{"schemaVersion":7,"rubricVersion":"0.3","canonicalUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/openspec/","markdownUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/openspec/index.md","dataUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/openspec/data.json","rubricUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/rubric/","generatedAt":"2026-11-22","publisher":{"name":"Podium","url":"https://podium.do","marketParticipant":true,"editorialControl":"Podium selects the products, rubric, sources and wording, including for comparisons that do not include Podium, and may add labeled Podium team research without linked sources.","disclosure":"Podium publishes this catalog and sells an agent development environment. Podium chooses the products, criteria, sources and wording, so treat these pages as vendor-authored research. Check important claims against the linked primary sources. Sourced findings follow the same evidence rules for Podium and its competitors. Facts labeled Podium team research come from Podium's own team and have no linked source. None of this removes the conflict of interest."},"attribution":{"dataSource":{"name":"adecomparison.com by Podium","url":"https://adecomparison.com","repository":"https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison"},"license":{"name":"CC BY 4.0","url":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"dataLicenseUrl":"https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison/blob/4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e/DATA-LICENSE.md","snapshot":{"commit":"4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e","commitDate":"2026-11-22","url":"https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison/tree/4322f0c035f303791413639d1462a138443d8c1e"},"podiumTeamLabel":"Podium team research","podiumTeamText":"Podium team research is a fact the Podium team added without a linked source. It is labeled wherever it appears, and any differing adecomparison.com finding stays visible beside it.","statement":"Based on data from adecomparison.com by Podium (https://adecomparison.com; source repository https://github.com/madeinorbit/ade-comparison, snapshot 4322f0c of 2026-11-22), used under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Source links and check dates are kept. Podium arranges the findings into pairs, applies its publication checks, and added its own research where marked \"Podium team research\"."},"product":{"id":"openspec","name":"OpenSpec","website":"https://openspec.dev/","repository":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec","url":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/products/openspec/","lifecycle":{"status":"unknown","note":null},"sourcedClaimCount":36,"crossCheckedClaimCount":36,"sourcedOnlyClaimCount":0,"podiumTeamClaimCount":0,"oldestCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","lastCheckedAt":"2026-11-13","surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"criteria":[{"id":"ACC-01","title":"Client access","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:ACC-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec ships a terminal CLI on macOS, Windows and Linux plus assistant workflow skills, without a standalone desktop GUI, browser client or phone app. It has no editor extension of its own; v2.1.1 installs skills only for selected assistants, some of which run as editor extensions, and removes command files that earlier versions generated.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13; editor_extensions at v2.1.1 0c737dc (code inspected 2026-11-22)","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"desktop_os","question":"Desktop os","support":"supported","answer":"The documented standalone CLI builds and installation commands support macOS, Windows and Linux. These are terminal clients, not desktop GUI applications.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:gaps-cli"]},{"id":"mobile_apps","question":"Mobile apps","support":"unsupported","answer":"The released package has no native iOS or Android app.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli"]},{"id":"browser","question":"Browser","support":"unsupported","answer":"The released package has no browser work interface.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli"]},{"id":"mobile_browser","question":"Mobile browser","support":"unsupported","answer":"The released package has no phone-browser client.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli"]},{"id":"cli","question":"Cli","support":"supported","answer":"Product-owned openspec terminal interface.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"editor_extensions","question":"Editor extensions","support":"partial","answer":"No OpenSpec editor extension. At v2.1.1, openspec init and update install workflow skills only for selected assistants, including editor-hosted ones such as GitHub Copilot, and remove the command files earlier versions generated, keeping edited ones.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov22-command-reconcile","openspec:b06-rel-2-0"]},{"id":"task_actions","question":"Task actions","support":"supported","answer":"CLI creates changes, lists progress, validates and archives artifacts.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"notifications","question":"Notifications","support":"unknown","answer":"Notifications: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"cross_device_continuity","question":"Cross device continuity","support":"unknown","answer":"Cross device continuity: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: notifications, cross_device_continuity.","docs/supported-tools.md at v2.1.1 (0c737dc) still describes delivery modes and per-tool command files. The v2.1.1 init and update code and the v2.0.0 release notes supersede it, so it is not used for current behaviour."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-22","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:nov22-command-reconcile","openspec:b06-rel-2-0"]}},{"id":"ACC-02","title":"Agent and model choice","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:ACC-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec integrates workflow skills into Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, OpenCode, Pi, Grok Build and Antigravity; the assistant supplies the model loop.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13; session_integration at v2.1.1 0c737dc (code inspected 2026-11-22)","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"harnesses","question":"Harnesses","support":"supported","answer":"The shipped AI_TOOLS registry explicitly enables Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, OpenCode, Pi, Grok Build and Antigravity.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-agents"]},{"id":"model_providers","question":"Model providers","support":"unknown","answer":"Model providers: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"custom_adapters","question":"Custom adapters","support":"supported","answer":"The shared .agents target supports tools that read vendor-neutral skills.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-agents"]},{"id":"session_integration","question":"Session integration","support":"supported","answer":"At v2.1.1, init writes workflow skills only into the selected assistants' skill locations and removes command files generated by earlier versions, keeping edited ones. OpenSpec 1.x init also wrote command files.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-tools","openspec:nov22-command-reconcile","openspec:b06-rel-2-0"]},{"id":"mixed_harness_operation","question":"Mixed harness operation","support":"unknown","answer":"Mixed harness operation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: model_providers, mixed_harness_operation."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-22","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-tools","openspec:gaps-agents","openspec:v200-tools","openspec:v200-n-aider","openspec:nov22-command-reconcile","openspec:b06-rel-2-0"]}},{"id":"ACC-03","title":"Subscriptions, API keys and vendor credits","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:ACC-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec adds skills and commands to the user's existing coding assistant and runs inside it, so the assistant's own sign-in, including a subscription login, applies. OpenSpec handles no model credentials itself.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"agent_subscriptions","question":"Agent subscriptions","support":"partial","answer":"The workflow runs inside the user's chosen assistant (for example Claude Code or Codex), so that assistant's native login, including a subscription, applies. Not tested; plan terms not checked.","evidenceIds":["openspec:src1-tools"]},{"id":"api_accounts","question":"Api accounts","support":"unknown","answer":"Api accounts: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"vendor_credits","question":"Vendor credits","support":"unknown","answer":"Vendor credits: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"local_models","question":"Local models","support":"unknown","answer":"Local models: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"account_switching","question":"Account switching","support":"unknown","answer":"Account switching: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"vendor_account_requirement","question":"Vendor account requirement","support":"unknown","answer":"Vendor account requirement: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"provider_restrictions","question":"Provider restrictions","support":"unknown","answer":"Provider restrictions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Per-assistant plan terms were not checked. No installed-product test was run."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-10","ageDays":12,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-10","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-10","evidenceIds":["openspec:src1-tools"]}},{"id":"ACC-04","title":"Onboarding and project prerequisites","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:ACC-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Initialize in a project directory or create a separate planning store. OpenSpec itself never runs git in the project, so a folder without Git works; versioning is left to the user.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07; no_git at v2.1.1 0c737dc","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"first_task_setup","question":"First task setup","support":"supported","answer":"Install the CLI, run openspec init and select tool integrations.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"no_git","question":"No git","support":"supported","answer":"OpenSpec reads and writes Markdown under openspec/ and never commits, branches, pushes or pulls in the project; the CLI has no Git prerequisite for project use. Only optional beta store setup runs git init.","evidenceIds":["openspec:b06-team-workflow","openspec:b06-store-git"]},{"id":"local_git_without_remote","question":"Local git without remote","support":"supported","answer":"Store setup creates a local store and does not add a remote; sharing is a separate user Git step.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"hosted_git","question":"Hosted git","support":"unknown","answer":"Hosted git: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"prerequisite_guidance","question":"Prerequisite guidance","support":"supported","answer":"npm requires Node 22.12+; standalone binaries do not need Node.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"managed_cloud_setup","question":"Managed cloud setup","support":"unknown","answer":"Managed cloud setup: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"byo_vps_onboarding","question":"Byo vps onboarding","support":"unknown","answer":"Byo vps onboarding: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: hosted_git, managed_cloud_setup, byo_vps_onboarding."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-22","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-stores","openspec:b06-team-workflow","openspec:b06-store-git"]}},{"id":"ACC-05","title":"Programmable access","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:ACC-05","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Product-owned CLI exposes machine-readable change, spec, readiness and instruction operations.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"cli","question":"Cli","support":"supported","answer":"openspec command line is documented.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"api","question":"Api","support":"unknown","answer":"Api: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"sdk","question":"Sdk","support":"unknown","answer":"Sdk: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"mcp_server","question":"Mcp server","support":"unknown","answer":"Mcp server: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"webhooks","question":"Webhooks","support":"unknown","answer":"Webhooks: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"operations","question":"Operations","support":"supported","answer":"Create/list/show changes and specs, inspect status/instructions, validate and archive.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"authentication","question":"Authentication","support":"unknown","answer":"Authentication: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"stability","question":"Stability","support":"supported","answer":"Store and schema commands retain beta/experimental scope.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli"]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: api, sdk, mcp_server, webhooks, authentication."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli"]}},{"id":"ACC-06","title":"External tools and extensions","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:ACC-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec delivers configurable workflow skills into supported coding assistants.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"mcp_client","question":"Mcp client","support":"unknown","answer":"Mcp client: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"plugins","question":"Plugins","support":"supported","answer":"Generated OpenSpec skills and commands install into assistant-specific directories.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-tools"]},{"id":"custom_tools","question":"Custom tools","support":"unknown","answer":"Custom tools: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"instructions_import","question":"Instructions import","support":"supported","answer":"Project config.yaml injects context, rules and operation guidance.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-tools"]},{"id":"authentication","question":"Authentication","support":"unknown","answer":"Authentication: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"permission_scope","question":"Permission scope","support":"unknown","answer":"Permission scope: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"integration_owner","question":"Integration owner","support":"supported","answer":"The project maintains its supported tool integrations.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-tools"]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: mcp_client, custom_tools, authentication, permission_scope."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-tools"]}},{"id":"ACC-07","title":"Client implementation","group":{"id":1,"name":"Access and agent choice"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:ACC-07","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"PLAN-01","title":"Intake and external tracker relationship","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:PLAN-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Ideas become named change folders through an agent workflow or CLI.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"local_creation","question":"Local creation","support":"supported","answer":"openspec new change creates a stable named change directory.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"prompt_intake","question":"Prompt intake","support":"supported","answer":"Propose accepts a change name or plain description; explore helps refine an idea.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"external_import","question":"External import","support":"unknown","answer":"External import: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"chat_git_triggers","question":"Chat git triggers","support":"unknown","answer":"Chat git triggers: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"authoritative_tracker","question":"Authoritative tracker","support":"unknown","answer":"Authoritative tracker: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"stable_ids","question":"Stable ids","support":"supported","answer":"Change folder name identifies the change to subsequent CLI commands.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"sync","question":"Sync","support":"unknown","answer":"Sync: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"supported_edits","question":"Supported edits","support":"unknown","answer":"Supported edits: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"external_roundtrips","question":"External roundtrips","support":"unknown","answer":"External roundtrips: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: external_import, chat_git_triggers, authoritative_tracker, sync, supported_edits, external_roundtrips."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-cli"]}},{"id":"PLAN-02","title":"Durable task plans","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:PLAN-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"A change retains its proposal, requirements, design and implementation checklist as files.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"plans","question":"Plans","support":"supported","answer":"proposal.md, design.md and tasks.md capture the plan.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"acceptance_criteria","question":"Acceptance criteria","support":"supported","answer":"Delta specs contain explicit requirements and WHEN/THEN scenarios.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"editors","question":"Editors","support":"supported","answer":"Agents generate artifacts; update-change revises existing planning files after confirmation.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"revisions","question":"Revisions","support":"unknown","answer":"Revisions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"implementation_links","question":"Implementation links","support":"unknown","answer":"Implementation links: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"amendment","question":"Amendment","support":"supported","answer":"Update-change checks artifacts for contradictions and proposes revisions.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"restart_persistence","question":"Restart persistence","support":"supported","answer":"Artifacts persist under openspec/changes/<name>/.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: revisions, implementation_links."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]}},{"id":"PLAN-03","title":"Hierarchy, dependencies and evolving scope","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:PLAN-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Schema dependencies order planning artifacts before implementation.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"epics","question":"Epics","support":"unknown","answer":"Epics: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"hierarchy","question":"Hierarchy","support":"unknown","answer":"Hierarchy: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"blockers","question":"Blockers","support":"supported","answer":"Tasks require specs and design unless explicitly skipped by schema rules.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"readiness","question":"Readiness","support":"supported","answer":"openspec status reports artifact completion and readiness.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"enforcement","question":"Enforcement","support":"unknown","answer":"Enforcement: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"state_propagation","question":"State propagation","support":"unknown","answer":"State propagation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_to_epic","question":"Task to epic","support":"unknown","answer":"Task to epic: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"identity_retention","question":"Identity retention","support":"unknown","answer":"Identity retention: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"workflow_constraints","question":"Workflow constraints","support":"supported","answer":"Apply requires its implementation artifacts; schema rules govern artifact order, not a general issue dependency scheduler.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-cli"]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: epics, hierarchy, enforcement, state_propagation, task_to_epic, identity_retention."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-cli"]}},{"id":"PLAN-04","title":"Shared context and memory","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:PLAN-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Project config and shared stores provide persistent instructions and upstream specifications.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"instructions","question":"Instructions","support":"supported","answer":"config.yaml supplies context and operation guidance.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"skills","question":"Skills","support":"supported","answer":"OpenSpec installs named workflow skills.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"project_docs","question":"Project docs","support":"supported","answer":"Specs and change artifacts live in repositories.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"memory","question":"Memory","support":"unknown","answer":"Memory: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"scope","question":"Scope","support":"supported","answer":"Config is project-scoped; stores may be shared across code repositories.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"provenance","question":"Provenance","support":"supported","answer":"Read-only reference indexes name the upstream store and retrieval command.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"correction","question":"Correction","support":"unknown","answer":"Correction: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"deletion","question":"Deletion","support":"unknown","answer":"Deletion: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"freshness","question":"Freshness","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec does not clone, pull or push; a stale checkout returns stale specifications.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"takeover_continuity","question":"Takeover continuity","support":"unknown","answer":"Takeover continuity: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: memory, correction, deletion, takeover_continuity."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-stores"]}},{"id":"PLAN-05","title":"Architecture and API awareness","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:PLAN-05","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Planning can reference upstream specifications; freshness depends on the user Git checkout.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"code_search","question":"Code search","support":"unknown","answer":"Code search: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"indexing","question":"Indexing","support":"unknown","answer":"Indexing: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"external_knowledge","question":"External knowledge","support":"supported","answer":"References inject an index of another registered store specifications.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-stores","openspec:nov07-schema"]},{"id":"multimodal_inputs","question":"Multimodal inputs","support":"unknown","answer":"Multimodal inputs: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"freshness","question":"Freshness","support":"partial","answer":"Store references read whatever is on disk; users must pull updates.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-stores","openspec:nov07-schema"]},{"id":"access_scope","question":"Access scope","support":"unknown","answer":"Access scope: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"api_retrieval","question":"Api retrieval","support":"supported","answer":"openspec show <spec-id> --type spec --store <id> retrieves a referenced spec.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-stores","openspec:nov07-schema"]},{"id":"citations","question":"Citations","support":"supported","answer":"Reference context tells the agent to fetch relevant specs and cite what it uses.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-stores","openspec:nov07-schema"]},{"id":"conflict_detection","question":"Conflict detection","support":"unknown","answer":"Conflict detection: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"review_enforcement","question":"Review enforcement","support":"unknown","answer":"Review enforcement: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: code_search, indexing, multimodal_inputs, access_scope, conflict_detection, review_enforcement."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-stores","openspec:nov07-schema"]}},{"id":"PLAN-06","title":"Native issue management and idea backlog","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:PLAN-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Named change records and task checklists can be created and archived independently of a chat session.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"create","question":"Create","support":"supported","answer":"new change creates durable metadata.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"edit","question":"Edit","support":"supported","answer":"Update-change revises planning artifacts.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"discuss","question":"Discuss","support":"unknown","answer":"Discuss: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"prioritize","question":"Prioritize","support":"unknown","answer":"Prioritize: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"label","question":"Label","support":"unknown","answer":"Label: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"assign","question":"Assign","support":"unknown","answer":"Assign: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"search","question":"Search","support":"unknown","answer":"Search: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"filter","question":"Filter","support":"unknown","answer":"Filter: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"archive","question":"Archive","support":"supported","answer":"archive moves a change into a dated archive.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"reopen","question":"Reopen","support":"unknown","answer":"Reopen: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"project_epic_views","question":"Project epic views","support":"unknown","answer":"Project epic views: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"idea_parking","question":"Idea parking","support":"supported","answer":"Explore and proposal artifacts support planning before implementation.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"explicit_dispatch","question":"Explicit dispatch","support":"unknown","answer":"Explicit dispatch: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_session_separation","question":"Task session separation","support":"supported","answer":"A change directory exists independently of an assistant conversation.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"metadata","question":"Metadata","support":"supported","answer":"Changes retain schema and optional goal/description metadata.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"durable_states","question":"Durable states","support":"supported","answer":"Artifact completion and checklist state persist on disk.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"external_tracker_requirement","question":"External tracker requirement","support":"unknown","answer":"External tracker requirement: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: discuss, prioritize, label, assign, search, filter, reopen, project_epic_views, explicit_dispatch, external_tracker_requirement."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]}},{"id":"PLAN-07","title":"Agent-native issue operations","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:PLAN-07","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Assistant workflows operate the same named change artifacts users inspect.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"shared_ids","question":"Shared ids","support":"supported","answer":"Agents and users address the same change folder name.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"read","question":"Read","support":"supported","answer":"status, show and instructions expose change data.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"create","question":"Create","support":"supported","answer":"Propose/new-change creates change scaffolds.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"update","question":"Update","support":"supported","answer":"Apply updates task checkboxes; update-change revises artifacts.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"claim","question":"Claim","support":"unknown","answer":"Claim: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"assign","question":"Assign","support":"unknown","answer":"Assign: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"state_changes","question":"State changes","support":"unknown","answer":"State changes: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"dependencies","question":"Dependencies","support":"unknown","answer":"Dependencies: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"children","question":"Children","support":"unknown","answer":"Children: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"results","question":"Results","support":"supported","answer":"Task progress is written into tracked tasks files.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"human_visibility","question":"Human visibility","support":"supported","answer":"Users inspect the same Markdown artifacts and CLI status.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"attribution","question":"Attribution","support":"unknown","answer":"Attribution: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"permissions","question":"Permissions","support":"unknown","answer":"Permissions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"conflicts","question":"Conflicts","support":"unknown","answer":"Conflicts: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: claim, assign, state_changes, dependencies, children, attribution, permissions, conflicts."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills"]}},{"id":"PLAN-08","title":"Living product specifications","group":{"id":2,"name":"Planning and context"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:PLAN-08","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec maintains canonical requirements through change deltas and archive/sync workflows. Archive keeps dated change folders while revision history relies on the user's Git; drift is checked only by an on-request verify workflow.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07; revisions and drift at v2.1.1 0c737dc","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"persistent_requirements","question":"Persistent requirements","support":"supported","answer":"Canonical requirements live in openspec/specs/.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"human_edits","question":"Human edits","support":"supported","answer":"Requirements and plans are plain editable Markdown.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"agent_edits","question":"Agent edits","support":"supported","answer":"Propose drafts specs; update-change and sync revise them.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"revisions","question":"Revisions","support":"partial","answer":"Archive folds deltas into openspec/specs/ and keeps the change in openspec/changes/archive/YYYY-MM-DD-<name>/. There is no built-in revision log of spec edits; history relies on the user committing openspec/ to Git.","evidenceIds":["openspec:b06-team-workflow"]},{"id":"approvals","question":"Approvals","support":"partial","answer":"Update-change asks before writing each artifact revision; this is a prompted workflow, not an enforced approval ledger.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"implementation_links","question":"Implementation links","support":"supported","answer":"A change groups requirement deltas, design and implementation tasks.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"later_retrieval","question":"Later retrieval","support":"supported","answer":"show retrieves canonical specs or named changes.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"drift_detection","question":"Drift detection","support":"partial","answer":"The expanded-profile verify workflow compares code against the change artifacts on request and reports mismatches. No continuous or automatic drift detection is documented.","evidenceIds":["openspec:b06-reviewing"]},{"id":"review_integration","question":"Review integration","support":"supported","answer":"Verify compares implementation against the change artifacts and reports readiness.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-stores"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-22","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-stores","openspec:b06-team-workflow","openspec:b06-reviewing"]}},{"id":"COORD-01","title":"Parallel work","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:COORD-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec tracks plans and task checklists but does not own or run concurrent coding-agent sessions.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"concurrent_sessions","question":"Concurrent sessions","support":"unsupported","answer":"The command graph and workflow skills do not start or manage coding-agent sessions.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"concurrent_tasks","question":"Concurrent tasks","support":"unknown","answer":"Concurrent tasks: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"quotas","question":"Quotas","support":"unknown","answer":"Quotas: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"observed_concurrency","question":"Observed concurrency","support":"unknown","answer":"Observed concurrency: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"status_visibility","question":"Status visibility","support":"unknown","answer":"Status visibility: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: concurrent_tasks, quotas, observed_concurrency, status_visibility."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-17","nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]}},{"id":"COORD-02","title":"Ownership and dispatch","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:COORD-02","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"COORD-03","title":"Inspectable delegation and communication","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:COORD-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec supplies workflow instructions for an existing assistant without a product-owned coordinator or agent-session messaging tools.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"roles","question":"Roles","support":"unknown","answer":"Roles: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"model_harness_effort","question":"Model harness effort","support":"unknown","answer":"Model harness effort: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"messages","question":"Messages","support":"unknown","answer":"Messages: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"results_return","question":"Results return","support":"unknown","answer":"Results return: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"cross_harness","question":"Cross harness","support":"unknown","answer":"Cross harness: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"orchestration_owner","question":"Orchestration owner","support":"unsupported","answer":"No coordinator session, agent-session delegation or inter-agent messaging tools exist in the inspected CLI and workflow skills.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"activation","question":"Activation","support":"unknown","answer":"Activation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"authentication","question":"Authentication","support":"unknown","answer":"Authentication: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"live_progress","question":"Live progress","support":"unknown","answer":"Live progress: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retained_results","question":"Retained results","support":"unknown","answer":"Retained results: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"followup","question":"Followup","support":"unknown","answer":"Followup: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"invocation","question":"Invocation","support":"unknown","answer":"Invocation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: roles, model_harness_effort, messages, results_return, cross_harness, activation, authentication, live_progress, retained_results, followup, invocation."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-17","nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]}},{"id":"COORD-04","title":"Unattended triggers","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:COORD-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec workflows are invoked by a user or an external assistant; the product has no schedule or event runner.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"schedules","question":"Schedules","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected CLI and workflow skills implement no scheduled starts.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"events","question":"Events","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected CLI and workflow skills implement no event-triggered agent starts.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"recurring_tasks","question":"Recurring tasks","support":"unsupported","answer":"The inspected CLI and workflow skills implement no recurring agent-run scheduler.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"completion_conditions","question":"Completion conditions","support":"unknown","answer":"Completion conditions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"scheduler_location","question":"Scheduler location","support":"unknown","answer":"Scheduler location: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"overlaps","question":"Overlaps","support":"unknown","answer":"Overlaps: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retries","question":"Retries","support":"unknown","answer":"Retries: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"client_independence","question":"Client independence","support":"unknown","answer":"Client independence: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: completion_conditions, scheduler_location, overlaps, retries, client_independence."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-17","nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]}},{"id":"COORD-05","title":"Intervention and attention","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:COORD-05","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Apply pauses when tasks are unclear or errors block implementation.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"pause","question":"Pause","support":"unknown","answer":"Pause: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"stop","question":"Stop","support":"unknown","answer":"Stop: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"resume","question":"Resume","support":"unknown","answer":"Resume: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"steer","question":"Steer","support":"unknown","answer":"Steer: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"notifications","question":"Notifications","support":"unknown","answer":"Notifications: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"pending_decisions","question":"Pending decisions","support":"supported","answer":"Apply pauses and asks about unclear tasks or errors.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"escalation","question":"Escalation","support":"unknown","answer":"Escalation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"visible_errors","question":"Visible errors","support":"unknown","answer":"Visible errors: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"chat_terminal_parity","question":"Chat terminal parity","support":"unknown","answer":"Chat terminal parity: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retained_history","question":"Retained history","support":"supported","answer":"Tracked task checkboxes preserve completed work.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills"]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: pause, stop, resume, steer, notifications, escalation, visible_errors, chat_terminal_parity."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills"]}},{"id":"COORD-06","title":"Fleet and epic management UI","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:COORD-06","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"COORD-07","title":"Workflow flexibility and orchestration visibility","group":{"id":3,"name":"Coordination and automation"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:COORD-07","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Profiles, schemas and natural-language workflows customize planning and implementation.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"quick_task","question":"Quick task","support":"supported","answer":"Propose can draft all planning artifacts in one pass.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"growing_epic","question":"Growing epic","support":"unknown","answer":"Growing epic: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"presets","question":"Presets","support":"supported","answer":"Core/custom workflow profiles select installed skills.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"natural_language","question":"Natural language","support":"supported","answer":"Explore and propose accept a plain description.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"agent_configuration","question":"Agent configuration","support":"supported","answer":"Project YAML adds context, rules and operation guidance.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"in_run_changes","question":"In run changes","support":"supported","answer":"Update-change revises existing planning artifacts with confirmation.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"live_roles","question":"Live roles","support":"unknown","answer":"Live roles: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retained_relationships","question":"Retained relationships","support":"unknown","answer":"Retained relationships: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"discoverability","question":"Discoverability","support":"unknown","answer":"Discoverability: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"auth_friction","question":"Auth friction","support":"unknown","answer":"Auth friction: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: growing_epic, live_roles, retained_relationships, discoverability, auth_friction."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-config","openspec:nov07-skills"]}},{"id":"RUN-01","title":"Laptop-independent execution","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:RUN-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec runs its CLI and planning workflow on the user-controlled machine with an installed assistant. It provides no vendor-managed coding runtime; remote continuation depends on the assistant host.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13 Source-depth answers added 2026-11-16 from release v2.0.0 (d12c28177767); older citations identify their own revisions.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":["local"],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"local","question":"Local","support":"supported","answer":"The CLI and assistant read and edit local project files on the user-controlled machine.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"byo_remote","question":"Byo remote","support":"unsupported","answer":"OpenSpec runs no agents, so it offers no remote-host execution mode of its own.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]},{"id":"self_hosted","question":"Self hosted","support":"unsupported","answer":"No service exists to self-host beyond the local CLI.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]},{"id":"managed_cloud","question":"Managed cloud","support":"unsupported","answer":"OpenSpec has no vendor-operated agent executor in its released CLI package.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"hybrid","question":"Hybrid","support":"unsupported","answer":"No execution modes exist to combine.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]},{"id":"provisioning","question":"Provisioning","support":"unsupported","answer":"OpenSpec provisions no machines.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]},{"id":"payer","question":"Payer","support":"unsupported","answer":"OpenSpec supplies no compute to pay for.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]},{"id":"resources","question":"Resources","support":"unsupported","answer":"OpenSpec manages no compute resources.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]},{"id":"region","question":"Region","support":"unsupported","answer":"No region concept exists.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]},{"id":"expiry","question":"Expiry","support":"unsupported","answer":"No lifetime limit exists.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]},{"id":"client_disconnect","question":"Client disconnect","support":"unsupported","answer":"OpenSpec has no running work to continue; its state is files in the repository.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]},{"id":"other_device_continuation","question":"Other device continuation","support":"partial","answer":"Specs live in repository files, so another device can continue by pulling them; no running session exists to continue.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-readme"]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-22","nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply","openspec:v200-n-exec","openspec:v200-readme"]}},{"id":"RUN-02","title":"Workspace and process isolation","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:RUN-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec edits artifacts in existing project directories; it provisions no Git worktree, container or VM isolation.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"checkout","question":"Checkout","support":"unknown","answer":"Checkout: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"branch","question":"Branch","support":"unknown","answer":"Branch: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"worktree","question":"Worktree","support":"unsupported","answer":"The CLI and workflow skills do not provision Git worktrees.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"container","question":"Container","support":"unsupported","answer":"The CLI and workflow skills do not provision containers.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"vm","question":"Vm","support":"unsupported","answer":"The CLI and workflow skills do not provision virtual machines.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"os_sandbox","question":"Os sandbox","support":"unknown","answer":"Os sandbox: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"filesystem","question":"Filesystem","support":"unknown","answer":"Filesystem: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"process","question":"Process","support":"unknown","answer":"Process: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"network","question":"Network","support":"unknown","answer":"Network: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"secrets","question":"Secrets","support":"unknown","answer":"Secrets: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"code_separation","question":"Code separation","support":"unknown","answer":"Code separation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"security_boundary","question":"Security boundary","support":"unknown","answer":"Security boundary: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: checkout, branch, os_sandbox, filesystem, process, network, secrets, code_separation, security_boundary."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-17","nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-apply"]}},{"id":"RUN-03","title":"Recovery, expiry and continuity","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:RUN-03","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"RUN-04","title":"Development environment reliability","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:RUN-04","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"RUN-05","title":"Limits and failure handling","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:RUN-05","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"RUN-06","title":"Truthful status and operational statistics","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:RUN-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"CLI reports planning and checklist status, not verified agent runtime statistics.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"logs","question":"Logs","support":"unknown","answer":"Logs: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"traces","question":"Traces","support":"unknown","answer":"Traces: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"failure_reasons","question":"Failure reasons","support":"supported","answer":"Validate reports structural spec errors and proposed fixes.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"usage_export","question":"Usage export","support":"unknown","answer":"Usage export: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_stats","question":"Task stats","support":"supported","answer":"List/status count checked task boxes.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli"]},{"id":"agent_stats","question":"Agent stats","support":"unknown","answer":"Agent stats: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"project_stats","question":"Project stats","support":"unknown","answer":"Project stats: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"time_stats","question":"Time stats","support":"unknown","answer":"Time stats: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"failure_status","question":"Failure status","support":"unknown","answer":"Failure status: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"approval_status","question":"Approval status","support":"unknown","answer":"Approval status: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"reconnect_consistency","question":"Reconnect consistency","support":"unknown","answer":"Reconnect consistency: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"performance_method","question":"Performance method","support":"unknown","answer":"Performance method: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"responsiveness","question":"Responsiveness","support":"unknown","answer":"Responsiveness: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: logs, traces, usage_export, agent_stats, project_stats, time_stats, failure_status, approval_status, reconnect_consistency, performance_method, responsiveness."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli"]}},{"id":"RUN-07","title":"Per-task API and compute cost","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:RUN-07","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"RUN-08","title":"Compute-aware scheduling and verification","group":{"id":4,"name":"Execution and reliability"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:RUN-08","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"TEAM-01","title":"Live human collaboration","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:TEAM-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec shares planning artifacts through ordinary Git repositories; it has no shared agent prompting session.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"visibility","question":"Visibility","support":"supported","answer":"Teammates see committed store artifacts after pulling.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"discussion","question":"Discussion","support":"partial","answer":"Store specs and changes may be reviewed in ordinary Git pull requests outside OpenSpec.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"comments","question":"Comments","support":"unknown","answer":"Comments: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"presence","question":"Presence","support":"unknown","answer":"Presence: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"coprompting","question":"Coprompting","support":"unsupported","answer":"The CLI and store files have no multi-user agent-session input or ordering mechanism.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-store"]},{"id":"ordering","question":"Ordering","support":"unknown","answer":"Ordering: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"conflicts","question":"Conflicts","support":"partial","answer":"Users manage Git sharing and conflicts; OpenSpec performs no Git sync.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"attribution","question":"Attribution","support":"unknown","answer":"Attribution: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"permissions","question":"Permissions","support":"unknown","answer":"Permissions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"plan_restrictions","question":"Plan restrictions","support":"unknown","answer":"Plan restrictions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"owner_online","question":"Owner online","support":"unknown","answer":"Owner online: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: comments, presence, ordering, attribution, permissions, plan_restrictions, owner_online."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-17","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-stores","openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-store"]}},{"id":"TEAM-02","title":"Roles and access boundaries","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:TEAM-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec has no workspace identity service, named team roles or enterprise SSO. Store access follows external Git-host permissions.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"organization_roles","question":"Organization roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"No organization role or membership permission model exists in the CLI.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-store"]},{"id":"project_roles","question":"Project roles","support":"unsupported","answer":"Project and store files use filesystem and external Git access, without product-owned team roles.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-store"]},{"id":"task_roles","question":"Task roles","support":"unknown","answer":"Task roles: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"membership","question":"Membership","support":"unknown","answer":"Membership: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"sso","question":"Sso","support":"unsupported","answer":"No SAML/OIDC team SSO service exists in the released CLI.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-store"]},{"id":"provisioning","question":"Provisioning","support":"unknown","answer":"Provisioning: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"unauthorized_access","question":"Unauthorized access","support":"unknown","answer":"Unauthorized access: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"revocation","question":"Revocation","support":"unknown","answer":"Revocation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"plan_scope","question":"Plan scope","support":"unknown","answer":"Plan scope: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: task_roles, membership, provisioning, unauthorized_access, revocation, plan_scope."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-17","nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-store"]}},{"id":"TEAM-03","title":"Approvals and temporary access","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:TEAM-03","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"TEAM-04","title":"Decision and activity history","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:TEAM-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Specification and archived change files remain available through the user repository.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"actions","question":"Actions","support":"unknown","answer":"Actions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"approvals","question":"Approvals","support":"unknown","answer":"Approvals: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"edits","question":"Edits","support":"unknown","answer":"Edits: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"discussion","question":"Discussion","support":"unknown","answer":"Discussion: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"decisions","question":"Decisions","support":"unknown","answer":"Decisions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"cross_user_persistence","question":"Cross user persistence","support":"unknown","answer":"Cross user persistence: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"cross_session_persistence","question":"Cross session persistence","support":"supported","answer":"Markdown artifacts remain on disk across assistant sessions.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"export","question":"Export","support":"supported","answer":"Files can be copied or committed with ordinary Git.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"mutability","question":"Mutability","support":"supported","answer":"Users edit ordinary files; no immutable audit history is established.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"retention","question":"Retention","support":"unknown","answer":"Retention: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"integrity","question":"Integrity","support":"unknown","answer":"Integrity: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: actions, approvals, edits, discussion, decisions, cross_user_persistence, retention, integrity."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-stores"]}},{"id":"TEAM-05","title":"Review experience and guidance","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:TEAM-05","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec prints task and artifact progress and supplies verification instructions; it has no code-diff review interface.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"pending_reviews","question":"Pending reviews","support":"unknown","answer":"Pending reviews: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"change_understanding","question":"Change understanding","support":"unsupported","answer":"The terminal view prints status and checklist progress, not proposed code changes or code diffs.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli"]},{"id":"evidence_navigation","question":"Evidence navigation","support":"unknown","answer":"Evidence navigation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"comments","question":"Comments","support":"unknown","answer":"Comments: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"request_changes","question":"Request changes","support":"unknown","answer":"Request changes: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"shipping_guidance","question":"Shipping guidance","support":"unknown","answer":"Shipping guidance: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"effort","question":"Effort","support":"unknown","answer":"Effort: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"missed_evidence","question":"Missed evidence","support":"unknown","answer":"Missed evidence: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"keyboard","question":"Keyboard","support":"unknown","answer":"Keyboard: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"narrow_screen","question":"Narrow screen","support":"unknown","answer":"Narrow screen: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"context_switching","question":"Context switching","support":"unknown","answer":"Context switching: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"roles","question":"Roles","support":"unknown","answer":"Roles: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retained_context","question":"Retained context","support":"unknown","answer":"Retained context: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: pending_reviews, evidence_navigation, comments, request_changes, shipping_guidance, effort, missed_evidence, keyboard, narrow_screen, context_switching, roles, retained_context."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-17","nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli"]}},{"id":"TEAM-06","title":"Colleague takeover and continuity","group":{"id":5,"name":"Human collaboration and control"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:TEAM-06","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"SHIP-01","title":"Retained artifacts and outputs","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:SHIP-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Change folders retain documents and implementation checklists.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"diffs","question":"Diffs","support":"unknown","answer":"Diffs: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"documents","question":"Documents","support":"supported","answer":"Proposal, design, specifications and tasks are files.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"screenshots","question":"Screenshots","support":"unknown","answer":"Screenshots: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"recordings","question":"Recordings","support":"unknown","answer":"Recordings: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"previews","question":"Previews","support":"unknown","answer":"Previews: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"test_outputs","question":"Test outputs","support":"unknown","answer":"Test outputs: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"reviewer_outputs","question":"Reviewer outputs","support":"partial","answer":"Verify produces an implementation assessment; durable storage of that assessment is not specified.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"gallery","question":"Gallery","support":"unknown","answer":"Gallery: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"task_links","question":"Task links","support":"supported","answer":"Artifacts share a named change directory.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"revision_links","question":"Revision links","support":"unknown","answer":"Revision links: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"persistence","question":"Persistence","support":"supported","answer":"Archive retains the full folder under a dated path.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"child_findings","question":"Child findings","support":"unknown","answer":"Child findings: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"prompt_leakage","question":"Prompt leakage","support":"unknown","answer":"Prompt leakage: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: diffs, screenshots, recordings, previews, test_outputs, gallery, revision_links, child_findings, prompt_leakage."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-schema","openspec:nov07-skills"]}},{"id":"SHIP-02","title":"Verification and spec gates","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:SHIP-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Structural validation and report-only verification are documented; archive offers bypasses.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"tests","question":"Tests","support":"unknown","answer":"Tests: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"lint","question":"Lint","support":"unknown","answer":"Lint: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"types","question":"Types","support":"unknown","answer":"Types: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"ci","question":"Ci","support":"unknown","answer":"Ci: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"independent_review","question":"Independent review","support":"unknown","answer":"Independent review: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"spec_checks","question":"Spec checks","support":"supported","answer":"Validate checks requirement/scenario structure and archive merge issues.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-config"]},{"id":"required_checks","question":"Required checks","support":"unknown","answer":"Required checks: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"failure_blocking","question":"Failure blocking","support":"partial","answer":"Archive refuses invalid deltas unless validation is explicitly bypassed.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-config"]},{"id":"requirement_conflicts","question":"Requirement conflicts","support":"unknown","answer":"Requirement conflicts: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"configured_policy","question":"Configured policy","support":"supported","answer":"Project rules can ask the agent to run lint/tests.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-config"]},{"id":"enforced_policy","question":"Enforced policy","support":"partial","answer":"Prompt guidance is not an execution gate; archive allows --no-validate, and incomplete tasks only warn.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-config"]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: tests, lint, types, ci, independent_review, required_checks, requirement_conflicts."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-cli","openspec:nov07-skills","openspec:nov07-config"]}},{"id":"SHIP-03","title":"Git and pull request workflow","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:SHIP-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec leaves code commits and pull requests to the user and coding assistant; its native workflow does not create or manage pull requests, branches or project commits.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 2.0.0, commit d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106; inspected 2026-11-13; branches and commits at v2.1.1 0c737dc","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"branches","question":"Branches","support":"unsupported","answer":"Docs state OpenSpec never branches; a bounded search of v2.1.1 src found no branch, switch, checkout -b or worktree invocation. Users create branches themselves.","evidenceIds":["openspec:b06-team-workflow","openspec:b06-store-git"]},{"id":"worktrees","question":"Worktrees","support":"unknown","answer":"Worktrees: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"commits","question":"Commits","support":"unsupported","answer":"OpenSpec never commits in the project. The only commit in src is one initial commit of a new beta store at setup, skippable with --no-init-git.","evidenceIds":["openspec:b06-team-workflow","openspec:b06-store-git"]},{"id":"pull_requests","question":"Pull requests","support":"unsupported","answer":"The command graph, workflow templates and store documentation provide no product-owned pull request creation or management action.","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-store","openspec:gaps-apply"]},{"id":"comments","question":"Comments","support":"unknown","answer":"Comments: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"ci_response","question":"Ci response","support":"unknown","answer":"Ci response: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"rebase","question":"Rebase","support":"unknown","answer":"Rebase: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"conflicts","question":"Conflicts","support":"unknown","answer":"Conflicts: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"product_state","question":"Product state","support":"unknown","answer":"Product state: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Documentation and pinned source inspection only; no hands-on scenario was run.","Other atomic questions remain unestablished: worktrees, comments, ci_response, rebase, conflicts, product_state."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-13","ageDays":9,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-22","nextCheckAt":"2027-03-13","evidenceIds":["openspec:gaps-cli","openspec:gaps-store","openspec:gaps-apply","openspec:b06-team-workflow","openspec:b06-store-git"]}},{"id":"SHIP-04","title":"Merge and deployment authority","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:SHIP-04","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"SHIP-05","title":"Completion evidence and rollback","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:SHIP-05","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"SHIP-06","title":"Batch review and high-volume shipping","group":{"id":6,"name":"Verification and delivery"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:SHIP-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"Bulk archive reviews several changes and syncs deltas before archiving.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"review_queue","question":"Review queue","support":"unknown","answer":"Review queue: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"summaries","question":"Summaries","support":"supported","answer":"Bulk archive shows a status table for selected changes.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"grouping","question":"Grouping","support":"unknown","answer":"Grouping: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"risk_size_filters","question":"Risk size filters","support":"unknown","answer":"Risk size filters: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"findings","question":"Findings","support":"unknown","answer":"Findings: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"artifacts","question":"Artifacts","support":"unknown","answer":"Artifacts: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"request_changes","question":"Request changes","support":"unknown","answer":"Request changes: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"exact_revision_approval","question":"Exact revision approval","support":"unknown","answer":"Exact revision approval: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"dependency_queues","question":"Dependency queues","support":"partial","answer":"When changes touch the same spec, bulk archive checks implementation and applies implemented deltas oldest first; no merge/release queue is established.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"next_actions","question":"Next actions","support":"supported","answer":"Summary reports archived, skipped and failed changes.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills"]},{"id":"stale_approval_invalidation","question":"Stale approval invalidation","support":"unknown","answer":"Stale approval invalidation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"check_deduplication","question":"Check deduplication","support":"unknown","answer":"Check deduplication: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: review_queue, grouping, risk_size_filters, findings, artifacts, request_changes, exact_revision_approval, stale_approval_invalidation, check_deduplication."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-skills"]}},{"id":"OWN-01","title":"Source and license","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:OWN-01","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"The OpenSpec application repository is MIT licensed.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"client_license","question":"Client license","support":"supported","answer":"MIT license covers the OpenSpec repository.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-license"]},{"id":"server_license","question":"Server license","support":"unknown","answer":"Server license: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"hosted_extensions","question":"Hosted extensions","support":"unknown","answer":"Hosted extensions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"source_visibility","question":"Source visibility","support":"supported","answer":"Application source is public.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-license"]},{"id":"source_revision","question":"Source revision","support":"supported","answer":"License checked at commit 0fa4a9705c20ef1c571fe3ded74435733e4b73a1.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-license"]},{"id":"hosted_parity","question":"Hosted parity","support":"unknown","answer":"Hosted parity: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: server_license, hosted_extensions, hosted_parity."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-license"]}},{"id":"OWN-02","title":"Hosting and exit","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:OWN-02","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"The CLI and durable Markdown planning files run on user-controlled machines. No vendor account or sign-in is needed.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07; account_independence at v2.1.1 0c737dc","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"self_hosting","question":"Self hosting","support":"supported","answer":"Install the local CLI; stores are local Git checkouts.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"vendor_dependencies","question":"Vendor dependencies","support":"unknown","answer":"Vendor dependencies: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"export","question":"Export","support":"supported","answer":"Copy or commit the specification/change files.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"import","question":"Import","support":"unknown","answer":"Import: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"formats","question":"Formats","support":"supported","answer":"Markdown artifacts and YAML metadata remain readable without the CLI.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-stores"]},{"id":"cancellation","question":"Cancellation","support":"unknown","answer":"Cancellation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"account_independence","question":"Account independence","support":"supported","answer":"The v2.1.1 CLI has no login, auth or account command; its only outbound calls are opt-out telemetry, a release version check and optional feedback through the user's gh CLI.","evidenceIds":["openspec:b06-cli-commands"]},{"id":"history_portability","question":"History portability","support":"supported","answer":"Archived change folders remain ordinary files after uninstalling.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-stores"]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: vendor_dependencies, import, cancellation."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-22","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov07-stores","openspec:b06-cli-commands"]}},{"id":"OWN-03","title":"Data handling and telemetry","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:OWN-03","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec documents telemetry identifiers and opt-out controls. Telemetry is on by default outside CI, announced by a one-time stderr notice without a consent prompt.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07; telemetry defaults and notice at v2.1.1 0c737dc","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"code_data","question":"Code data","support":"unknown","answer":"Code data: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"prompts","question":"Prompts","support":"unknown","answer":"Prompts: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"credentials","question":"Credentials","support":"unknown","answer":"Credentials: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"logs","question":"Logs","support":"unknown","answer":"Logs: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"artifacts","question":"Artifacts","support":"unknown","answer":"Artifacts: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"retention","question":"Retention","support":"unknown","answer":"Retention: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"deletion","question":"Deletion","support":"unknown","answer":"Deletion: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"training","question":"Training","support":"unknown","answer":"Training: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"residency","question":"Residency","support":"unknown","answer":"Residency: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"subprocessors","question":"Subprocessors","support":"unknown","answer":"Subprocessors: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"telemetry_disclosure","question":"Telemetry disclosure","support":"supported","answer":"Global config contains an anonymous identifier and noticeSeen state.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-telemetry"]},{"id":"telemetry_defaults","question":"Telemetry defaults","support":"supported","answer":"On by default: unset telemetry.enabled means on; disabled automatically in CI and by OPENSPEC_TELEMETRY=0 or DO_NOT_TRACK. Collects command names and version only, without IP.","evidenceIds":["openspec:b06-telemetry-code","openspec:b06-readme-telemetry"]},{"id":"telemetry_controls","question":"Telemetry controls","support":"supported","answer":"Set telemetry.enabled=false, OPENSPEC_TELEMETRY=0 or DO_NOT_TRACK=1.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-telemetry"]},{"id":"consent_prompt","question":"Consent prompt","support":"unsupported","answer":"No consent prompt: the first non-JSON run prints a one-line stderr notice with opt-out instructions, then collection proceeds. Nothing is sent before that notice has been shown.","evidenceIds":["openspec:b06-telemetry-code"]},{"id":"provider_separation","question":"Provider separation","support":"unknown","answer":"Provider separation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: code_data, prompts, credentials, logs, artifacts, retention, deletion, training, residency, subprocessors, provider_separation."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-22","nextCheckAt":"2026-12-07","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-telemetry","openspec:b06-telemetry-code","openspec:b06-readme-telemetry"]}},{"id":"OWN-04","title":"Price and included usage","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:OWN-04","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec is an MIT open-source npm package with no paid plan or price published; it runs inside your existing AI coding assistant, and that assistant's costs are separate.","availability":"unknown","delivery":"unknown","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"First-party pricing sources read 2026-11-10 Source-depth answers added 2026-11-16 from release v2.0.0 (d12c28177767); older citations identify their own revisions.","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"currency","question":"Currency","support":"unsupported","answer":"No price exists.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"interval","question":"Interval","support":"unsupported","answer":"No billing interval exists.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"seats","question":"Seats","support":"unsupported","answer":"No seat charge exists.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"seat_minimum","question":"Seat minimum","support":"unsupported","answer":"No seat minimum exists.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"workspace_fees","question":"Workspace fees","support":"unsupported","answer":"No workspace fee exists.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"included_usage","question":"Included usage","support":"unsupported","answer":"No usage is included; the user's AI tools bill their own use.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"credits","question":"Credits","support":"unsupported","answer":"No credits are offered.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"trial","question":"Trial","support":"unsupported","answer":"No trial exists.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"overages","question":"Overages","support":"unsupported","answer":"No overages exist.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"taxes","question":"Taxes","support":"unsupported","answer":"No tax treatment applies to free software.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"model_cost","question":"Model cost","support":"supported","answer":"Model use happens inside the user's own AI coding tools and is billed by their providers.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-readme"]},{"id":"compute_cost","question":"Compute cost","support":"unsupported","answer":"OpenSpec runs no compute; the user's machine runs the CLI.","evidenceIds":["openspec:v200-n-exec"]}],"limitations":["First-party pricing pages, terms and licences read 2026-11-10; no purchase, billing or authenticated account test."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-10","ageDays":12,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-17","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-24","evidenceIds":["openspec:home-nov10","openspec:license-nov10","openspec:v200-readme","openspec:v200-lic","openspec:v200-n-exec"]}},{"id":"OWN-05","title":"Scenario cost and controls","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:OWN-05","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"OWN-06","title":"Availability and support","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:OWN-06","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec's current release is v2.1.1 (2026-11-19); multi-repo store workflows remain beta. v1.17.0 announced, and v2.0.0 (2026-11-11) carried out, removal of the /opsx:* command files and Amazon Q support, with an upgrade guide.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec v2.1.1 (0c737dc, 2026-11-19), release status rechecked 2026-11-22; v1.16.1 documentation checked 2026-11-07; deprecation from v1.17.0 and v2.0.0 release notes","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"release_stage","question":"Release stage","support":"supported","answer":"The CLI has published stable releases (current v2.1.1); multi-repo stores are separately labeled beta.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-release","openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov22-releases","openspec:nov22-stores-beta"]},{"id":"access_restrictions","question":"Access restrictions","support":"unknown","answer":"Access restrictions: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"support","question":"Support","support":"supported","answer":"Repository README/docs direct questions to Discord and GitHub issues.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-release","openspec:nov07-install"]},{"id":"response_commitments","question":"Response commitments","support":"unknown","answer":"Response commitments: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"release_activity","question":"Release activity","support":"supported","answer":"v2.1.1 (2026-11-19) is the latest release, after v2.1.0 (2026-11-17), v2.0.0 (2026-11-11), v1.17.0 (2026-11-09) and v1.16.1 (2026-11-07).","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-release","openspec:nov07-install","openspec:nov22-releases"]},{"id":"status_history","question":"Status history","support":"unknown","answer":"Status history: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"deprecation","question":"Deprecation","support":"supported","answer":"v1.17.0 (2026-11-09) announced that command files go away in 2.0 and added an in-CLI notice; v2.0.0 (2026-11-11) removed /opsx:* commands (skills remain) and Amazon Q support, and openspec update cleans up unedited old files.","evidenceIds":["openspec:b06-rel-1-17","openspec:b06-rel-2-0"]},{"id":"export_options","question":"Export options","support":"unknown","answer":"Export options: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: access_restrictions, response_commitments, status_history, export_options."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-22","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-21","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-release","openspec:nov07-install","openspec:b06-rel-1-17","openspec:b06-rel-2-0","openspec:nov22-releases","openspec:nov22-stores-beta"]}},{"id":"OWN-07","title":"Enterprise assurance","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:OWN-07","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}},{"id":"OWN-08","title":"Useful free tier and evaluation access","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:OWN-08","verificationStatus":"agent-cross-checked","support":"partial","answer":"OpenSpec is freely installable MIT software; coding assistant costs are separate.","availability":"generally-available","delivery":"native","scope":{"surfaceIds":["framework"],"version":"OpenSpec 1.16.1; documentation checked 2026-11-07","plan":null,"os":[],"executionModes":[],"region":null,"harness":null,"surfaces":[{"id":"framework","name":"OpenSpec CLI and agent workflow","type":"framework"}]},"questions":[{"id":"ongoing_free","question":"Ongoing free","support":"supported","answer":"OpenSpec can be downloaded and used under the MIT grant.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-license","openspec:nov07-install"]},{"id":"trial","question":"Trial","support":"unknown","answer":"Trial: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"credits_trial","question":"Credits trial","support":"unknown","answer":"Credits trial: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"self_host_cost","question":"Self host cost","support":"unknown","answer":"Self host cost: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"paid_only","question":"Paid only","support":"unknown","answer":"Paid only: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"early_access","question":"Early access","support":"unknown","answer":"Early access: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"free_scenarios","question":"Free scenarios","support":"supported","answer":"Local specification planning and archive workflows are available in the installed CLI.","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-license","openspec:nov07-install"]},{"id":"card_required","question":"Card required","support":"unknown","answer":"Card required: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"usage_caps","question":"Usage caps","support":"unknown","answer":"Usage caps: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]},{"id":"paid_evaluation","question":"Paid evaluation","support":"unknown","answer":"Paid evaluation: no explicit product-scoped answer found in the checked first-party material.","evidenceIds":[]}],"limitations":["Not established by this source pass: trial, credits_trial, self_host_cost, paid_only, early_access, card_required, usage_caps, paid_evaluation."],"checkedAt":"2026-11-07","ageDays":15,"crossCheckedAt":"2026-11-07","nextCheckAt":"2026-11-21","evidenceIds":["openspec:nov07-license","openspec:nov07-install"]}},{"id":"OWN-09","title":"Pricing transparency","group":{"id":7,"name":"Ownership, privacy and economics"},"claim":{"productId":"openspec","claimId":"openspec:OWN-09","verificationStatus":"not-published","support":"not-published","answer":"No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.","availability":null,"delivery":null,"scope":null,"questions":[],"limitations":[],"checkedAt":null,"ageDays":null,"crossCheckedAt":null,"nextCheckAt":null,"evidenceIds":[]}}],"sources":[{"id":"openspec:nov07-install","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://openspec.dev/docs/installation","title":"OpenSpec installation","locator":"Install; package managers; uninstalling","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"Standalone CLI binaries cover macOS, Linux and Windows; npm requires Node 22.12+. Removing the CLI leaves Markdown specs and archived changes readable."},{"id":"openspec:nov07-cli","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://openspec.dev/docs/cli","title":"OpenSpec CLI reference","locator":"init; list; view; validate; archive; status; instructions; store","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"CLI creates changes, reads artifacts as JSON, reports readiness and task completion, validates specs and archives changes. Validation can be bypassed; incomplete tasks warn rather than block. Stores do not synchronize Git."},{"id":"openspec:gaps-cli","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106/src/cli/index.ts","title":"OpenSpec: src/cli/index.ts","locator":"Command registrations and imported command implementations; package.json bin/files; src/core/view.ts dashboard","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"The released package exposes the openspec terminal CLI and Markdown workflow skills. Its command graph reads and writes project artifacts; it ships no desktop application, browser server or phone application. The view command prints status and progress to the terminal, not code diffs. Searches across src, skills and package.json for createServer, listen, spawn, worktree, docker, VM, scheduler, SAML and agent sessions found no agent runtime, workspace sandbox, co-prompting service or team identity layer. Child processes cover installation, Git store operations and editor/config helpers, not coding-agent sessions.","commit":"d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106","path":"src/cli/index.ts"},{"id":"openspec:b06-rel-2-0","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/releases/tag/v2.0.0","title":"OpenSpec v2.0.0 release notes","locator":"What changed; How to upgrade","sourceDate":"2026-11-11","retrievedAt":"2026-11-21","finding":"2.0 removes the /opsx:* slash commands in favour of matching skills in .agents/skills/, removes Amazon Q Developer support, and openspec update removes files generated by older versions while keeping edited ones; an upgrade guide is linked."},{"id":"openspec:nov22-command-reconcile","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd/src/core/shared/command-reconcile.ts","title":"OpenSpec command file reconciliation (v2.1.1)","locator":"File header and reconcileCommandFiles; called from src/core/init.ts (lines 1173, 1209) and src/core/update.ts (line 585); src/core/config.ts AI_TOOLS","sourceDate":"2026-11-19","retrievedAt":"2026-11-22","finding":"The module removes the command files earlier versions generated because OpenSpec 2.0 installs skills only, keeping files the user edited. openspec init and openspec update call it for each selected tool and write no command files; generateCommands is used only to recognise previously generated files. Selectable assistants include editor-hosted ones such as GitHub Copilot.","commit":"0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd","path":"src/core/shared/command-reconcile.ts"},{"id":"openspec:nov07-tools","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://openspec.dev/docs/supported-tools","title":"OpenSpec supported tools","locator":"Support matrix; per-tool notes","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"OpenSpec installs skills and commands into coding assistant directories including Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, OpenCode and Pi. These are workflow integrations, not a hosted agent runtime."},{"id":"openspec:gaps-agents","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106/src/core/config.ts","title":"OpenSpec: src/core/config.ts","locator":"AI_TOOLS registry, available=true entries; docs/supported-tools.md shared agents target","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"The shipped tool registry includes Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, OpenCode, Pi, Grok Build and Antigravity. OpenSpec writes workflow skills for these tools. A vendor-neutral .agents target lets other compatible agents consume skills, so omission of Aider is not an explicit incompatibility.","commit":"d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106","path":"src/core/config.ts"},{"id":"openspec:v200-tools","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106/docs/supported-tools.md#L63-L120","title":"OpenSpec docs/supported-tools.md at v2.0.0","locator":"Tool Directory Reference (v2.0.0, d12c28177767)","sourceDate":"2026-11-11","retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"A table of the tools OpenSpec can configure, listing about 50 assistants by ID with skill and command paths; Aider is not among them."},{"id":"openspec:v200-n-aider","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/tree/d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106/src","title":"OpenSpec src/ at v2.0.0","locator":"bounded scan for aider (v2.0.0, d12c28177767)","sourceDate":"2026-11-11","retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Searched aider case-insensitively across src/, docs/ and README.md at v2.0.0: no hits outside an archived 2025 change spec, so no Aider tool configuration exists.","commit":"d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106","path":"src"},{"id":"openspec:src1-tools","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/579fcac57ae00c2dff38f971b6d88b6f1f098b8a/docs/supported-tools.md#L3-L10","title":"OpenSpec docs: Supported Tools","locator":"docs/supported-tools.md lines 3-10 (How It Works) and Tool Directory Reference lines 65-105, commit 579fcac","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"openspec init writes OpenSpec skills and command files into each selected assistant's own directory; the user then invokes the workflow inside that assistant, so OpenSpec runs within the assistant's existing session rather than its own runtime or login."},{"id":"openspec:nov07-stores","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://openspec.dev/docs/stores","title":"OpenSpec stores beta","locator":"Set up a store; references; beta limits","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"Stores separate shared planning into a Git repository and support read-only upstream references. Users push/pull themselves; stale checkouts remain stale. Stores are beta."},{"id":"openspec:b06-team-workflow","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd/docs/team-workflow.md","title":"OpenSpec docs: Team workflow (v2.1.1)","locator":"One rule: OpenSpec doesn't touch git; When to archive","sourceDate":"2026-11-19","retrievedAt":"2026-11-21","finding":"OpenSpec reads and writes plain Markdown under openspec/ and never commits, branches, pushes or pulls in the project, nor clones or syncs a store on its own. Users map a change onto their own branch and PR. Archiving folds deltas into openspec/specs/ and moves the change to openspec/changes/archive/YYYY-MM-DD-<name>/; the archive is kept in the user's Git history."},{"id":"openspec:b06-store-git","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd/src/core/store/git.ts","title":"OpenSpec src/core/store/git.ts (v2.1.1)","locator":"module comment; initGitRepository; commitStoreFiles","sourceDate":"2026-11-19","retrievedAt":"2026-11-21","finding":"The only git write paths in src are beta store setup: git init and one 'Initialize OpenSpec store' commit of the created store files, skippable with --no-init-git. The module states nothing clones, pulls, pushes or syncs. A search of src for spawn/execFile git calls found otherwise only read-only rev-parse probes and no branch, switch, checkout -b or worktree command.","commit":"0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd","path":"src/core/store/git.ts"},{"id":"openspec:nov07-config","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://openspec.dev/docs/project-config","title":"OpenSpec project configuration","locator":"How it works; context; rules; operations","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"Project YAML injects context and artifact-specific rules into agent prompts; operations guide apply/archive. Config edits take effect on the next workflow run and are instructions, not enforced execution policy."},{"id":"openspec:nov07-skills","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://openspec.dev/docs/skills","title":"OpenSpec skills","locator":"propose; apply; update; sync; verify; bulk archive","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"Skills explore ideas, draft plans, edit requirements, check task boxes, verify implementation and archive changes. Verify is report-only; update asks for confirmation before artifact revisions."},{"id":"openspec:nov07-schema","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://openspec.dev/docs/schemas/spec-driven","title":"OpenSpec default schema","locator":"Artifacts; drafting order; delta specs; tasks","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"Proposal, delta specifications, design and task checklist are durable files. Artifact readiness follows schema dependencies; specs have requirements and scenarios; archive merges deltas into canonical specs."},{"id":"openspec:b06-reviewing","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd/docs/reviewing-changes.md","title":"OpenSpec docs: Reviewing changes (v2.1.1)","locator":"After the code: verify","sourceDate":"2026-11-19","retrievedAt":"2026-11-21","finding":"The verify workflow (expanded profile) re-reads the change artifacts and the code on request and reports mismatches; without it, users re-read the change and diff themselves. No continuous or automatic drift check is described."},{"id":"openspec:gaps-apply","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106/skills/openspec-apply-change/SKILL.md","title":"OpenSpec: skills/openspec-apply-change/SKILL.md","locator":"Steps 1-6 and guardrails; src/core/templates/workflows/","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"The apply skill tells the existing assistant to read instructions and implement tasks from local project files. OpenSpec does not start or coordinate agent sessions. The installed CLI and skills have no schedule/event runner. Execution, parallel agent work and remote continuation depend on the assistant environment rather than an OpenSpec-managed executor.","commit":"d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106","path":"skills/openspec-apply-change/SKILL.md"},{"id":"openspec:v200-n-exec","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/tree/d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106/src","title":"OpenSpec src/ at v2.0.0","locator":"bounded scan for execution features (v2.0.0, d12c28177767)","sourceDate":"2026-11-11","retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"Searched ssh, remote host, daemon, vps, sandbox, container, spawn and child_process across src/: only the version check spawns a package-manager command; OpenSpec runs no agents and has no remote or server execution of its own.","commit":"d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106","path":"src"},{"id":"openspec:v200-readme","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106/README.md#L1-L60","title":"OpenSpec README.md at v2.0.0","locator":"what OpenSpec is (v2.0.0, d12c28177767)","sourceDate":"2026-11-11","retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"OpenSpec is a spec framework installed through npm that writes skills and commands into the user's own AI coding tools, which do the work."},{"id":"openspec:gaps-store","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106/docs/stores-beta/user-guide.md","title":"OpenSpec: docs/stores-beta/user-guide.md","locator":"The shape; Two rules; Sharing work is git, on purpose","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-13","finding":"A store is an ordinary Git repository shared by user-managed commits, pushes, pulls and reviews. The source contains no multi-user prompting session, workspace role permissions or enterprise SSO; Git host permissions and review tools remain external."},{"id":"openspec:nov07-license","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/0fa4a9705c20ef1c571fe3ded74435733e4b73a1/LICENSE","title":"OpenSpec MIT license","locator":"MIT grant","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"Repository application is licensed under MIT."},{"id":"openspec:b06-cli-commands","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd/src/cli/index.ts","title":"OpenSpec CLI command registry (v2.1.1)","locator":"program.command registrations; network calls in src","sourceDate":"2026-11-19","retrievedAt":"2026-11-21","finding":"Commands are archive, change, completion, experimental, feedback, generate, init, install, instructions, list, new, schemas, show, status, templates, uninstall, update, validate, version and view; there is no login, auth or account command. The only outbound requests in src are opt-out telemetry, the npm/GitHub release version check, and feedback through the user's own gh CLI.","commit":"0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd","path":"src/cli/index.ts"},{"id":"openspec:nov07-telemetry","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://openspec.dev/docs/configuration/config-json","title":"OpenSpec CLI settings","locator":"telemetry","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"Telemetry stores an anonymous identifier and notice state. Disable telemetry.enabled or set OPENSPEC_TELEMETRY=0 or DO_NOT_TRACK=1."},{"id":"openspec:b06-telemetry-code","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd/src/telemetry/index.ts","title":"OpenSpec src/telemetry/index.ts (v2.1.1)","locator":"isTelemetryEnabled; trackCommand; maybeShowTelemetryNotice","sourceDate":"2026-11-19","retrievedAt":"2026-11-21","finding":"Telemetry is on unless OPENSPEC_TELEMETRY or DO_NOT_TRACK opts out, a CI environment is detected, or telemetry.enabled is false (unset means on). The first non-JSON run prints a one-line stderr notice with opt-out instructions and marks noticeSeen; no event is sent before that notice. There is no consent question; collection proceeds after the notice.","commit":"0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd","path":"src/telemetry/index.ts"},{"id":"openspec:b06-readme-telemetry","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd/README.md","title":"OpenSpec README (v2.1.1)","locator":"Telemetry","sourceDate":"2026-11-19","retrievedAt":"2026-11-21","finding":"Anonymous usage stats (command names and version only); automatically disabled in CI; opt out with telemetry.enabled false (unset means on), OPENSPEC_TELEMETRY=0 or DO_NOT_TRACK=1."},{"id":"openspec:home-nov10","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://openspec.dev/","title":"OpenSpec homepage","locator":"'Public record' section (License: MIT); 'Installation'","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"Lists the license as MIT and installs from npm. The page shows no price, plan or pricing page."},{"id":"openspec:license-nov10","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/main/LICENSE","title":"Fission-AI/OpenSpec LICENSE (MIT)","locator":"Permission grant, first paragraph","sourceDate":null,"retrievedAt":"2026-11-10","finding":"The MIT License lets anyone obtain, use, copy and modify the software free of charge."},{"id":"openspec:v200-lic","productId":"openspec","kind":"source-inspected","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106/LICENSE#L1-L4","title":"OpenSpec LICENSE at v2.0.0","locator":"MIT License header (v2.0.0, d12c28177767)","sourceDate":"2026-11-11","retrievedAt":"2026-11-16","finding":"MIT license; no price, plan or account appears in the README, docs or license.","commit":"d12c2817776779e06891d68230773b3bb673b106","path":"LICENSE"},{"id":"openspec:nov07-release","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/releases/tag/v1.16.1","title":"OpenSpec v1.16.1","locator":"Release notes","sourceDate":"2026-11-07","retrievedAt":"2026-11-07","finding":"Release published 2026-11-07 fixes validation of unknown delta sections and explicit version checks with telemetry disabled."},{"id":"openspec:b06-rel-1-17","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/releases/tag/v1.17.0","title":"OpenSpec v1.17.0 release notes","locator":"Heads-up; 2.0 notice","sourceDate":"2026-11-09","retrievedAt":"2026-11-21","finding":"Announced that command files go away in OpenSpec 2.0, with an in-CLI notice from openspec update and a one-command early switch, tracked in issue #2022."},{"id":"openspec:nov22-releases","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/releases/tag/v2.1.1","title":"OpenSpec v2.1.1 release and release list","locator":"Release list (gh release list) and v2.1.1 notes, retrieved 2026-11-22","sourceDate":"2026-11-19","retrievedAt":"2026-11-22","finding":"v2.1.1 (2026-11-19) is the latest release, not a prerelease, with CLI binaries for macOS, Linux and Windows. Earlier releases: v2.1.0 (2026-11-17), v2.0.0 (2026-11-11), v1.17.0 (2026-11-09) and v1.16.1 (2026-11-07)."},{"id":"openspec:nov22-stores-beta","productId":"openspec","kind":"documented","url":"https://github.com/Fission-AI/OpenSpec/blob/0c737dc1b543249b38b0f4716816fcf493d894dd/docs/existing-projects.md#L119","title":"OpenSpec existing projects guide (v2.1.1)","locator":"Multiple repositories paragraph, line 119","sourceDate":"2026-11-19","retrievedAt":"2026-11-22","finding":"The multi-repository stores feature is labeled beta, with commands and state described as evolving."}],"comparisons":[{"slug":"openspec-vs-podium","productIds":["openspec","podium"],"canonicalUrl":"https://podium.do/compare/agents/openspec-vs-podium/"}],"otherComparisonsUrl":"https://adecomparison.com/compare/?products=openspec"}
