.sh"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:cli","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/docs/CLI_OPTIONS.md","title":"Ralph for Claude Code docs/CLI_OPTIONS.md","locator":"Loop options; .ralphrc security","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"The CLI configures hourly calls, timeouts, tool allowlists, session resets and queue processing. Repository-controlled ALLOWED_TOOLS is explicitly not a security boundary."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:queue","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/docs/QUEUE_MANAGEMENT.md","title":"Ralph for Claude Code docs/QUEUE_MANAGEMENT.md","locator":"Concepts; Processing; Design limits","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"A persistent queue imports GitHub issues or local PRDs, tracks states and priorities, enforces in-queue dependencies, skips duplicate IDs and processes items sequentially on the current branch."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:files","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/docs/user-guide/02-understanding-ralph-files.md","title":"Ralph for Claude Code docs/user-guide/02-understanding-ralph-files.md","locator":"PROMPT.md; fix_plan.md; AGENT.md; specs","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"User-editable prompt/spec files and prioritized checklists provide the loop context and work plan. They are files rather than a documented revision/approval system."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-monitor","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/ralph_monitor.sh","title":"ralph_monitor.sh","locator":"monitor (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Terminal dashboard reads local JSON state and logs: loop count, API usage, queue totals and status.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"ralph_monitor.sh"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:gaps-serial-queue","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/README.md","title":"ralph-claude-code: README.md","locator":"Queue management, concurrent processing restriction; ralph_queue.sh processing loop","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"The queue documentation explicitly excludes concurrent parallel processing and processes items one at a time on a single branch. The loop invokes Claude in sequence rather than running an independent fleet of sessions."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:e2b","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/docs/E2B_SANDBOX.md","title":"Ralph for Claude Code docs/E2B_SANDBOX.md","locator":"Architecture; Lifecycle; Cost tracking","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"E2B runs Claude remotely while the host loop controls iterations and file sync. Sandbox expiry can recreate/reupload; cost limits use estimates rather than invoices."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:gaps-e2b-vm","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://docs.e2b.dev/","title":"ralph-claude-code: E2B building blocks, Sandbox","locator":"E2B building blocks, Sandbox","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"E2B documents its Sandbox object as an on-demand isolated Linux VM. Ralph optional --sandbox e2b invokes this Sandbox execution path; Ralph orchestration and file sync remain on the host."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:monitor","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/ralph_monitor.sh","title":"Ralph for Claude Code ralph_monitor.sh","locator":"display_status; display_queue_status; main","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"The actual monitor reads local status/progress/queue JSON and log files, displays loop/API-call counts and queue state totals, and refreshes every two seconds.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"ralph_monitor.sh"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-ci","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/.github/workflows/test.yml","title":".github/workflows/test.yml","locator":"CI workflow (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"CI runs the BATS test suite for the project repository; other workflows run Claude code review and triage for maintainers.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":".github/workflows/test.yml"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:b4-github-pr","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/README.md#L518-L550","title":"Ralph README: GitHub issue lifecycle","locator":"README.md lines 518-550 (GitHub issue lifecycle flags), commit 11f9df5","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"With --github-issue, Ralph uses the gh CLI to post progress comments, create a pull request on completion (optionally as a draft and linked with Closes #N), post a summary, close the issue and open follow-up issues."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:license","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/LICENSE","title":"Ralph for Claude Code LICENSE","locator":"MIT grant","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-08","finding":"Ralph repository code is MIT licensed.","commit":"11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970","path":"LICENSE"},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:rc-license","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/LICENSE#L1-L3","title":"LICENSE","locator":"licence header (frankbria/ralph-claude-code @ 11f9df5becc8)","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"MIT licence."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:readme-nov10","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/main/README.md","title":"ralph-claude-code README","locator":"'E2B Cloud Sandbox Execution' section; 'License'","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"Says the tool is MIT licensed. Claude auth can use your own ANTHROPIC_API_KEY or Claude credentials. The optional E2B cloud sandbox has cost estimated from runtime times a user-set hourly rate, with budget caps, and E2B charges for it."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:license-nov10","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/main/LICENSE","title":"frankbria/ralph-claude-code LICENSE (MIT)","locator":"Permission grant, first paragraph","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"The MIT License lets anyone obtain, use, copy and modify the software free of charge."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:b4-install","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/README.md#L168-L192","title":"Ralph README: installation","locator":"README.md lines 168-192 (Install once), commit 11f9df5","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"Ralph is installed globally from a clone of the public repository with ./install.sh; the README names no price, account or paid plan."},{"id":"ralph-claude-code:b4-license","productId":"ralph-claude-code","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/frankbria/ralph-claude-code/blob/11f9df5becc8093ff2265542107e8e53a42e9970/LICENSE#L1-L3","title":"Ralph LICENSE","locator":"LICENSE lines 1-3, commit 11f9df5","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"The repository is under the MIT License, copyright Frank Bria."}],"comparisons":[{"slug":"podium-vs-ralph-claude-code","productIds":["podium","ralph-claude-code"],"canonicalUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/podium-vs-ralph-claude-code/"}],"otherComparisonsUrl":"https://adecomparison.com/compare/?products=ralph-claude-code"}
