50 of 51 criteria have a sourced finding; 50 were also cross-checked by a second agent. Every comparison that includes Dorothy links here for scope, limitations, atomic answers and sources.
Humans approve the rubric, templates and prototype; they do not review every finding. An agent source cross-check is not a hands-on product test. A missing sourced finding is not evidence that a capability is absent.
macOS-only Electron desktop app (arm64 DMG and zip); the Next.js UI can run in a browser only as a development server without agent features; remote control through Telegram and Slack chats; no mobile apps, CLI or editor extensions.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: macOS (arm64) · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Windows and Linux builds are not produced; Telegram and Slack are chat surfaces, not clients of the UI.
9 atomic answers
Desktop os [supported] electron-builder macOS dmg and zip targets only; release 1.2.10 ships arm64 assets; the site offers Download for Mac. Sources: dorothy:pkg, dorothy:release, dorothy:site.
Mobile apps [unsupported] README and site list no mobile app; remote control uses Telegram and Slack. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Browser [partial] npm run dev serves the UI at localhost:3000, but agent management and terminals need the Electron app. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Mobile browser [unsupported] No phone browser access; the API server binds 127.0.0.1. Sources: dorothy:apiserver.
Cli [unsupported] No product CLI (bounded search of package.json bin and README). Sources: dorothy:pkg.
Editor extensions [unsupported] No editor extension. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Task actions [supported] Start, stop and message agents, kanban, usage in the UI; /start_agent, /stop_agent and /ask from Telegram or Slack. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Notifications [supported] Telegram and Slack notifications for finished agents and permission prompts through hooks. Sources: dorothy:readme, dorothy:hookperm.
Cross device continuity [partial] Telegram and Slack let you check and command agents from a phone while the Mac app runs. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Launches Claude Code, Codex, Gemini CLI, Grok, OpenCode and pi CLIs in PTY terminals through provider modules, plus a local-model agent via Tasmania; no embedded harness; the Super Agent orchestrator is Claude-based.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Claude Code, Codex, Gemini CLI, Grok, OpenCode, pi (terminal CLIs via node-pty)
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: model_providers, custom_adapters; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
5 atomic answers
Harnesses [supported] electron/providers contains claude, codex, gemini, grok, opencode and pi providers; README names Claude Code, Codex, Gemini, Grok and local agents. Sources: dorothy:providers, dorothy:readme.
Model providers [partial] Models come from each CLI; Claude sonnet/opus/haiku selectable; local models via the Tasmania control API. Sources: dorothy:readme, dorothy:tasmania.
Custom adapters [partial] A cli-provider base class exists in the repository but no user-facing adapter API is documented. Sources: dorothy:providers.
Session integration [supported] Spawns each CLI as a PTY process and observes it through hooks and output parsing. Sources: dorothy:agentmgr, dorothy:readme.
Mixed harness operation [supported] Different providers run side by side and automations default to a configurable provider. Sources: dorothy:providers, dorothy:readme.
Agent CLIs use their own sign-ins, so existing Claude, ChatGPT and other subscriptions work as the CLIs allow; no vendor credits or Dorothy account; local models through Tasmania.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Account handling is entirely the CLIs'; Dorothy only shows Claude Code usage.
7 atomic answers
Agent subscriptions [partial] The dashboard screenshot shows Claude Code on Claude Max; each CLI signs in itself. Sources: dorothy:screenshot, dorothy:readme.
Api accounts [partial] Whatever each CLI accepts. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Local models [partial] A local agent type uses the Tasmania control API on localhost:3999; the site also lists Ollama. Sources: dorothy:tasmania, dorothy:site.
Account switching [unsupported] No account switching. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Vendor account requirement [supported] No account needed (site: free forever, no account). Sources: dorothy:site.
Provider restrictions [partial] Autonomous mode launches Claude Code with --dangerously-skip-permissions; no provider-terms discussion. Sources: dorothy:claudeprov.
Download the DMG, install the Claude Code CLI and gh, open a project and create an agent; any project path works with optional git worktrees; GitHub through gh; no cloud or VPS onboarding.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: hosted_git, managed_cloud_setup, byo_vps_onboarding; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
7 atomic answers
First task setup [supported] Download from GitHub Releases, run xattr -cr if macOS says the app is damaged, create an agent with a project path and start it. Sources: dorothy:readme.
No git [supported] Agents run in any project path; worktrees are optional. Sources: dorothy:agentmgr, dorothy:ipc.
Local git without remote [supported] Worktrees use local git worktree add. Sources: dorothy:ipc.
Hosted git [partial] GitHub automations use the gh CLI and JIRA REST; no repository binding UI beyond that. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Prerequisite guidance [supported] README lists Node 18+, Claude Code CLI and gh. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Managed cloud setup [unsupported] No managed cloud. Sources: dorothy:site.
Byo vps onboarding [unsupported] No remote host onboarding; the API server binds 127.0.0.1. Sources: dorothy:apiserver.
Local HTTP agent API on 127.0.0.1 with a token file used by hooks and bots, five stdio MCP servers (orchestrator, kanban, vault, telegram, socialdata) exposing agent control, tasks and automations; no CLI, SDK or inbound webhooks.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
The programmable surface is local and undocumented as an API; MCP is the documented route; stability is not promised.
Api [partial] HTTP API server on 127.0.0.1:31415 with health, hooks, agents, kanban, scheduler, Slack, Telegram and vault routes; not documented as a public API. Sources: dorothy:apiserver.
Mcp server [supported] mcp-orchestrator (26+ tools), mcp-kanban, mcp-vault, mcp-telegram and mcp-socialdata over stdio, registrable in any Claude Code session. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Webhooks [unsupported] Custom webhook source is Planned in the README, not shipped. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Operations [supported] list/get/create/start/send/stop/remove agents and wait_for_agent, output reads, tasks and automations through MCP. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Registers its MCP servers with agent providers, a plugin marketplace and skills from skills.sh per agent, Google Workspace gws MCP integration and Telegram/Slack/GitHub/JIRA connectors; MCP client behavior belongs to the agent CLIs.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: mcp_client, custom_tools, authentication, permission_scope; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
7 atomic answers
Mcp client [partial] Dorothy writes MCP configuration for providers (mcp-config handlers) and the CLIs act as MCP clients. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Tasks are created locally on a Kanban board; GitHub pull requests, issues and releases and JIRA issues are polled by automations and become agent runs, with JIRA items also created as Kanban backlog tasks; Telegram and Slack messages start work.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
GitHub and JIRA remain authoritative; sync is poll-based and one-way except JIRA comments/transitions.
9 atomic answers
Local creation [supported] Kanban create_task and board UI. Sources: dorothy:readme.
No durable plans; the Kanban task has title, description, progress and an agent summary on completion.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: plans, acceptance_criteria, editors, revisions, implementation_links, amendment; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
7 atomic answers
Plans [unsupported] No plan objects. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Acceptance criteria [unsupported] No acceptance criteria field. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Editors [partial] Task text is editable in the board. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Revisions [unsupported] No revision history. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Implementation links [partial] mark_task_done takes a summary; no commit links. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Amendment [partial] send_message to a running agent. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Restart persistence [supported] Tasks persist in ~/.dorothy/kanban-tasks.json. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Kanban columns Backlog, Planned, Ongoing, Done with priority, progress and skill requirements; no epics, hierarchy or enforced blockers.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: epics, hierarchy, blockers, readiness, enforcement, state_propagation, task_to_epic, identity_retention; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
Skills from skills.sh per agent, Claude Code native memory exposed on a Memory page, shared Vault of markdown documents with full-text search and attachments, agent CLAUDE.md files; no stale-context controls.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: instructions, scope, provenance, freshness, takeover_continuity; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
10 atomic answers
Instructions [partial] Handled by agent CLIs; Dorothy edits Claude settings and shows memory. Sources: dorothy:claudemd.
Skills [supported] Install skills per agent; skills view. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Project docs [supported] Vault documents with folders and tags readable by any agent. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Memory [supported] Memory page reads Claude Code native memory; Vault is cross-agent persistent storage. Sources: dorothy:claudemd, dorothy:readme.
Scope [partial] Per Claude project directory for memory; vault is global to the app. Sources: dorothy:claudemd, dorothy:readme.
Provenance [partial] Vault docs have tags and attachments; authorship not recorded. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Correction [supported] vault_update_document and delete tools. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Deletion [supported] vault_delete_document and folder delete. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Freshness [unsupported] No staleness controls. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Takeover continuity [partial] Vault persists in ~/.dorothy/vault.db across sessions. Sources: dorothy:readme.
LSP plugins and vault full-text search; agent CLIs do their own code search; no index.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: code_search, indexing, multimodal_inputs, freshness, access_scope, api_retrieval, citations, conflict_detection, review_enforcement; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
10 atomic answers
Code search [partial] LSP plugin installs for TypeScript, Python, Rust and Go; agents use their CLI tools. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Indexing [unsupported] No repository index. Sources: dorothy:readme.
External knowledge [supported] Google Workspace, Twitter/X SocialData and GitHub/JIRA connectors. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Multimodal inputs [partial] Telegram photo, video and document sending; no image input pipeline documented. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Kanban board with priority, progress, labels, assignment and skill requirements for agent work; no discussion, search, archive or issue views; trackers remain external.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
A task board, not an issue tracker: no comments, search, archive or project views.
17 atomic answers
Create [supported] Create tasks in the UI or by MCP. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Agents operate the same Kanban tasks as humans through mcp-kanban (list, get, create, move, progress, done, assign, delete); no dependencies or claims beyond assignment.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: claim, dependencies, children, attribution, permissions, conflicts; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
14 atomic answers
Shared ids [supported] Tasks have IDs with prefix matching. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Read [supported] list_tasks and get_task. Sources: dorothy:readme.
No living product specification; the Vault is a general document store.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: persistent_requirements, revisions, approvals, implementation_links, drift_detection, review_integration; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
9 atomic answers
Persistent requirements [partial] Vault documents persist across sessions. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Human edits [supported] People can edit vault documents. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Agent edits [supported] vault_create_document and update tools. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Revisions [unsupported] No revision history. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Product-owned Super Agent orchestrator creates, starts, stops, messages and waits on other agents through mcp-orchestrator and temporary agents for one-off tasks; results come from reading output; the Super Agent runs on Claude.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Orchestrator tools take a prompt and model but not a provider, so delegation is Claude Code only.
12 atomic answers
Roles [supported] Super Agent (orchestrator) and worker agents. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Model harness effort [partial] start_agent accepts sonnet/opus/haiku; create_agent has no provider parameter. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Messages [supported] send_message to a running agent and wait_for_agent. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Cron-based scheduled tasks run via launchd or cron even when the app is closed; automations poll GitHub and JIRA on an interval or cron inside the app; Telegram and Slack messages start work; webhooks are planned only.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: events, completion_conditions, overlaps, retries, client_independence; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
8 atomic answers
Schedules [supported] Cron scheduled tasks with launchd on macOS and crontab on Linux. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Events [partial] Polling GitHub and JIRA; Telegram/Slack messages; no webhooks. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Recurring tasks [supported] Scheduled tasks and automations. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Scheduler location [supported] Generated scripts run by launchd or cron on the Mac; the automation scheduler runs inside the app. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Overlaps [partial] Deduplication prevents reprocessing items; overlap of cron runs not documented. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Retries [unsupported] No retries documented. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Client independence [partial] Scheduled tasks run without the app via launchd; automations and bots need the app running. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Stop and Stop All, send_message steering, status waiting set by a permission hook with Telegram/Slack notifications; questions and approvals are answered in the agent terminal; no pause.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: pause, resume, pending_decisions, escalation, chat_terminal_parity; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
Visible errors [supported] Error status for agents. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Chat terminal parity [partial] Telegram/Slack cannot answer permission prompts; they can message the Super Agent. Sources: dorothy:hookperm, dorothy:readme.
Retained history [supported] Agent output history persisted. Sources: dorothy:readme.
No mandatory preset; agents are created with project, skills, model and autonomy per agent; Super Agent takes natural-language instructions; characters and a 3D world visualise agents.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: growing_epic, presets, in_run_changes, retained_relationships, discoverability; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
10 atomic answers
Quick task [supported] Create an agent and start with a prompt. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Growing epic [unsupported] No epics. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Presets [partial] Agent templates and skills. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Natural language [supported] Super Agent and bots accept natural language. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Agent configuration [supported] Skills, model and project context per agent. Sources: dorothy:readme.
In run changes [partial] Messages to running agents; model fixed at start. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Live roles [supported] Super Agent crown and agent cards. Sources: dorothy:screenshot.
Retained relationships [unsupported] No relationship records. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Everything runs locally on the Mac; no remote, self-hosted server or cloud mode; scheduled tasks can fire when the app is closed through launchd.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: local · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: byo_remote, self_hosted, managed_cloud, hybrid, provisioning, resources, region, expiry, client_disconnect, other_device_continuation; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
12 atomic answers
Local [supported] Agents run in PTYs on the user's computer. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Byo remote [unsupported] No remote execution; the API binds loopback. Sources: dorothy:apiserver.
Self hosted [unsupported] No server. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Managed cloud [unsupported] No cloud; free app with no account. Sources: dorothy:site.
Client disconnect [unsupported] Agents are children of the app and stop when it quits (state is restored, processes are not continued). Sources: dorothy:agentmgr.
Other device continuation [partial] Telegram and Slack can command the Mac app but do not continue execution elsewhere. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Each agent has its own PTY; optional git worktrees in a .worktrees folder inside the project, one per branch; secondary project paths; no container, VM or sandbox, and autonomous mode skips permissions.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
A worktree separates files only; agents run as the user with optional permission skipping.
12 atomic answers
Checkout [supported] Agents run in the project path. Sources: dorothy:agentmgr.
Branch [supported] Optional branch per worktree agent. Sources: dorothy:ipc.
Worktree [supported] git worktree add in a .worktrees folder inside the project, one per branch. Sources: dorothy:ipc.
Secrets [unsupported] No secret handling beyond app settings. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Code separation [supported] Worktree per agent when enabled. Sources: dorothy:ipc.
Security boundary [unsupported] No containment claim; skipPermissions defaults to true for created agents. Sources: dorothy:readme, dorothy:claudeprov.
Agent definitions and sessions persist in ~/.dorothy/agents.json and PTYs are re-initialised for restored agents after an app restart; running processes do not survive quitting.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: client_disconnect, worker_crash, service_restart, expiry, process_reconnect, task_resume, context_loss, duplicate_actions, manual_repair, multi_day_continuity; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
12 atomic answers
Client disconnect [unsupported] Quitting the app ends its child agent processes. Sources: dorothy:agentmgr.
Worker crash [partial] Error status is detected from output. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Service restart [partial] Restored agents get a new PTY. Sources: dorothy:agentmgr.
No product limits; agents show Claude Code's own usage-limit messages; MCP wait_for_agent defaults to a 300-second timeout.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: time_limits, turn_limits, token_limits, spend_limits, timeouts, retries, provider_failures, enforcement; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
8 atomic answers
Time limits [partial] wait_for_agent timeoutSeconds default 300. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Usage page with token and cost statistics from Claude Code data, scheduled task logs, hook-driven agent status and live output; no traces or exports.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: traces, failure_reasons, usage_export, task_stats, agent_stats, project_stats, approval_status, reconnect_consistency, performance_method, responsiveness; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
13 atomic answers
Logs [supported] Scheduled task logs under ~/.claude/logs and agent output. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Usage page shows Claude Code token consumption and estimated cost by model from token counts and a price table, plus conversation history and activity patterns; no per-task budgets or alerts.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Claude Code only; costs are estimates from a built-in price table.
14 atomic answers
Task cost [unsupported] No per-task cost. Sources: dorothy:usagepage.
Session cost [partial] Conversation-level usage from Claude Code data. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Coprompting [partial] Multiple authorized Telegram users and Slack members can send tasks to the Super Agent. Sources: dorothy:telegram, dorothy:readme.
Ordering [unsupported] Not documented. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Conflicts [unsupported] Not documented. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Attribution [unsupported] Not documented. Sources: dorothy:readme.
No accounts, roles or SSO; Telegram bot restricts commands to authorized chat IDs.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: organization_roles, project_roles, task_roles, membership, sso, provisioning, unauthorized_access, revocation; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
Agents are created with permission skipping on by default; --permission-mode default or auto can be chosen; a PermissionRequest hook flags waiting but approvals are answered in the agent terminal; no tool, network or delivery approval workflow.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Approval is the agent CLI's own prompt; Dorothy does not enforce policy.
14 atomic answers
Command [partial] Claude Code permission dialog appears in the terminal; hook sets waiting. Sources: dorothy:hookperm.
Local files only (agents.json, processed-items.json, logs); no attributed audit history.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
11 atomic answers
Actions [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Approvals [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Edits [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Discussion [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Decisions [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Cross user persistence [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Cross session persistence [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Export [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Mutability [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Retention [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Integrity [unsupported] Dorothy keeps no attributed activity history (bounded search of electron/ found only state files and logs). Sources: dorothy:readme.
Vault documents, Telegram media sending and terminal output; no diff viewer, artifacts gallery or previews.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: diffs, screenshots, recordings, previews, test_outputs, reviewer_outputs, gallery, task_links, revision_links, child_findings, prompt_leakage; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
13 atomic answers
Diffs [unsupported] No diff viewer. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Documents [supported] Vault markdown documents with attachments. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Screenshots [partial] Agents can send photos through Telegram. Sources: dorothy:readme.
No gates; automations run PR review agents that post comments but cannot block merges.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: tests, lint, types, ci, independent_review, spec_checks, required_checks, failure_blocking, requirement_conflicts, configured_policy, enforced_policy; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
Optional git worktrees per agent; GitHub automations poll PRs and issues and post comments through gh; PR creation and merge are left to the agent's own commands.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: commits, pull_requests, ci_response, rebase, conflicts, product_state; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
9 atomic answers
Branches [supported] Branch per worktree agent. Sources: dorothy:ipc.
Worktrees [supported] Worktree creation and use. Sources: dorothy:ipc.
Commits [unsupported] Agents commit through their own CLIs. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Pull requests [partial] Automations read PRs and post GitHub comments; no PR creation feature. Sources: dorothy:readme.
No delivery tracking beyond JIRA transitions and GitHub comments posted by automations.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: commit_links, pr_links, build_links, deployment_links, delivery_status, retained_evidence, rollback, revert, stale_approval_invalidation; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
Local state; prompts go to the agent CLIs' providers; the app has no analytics dependency (landing site uses Vercel Analytics); bots send messages through Telegram and Slack; update checks use GitHub; no privacy policy found.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
No privacy policy or telemetry statement was found; absence of an SDK in the app is not a guarantee.
15 atomic answers
Code data [supported] Stays local except what agent CLIs send to their providers. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Prompts [partial] Passed to agent CLIs; Telegram/Slack messages traverse those services. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Credentials [partial] Bot tokens in ~/.dorothy/app-settings.json; API token 0600. Sources: dorothy:readme, dorothy:apiserver.
Logs [partial] Local logs including /tmp/dorothy-hooks.log from hooks. Sources: dorothy:hookperm.
Retention [unsupported] No policy. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Deletion [partial] User deletes files or entries. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Training [unsupported] Dorothy does no model processing. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Residency [supported] Local Mac. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Subprocessors [partial] Telegram, Slack and SocialData if enabled by the user. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Telemetry disclosure [unsupported] No telemetry statement found. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Telemetry defaults [supported] Bounded search of package.json, electron/ and src/ found no analytics or telemetry dependency; the landing page uses @vercel/analytics. Sources: dorothy:pkg, dorothy:landing.
Telemetry controls [unsupported] None, because no app telemetry was found. Sources: dorothy:pkg.
Releases about every few months (1.2.8 in May, 1.2.9 in July, 1.2.10 in October 2026); GitHub issues; no commitments.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: support, response_commitments, status_history, deprecation, export_options; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
8 atomic answers
Release stage [supported] Version 1.2.x general releases. Sources: dorothy:release.
Access restrictions [supported] Public download for macOS arm64. Sources: dorothy:release.
Support [partial] GitHub issues linked from the site. Sources: dorothy:site.
Free forever open-source download; every supported scenario is free apart from agent subscriptions; collaboration, remote compute and mobile are not offered.
Scope
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: trial, credits_trial, paid_only, early_access, free_scenarios, card_required, usage_caps, paid_evaluation; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
Self host cost [supported] User hardware. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Paid only [unsupported] Not paid-only. Sources: dorothy:site.
Early access [unsupported] Public releases. Sources: dorothy:release.
Free scenarios [partial] BYO subscriptions, local runs, Telegram/Slack remote control work free; collaboration and managed remote compute are not offered. Sources: dorothy:readme.
Surfaces: Dorothy Electron desktop app (macOS arm64 DMG/zip) · Version: release 1.2.10 (2026-10-23, commit 787568d) · Plan: Open source (MIT) macOS desktop app, free download; no paid plan · OS: Not specified · Execution modes: Not specified · Region: Not specified · Harness: Not specified
Availability
generally-available
Delivery
native
Checked
2026-11-16 (6 days old)
Agent cross-check
2026-11-17
Partly met or absent atomic parts: overages, compute_markup, model_markup, minimum_commitment, sales_only_unknowns; see each atomic answer for the limitation.
Desktop app to orchestrate Claude Code, Codex, Gemini, Grok and local agents in parallel PTY terminals with a Super Agent orchestrator, Kanban, GitHub/JIRA automations, cron tasks, Telegram and Slack remote control, vault and usage tracking; macOS download; MIT.