A source-linked comparison across the complete Podium ADE rubric. 48 criteria sourced for both products; 36 criteria also agent cross-checked for both. 50 rows have at least one sourced finding, including 50 with an agent-cross-checked finding. No score or winner is inferred.
Each row shows a finding's verification status, support, check date and answer. Its scope, limitations, atomic answers and sources are on the product's page. Humans approve the rubric, templates and prototype; they do not review every finding. An agent source cross-check is not a hands-on product test. A missing sourced finding is not evidence that a capability is absent.
Podium ships desktop, CLI and browser clients, including phone-browser control. The native iPhone app is private beta; the complete download offering contains no native Android app.
Desktop apps ship for macOS 14+ (Apple Silicon and Intel), Windows x64 and Linux x64/ARM64; the complete install matrix omits native phone apps and editor extensions. The thinkrail CLI opens the same app in any browser, the web UI adapts to phone viewports over Tailscale, and notifications arrive via desktop alerts plus in-app waiting markers. Same-task state rebuilds on another surface, but running execution does not hand off.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium launches the native Claude Code, Codex, Grok, OpenCode, Cursor and Pi CLIs in persistent terminals on machines you control. The 0.2.0 release calls Pi fully supported. Models come from each harness catalog, and capabilities differ per harness: Pi declares no quota, handoff or hooks. Mixed-harness operation was not exercised.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The only harness is pi, run in-process with no second runtime. Model choice comes from pi provider auth plus JetBrains AI through the user-owned central CLI and user-added OpenAI-compatible servers (1,639 provider/model pairs in the pi 1.5.1 catalogue). Other coding-agent CLIs are only detected as provider-setup signals, never run as harnesses; mixed-harness operation is excluded by the single-engine design.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium supports native coding-agent logins and managed provider credentials. Claude subscriptions (via native login or a managed setup-token) and local ChatGPT/Codex login are supported paths, alongside Anthropic and OpenAI API keys. Docs list billing and hosted metering as not implemented product claims.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Sourcedpartial
ThinkRail uses provider API keys and Pi's native OAuth login, including Anthropic subscription credentials recognized by the embedded runtime. External CLI accounts are setup signals rather than borrowed credentials; there is no ThinkRail credit system.
Docs describe a first-run flow (install, podium, register a Git repository, confirm a detected logged-in harness) and a headless VPS installer with machine joining. Setup time and failure rate were not measured, and no self-serve managed cloud setup is documented. The current README and installation guide use podium.do/download and podium.do/install.sh as the canonical stable entrypoints.
A first-run wizard (intro, privacy question, Connect a model) drops the user on Start/Open project; Start a new project creates an empty git repo, and Clone repository accepts a Git URL. Any local git repo opens as a project, chats without a project work in scratch folders, and GitHub works through the user’s git credentials and gh CLI. No vendor-cloud or user-server hosting path exists.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
The podium CLI covers issue create, show, update, claim, dependencies, artifacts, session send/status/read/stop and review actions, and the server exposes the same issue commands as a bearer-token MCP tool endpoint. No documented public HTTP API, SDK or webhooks were found.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The product-owned thinkrail CLI is a launcher with an exhaustive inventory: open, update and uninstall plus connection flags; it exposes no agent operations. The engine-to-UI wire is internal (/ws plus /health and static routes), with no public API, SDK, MCP server or webhooks in the pinned release.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium gives agents its own issue tools over CLI and MCP, and agent profiles import and export Claude Code agent files. No Podium documentation for user-configured MCP clients, plugins or custom tools was found.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-07. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedsupported
MCP servers come from pi mcp.json and Settings with presets, per-chat visibility and in-chat confirm for data-changing calls. pi packages (extensions, skills, prompts) install from npm, git or local folders for the user or a repo with per-item switches. Skills import from Claude, Codex and other agents’ folders; repo-defined resources stay off until a per-project trust grant, and repo MCP entries need per-entry approval.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Desktop releases use a Tauri 2 shell that serves the Podium web UI; mobile source uses Expo and React Native. A native iPhone release is described as private beta.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The desktop app is an Electrobun package: a native system-webview shell around the same engine host the CLI uses. No native mobile client exists (apps/ holds cli, desktop, web and website only; the install matrix omits mobile) and no hybrid construction exists beyond the system-webview shell.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium issue records are native and authoritative with stable references, CLI creation and editing, and agent-driven filing from conversation. The in-product assistant has Linear search, create and move tools when a key is configured, but no import or two-way tracker sync was found.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Projects, workspaces and scratch chats are created locally from prompts, and asking for work in a side workspace makes the agent start the workspace and its chat itself. External intake is repository-shaped (clone URL, attached worktrees) with GitHub PR metadata read back into the topbar and PR round-trips through gh. No issue tracker, sync, or chat/git triggers exist in docs or the pinned release.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Issue brief, acceptance criteria, state paragraph and todos persist on the durable issue record. Release 0.3.0 removed the separate design and notes fields and appended their text to the brief. On the human issue page the title, description and acceptance are editable and the brief is read-only; agents edit the brief and other fields through issue commands.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-11. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Shared TODO plans carry the work with per-step review and independent reviewers, editable by user and agent, with implementation links through per-step commits and turn receipts. Plans survive restarts and mid-run steering. Completed steps form immutable history; explicit acceptance-criteria fields and a separate plan-edit history are undescribed.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium supports persistent parent and child issues, phases and typed dependency links, including reparenting an existing issue without replacing its identity. Since 0.3.0 issue types are task, phase and decision: epic and other kinds are retired, and any issue with children acts as a parent. Dependency types are fixed to blocked-by, related, discovered-from, supersedes and duplicates. Cycles are refused and docs list an open blocker as a reason an issue cannot start. No mandatory workflow preset applies in the baseline.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The pinned release implements a flat workspace model (own branch/cwd, settled/active states) with side workspaces and handoff growth, but no epics, parent/child depth, blockers, readiness gates, dependency enforcement or state propagation. A bundled workflow skill set routes by default without a mandatory gate.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
v0.3.0 routes Podium issue instructions and relay environment through terminal and engine session launch. Claude stream sessions use appended instructions and boundary callbacks; Codex server sessions use developer instructions, Grok ACP uses rules, and OpenCode uses the prompt system field. Claude and Codex boundary hooks can re-prime after compaction. Transcript mirroring is on by default; full-text indexing needs the command-palette flag, which defaults off. Agent profiles can carry markdown instructions. Curated memory, skills and memory correction or deletion controls remain unestablished. No instruction-delivery or compaction scenario was run.
Project knowledge persists in the mtime-guarded SPEC.md graph the agent searches and maintains, plus pi skills, project skills and session state shared between CLI and app. Per-project trust grants scope what loads. Provenance, correction and freshness beyond index revalidation are only partly established.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Not established. Podium mirrors daemon transcripts by default, keeps a full-text index only when the command-palette flag is on, and stores session attachments. No repository code search, architecture awareness or API retrieval feature was found.
The agent retrieves code and specs through pi tools, spec_search and a ranked spec index that also powers palette # search; file text search, web research and MCP knowledge presets extend it. Voice dictation and @ files add input modalities. Retrieval freshness and scope are partly established; citations, conflict detection and review-time rule enforcement are not.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium exposes native issue creation with an optional start flag, separate dispatch, editing, comments, labels, assignment, search, board filters, archive, sibling ordering and an issue tree. Issue records have their own identity separate from sessions and stages are durable. The idea-to-mission scenario was not run. v0.3.0 refuses an agent close or done update while issue sessions are computing unless --confirm-interrupt is supplied; guidance says to request review and close only on user instruction.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
ThinkRail manages work as projects, workspaces (active to Settled shelf) and shared TODO plans rather than a labelled tracker: creation, edit, discussion, search, archive/Trash, reopen, dispatch-by-handoff and durable states exist and were confirmed in code, but prioritisation, labels, assignment and filters do not. No external tracker is required for core work.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
CLI and MCP address the same canonical issue records for reads, creation, edits, claims, state, dependencies and artifacts. Relayed agents have worker capability scoped to their issue subtree, with --outside-scope confirmation for other existing issues. attachSession is not subtree-gated, but direct rehoming from a real issue is refused and an agent attach naming a Proposed target is refused. That does not make every Proposed subtree inert: operator attachment or spawn-time cwd binding can leave a session attached to a Proposed issue; newSubissue without targetId then bypasses the proposed-parent guard, creates a human-audience backlog child and attaches the existing session. This path remains at v0.3.0 source and was not exercised live. Concurrent-edit handling remains unknown.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The agent works the same workspaces, chats and PRs the human sees: it starts side workspaces with chats, checks their chats, PRs and diffs, delegates to subagents and reports results, all visible in the Resources view. Reads, creates and result reporting are established in docs and tool code. Claims, assignment, state changes, dependencies, issue children, attribution and conflict handling do not exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
The spec CLI and service (living specs under pspec with stable SP IDs) are in v0.3.0. Specs is an experimental, default-off feature listed on the edge channel: the flag controls the Specs UI, the spec line in CLI help and whether agents are told about the spec CLI. The podium spec command itself is dispatched, and the server specs service has no flag check, so direct CLI use does not need the flag. This agrees with the docs, which call specs not baseline rather than blocked. Not run end to end.
SPEC.md files form a versioned, human- and agent-editable requirement graph beside the code with frontmatter parent links, maintained by spec_* tools and retrieved in later work through agent search and palette # search. Approval rules, automated drift checks and review-time spec gates do not exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Docs and release notes describe many sessions running as independent terminals, one worktree per issue, and several paired machines under one server, with session and issue state visible on the flight deck, board and CLI. Agent-initiated spawns are limited to 10 per target issue per UTC day. Achieved concurrency is unmeasured.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Several sessions run concurrently per workspace and several workspaces run in parallel, each isolated on its own branch and cwd — implemented in the session manager with parallel Agent calls and background commands. The Projects rail and Resources views show running work. No quotas exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Issues carry an assignee, claim sets assignee and in_progress, a coordinator session can be set per issue, sessions have seats, and work can be placed on a chosen machine or agent profile. claim has no exclusivity check of its own, locks are advisory leases and Podium does not serialize agents editing one worktree, so exclusive ownership is not enforced.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Dispatch is user-initiated: people create workspace chats and agents delegate to subagents; worktree isolation prevents file collision. No queues, claims, routing, duplicate prevention or enforced ownership exist in docs or code.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium orchestrates delegation itself: podium agent spawn starts a full child session on an issue with a chosen harness, model, effort or agent profile, mail carries messages, and bounded await reports the child result. Children are real sessions shown as seats on the flight deck. Agent-initiated spawns take a daily budget per issue. A complete delegated task with retained child findings was not run.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
ThinkRail-bundled pi-subagents and pi-delegation give every parent session Agent and get_subagent_result tools over isolated child sessions, with per-session model and effort choice, live progress and retained outcomes in Resources. Delegation is pi-only with no cross-harness teams; child messaging detail and auth are undescribed, and follow-up is re-reading, not reopening.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
The server owns a scheduler for cron and one-time automations that spawn agent sessions, skipping overlaps and not backfilling occurrences more than an hour late. The Automations UI is an edge-visibility feature that defaults off and docs list automations as non-baseline. Agents can subscribe to issue and session events.
Unattended triggers do not exist: bounded v0.3.2 inspection of packages/server, apps/* and packages/* for schedul|cron|trigger|recur|setInterval-based scheduling found only UI polling, update checks and request replay. No schedules, event triggers, recurring tasks or completion-driven runs exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Chat and native CLI views share a session. v0.3.0 defaults human controller chat to steer and immediately types it into running Claude Code, Codex, Grok and OpenCode TUIs that declare native busy-input queuing; undeclared harnesses wait for a boundary, and compaction waits. Mail and automation keep when-ready delivery. Stop, resume, questions, decision issues and offers remain available. This is inspected implementation, not a cross-harness runtime parity result.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Running turns accept steering and queued follow-ups; background commands and subagents can be watched, inspected and stopped from Resources. MCP data-changing calls and structured agent questions surface as pending decisions with allow/deny control, and history persists. Pause, resume, escalation and terminal-side intervention do not exist; errors surface as toasts.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Release 0.3.0 ships a flight deck showing a whole mission in one view: phases, every task and its state, who works on what, what is blocked and by what, and proposals. Done work stays visible. The CLI prints the same snapshot. The waterfall source is dormant and the Timeline view was deleted, so per-task timeline history is not shown. The shared 12-task UX scenario has not been run.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-11. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The Projects panel lists workspaces across projects with settled states, attention markers and per-branch PR status; no parent/child, dependency or workload views exist and no fleet fixture was exercised. Navigation errors cannot be determined without running the product.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
A quick task can be an interactive session or an issue; an issue can grow into a mission by gaining children while keeping its identity; no mandatory workflow preset applies in the baseline. Per-agent harness, model and effort are chosen at spawn or through agent profiles, and the deck shows seats. The coordinator-with-two-reviewers scenario was not run.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Quick scratch chats grow into workspace work via Continue-in-workspace handoff, and plain-language side-workspace requests configure delegation; per-session model and effort plus mid-run steering adapt execution live. Bundled workflow skills exist without a mandatory preset gate. Roles during work and retained relationships are only partly described.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
The published Podium execution choices are local user machines and a user-owned VPS or paired machine. No vendor-operated agent host is in the complete download offering.
Execution is local: the desktop app and the CLI host run the in-process pi engine on the user’s own machine, provisioned by the installer, with no vendor cloud, no user-server path and no resource, region or expiry concepts. State rebuilds on other surfaces over the wire, but execution does not survive the originating host.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium separates issue files with Git branches and worktrees, but its released daemon launches native host processes without product-managed container or VM provisioning.
Isolation is git worktrees: separate directories, branches and cwds per workspace on the same machine and OS user, with env-based secret handling. No container, VM, OS-sandbox, process or network boundary exists; pi runs in-process. A worktree is file separation, not a security boundary.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Closing a browser tab does not stop the agent process on a running Podium host. Idle sessions may hibernate under configurable policies; a stopped session keeps its transcript, branch and resume reference. Release 0.2.0 says a failed update rolls back and running sessions keep running through the upgrade; database rollback remains a manual restore. Terminal reattachment goes through the driver adopt contract with process-identity and observation-lease checks. Worker-crash and multi-day behavior were not tested.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
State reconstructs from host reads on reload, second tab, phone or host restart, with request replay and delta repair on reconnect; transcripts persist on disk. Disconnect, crash and multi-day behaviour on one machine are partly established. Expiry, duplicates handling and repair flows do not exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Only machine setup is documented: the installer installs missing runtime tools and pairs a host, and the state directory holds server-managed secrets. Dependency caching, services, ports and automatic repair for project environments were not found.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The only environment mechanism is per-host environment-variable injection for agents, terminals and MCP servers. Dependency setup, caches, snapshots, services, ports, duplication, collisions, remote setup and automatic repair do not exist in the product.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium exposes retryable errors, optional auto-continue with backoff, bounded waits and provider quota. Claude stream and hosted headless drivers enforce a supplied turn deadline, with no deadline when timeoutMs is absent. The one-shot headless server runner supplies its budget, default ten minutes. Agent spawns have a daily per-issue budget. Operator-configurable task-wide turn, token and spend caps remain unestablished; quota display is not enforcement.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Limits and failure handling do not exist: bounded v0.3.2 inspection of the server found only model maxTokens passthrough and an internal session-shutdown budget. No time, turn, token or spend limits, timeouts, retries or provider-failure budgets exist. Token and cost displays are visibility, not enforcement.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium offers local logs and crash export, structured session status, issue stats, a usage and analytics sheet with hourly list-price cost, per-task costs and host load panels. The 0.3.0 notes report a vendor benchmark of about 330 MB server memory against about 1.2 GB for an earlier Podium build, and 8 to 52 percent faster start; the method is published in the repository and was not reproduced here. Usage export and cross-reconnect consistency were not established.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-11. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Turn receipts, folded tool steps, command log tails, per-chat token and cost ticks, MCP pending-confirm cards and topbar PR checks and review decisions give live status; per-chat token stats are the only statistics, and reconnects repair state. Usage export and measured responsiveness do not exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Since 0.2.0 Podium shows what each task costs, on the task header and the usage sheet, with per-session rows and descendant rollups. The 0.3.0 deck adds a mission cost chip. Figures are token estimates at public model list prices, not subscription invoices or provider bills.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Every chat ticks pi-reported tokens (input, output, cache reads and writes) and cost live; JetBrains AI quota snapshots on a 30-second default cadence with a 20-second PR-check refresh. Child, epic and aggregate costs, reconciliation, alerts, export and drill-down do not exist, and unknown subscription marginal cost is never rendered as zero.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium reports host memory, load and disk, auto-hibernates idle sessions under pressure, and provides named advisory resource leases. The merge-queue panel was removed; a shipping queue remains behind the Shipping flag. Concurrency limits and bounded test queuing were not established.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Parallel sessions and workspaces run with no declared concurrency limits, queues or resource awareness; the only controls are session ownership and stopping background commands or subagents. No bounded load behaviour was established in code.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
The issue UI displays owner and visibility read-only and deliberately omits sharing controls. Backend share handlers and a Members settings section with invites and admin or member roles exist; they do not establish a finished human collaboration workflow. Docs say small teams can share an instance but the interface prioritizes one operator.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Live human collaboration does not exist: ThinkRail is a single-owner local product whose auth model (Tailscale ACLs plus an owner field, no login UI) has no second user, shared prompting, presence, ordering, attribution or permission constructs. The launch post’s Git-and-GitHub line does not establish co-steering.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium defines member/admin instance roles and admin-only membership management. The released client authentication uses password-backed sessions and paired-device tokens without enterprise SSO.
Roles and access boundaries do not exist: no organisations, project or task roles, membership, SSO, provisioning, revocation or plan scoping, because there are no accounts. Host reach is a network (Tailscale) matter, and SSO is excluded by the no-login-UI non-goal.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Agent-session management requests go through an operator approval broker with approve and deny; the privacy docs say lifecycle commands and automation requests may require operator approval. Harness permission prompts appear as a Permission needed state; credential copying during pairing is a per-grant opt-in. Command-level policy enforcement beyond the harness own modes was not established.
MCP data-changing calls confirm in the chat with Deny, Allow once, Allow in this chat or Always allow (per project, lapsing on entry change); repo resources and repo MCP entries stay off until explicit grants; shell-credential hygiene is host-enforced. The human user approves merges. Shell-command and network approvals are not a product surface, and no tunnels exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Issue actions, approval steps, comments and mail are recorded server-side. Issue activity events, including approval steps, are pruned by the server's janitor once they are older than 14 days or fall outside the newest 50,000 rows. That policy does not define all content retention, export or tamper-evident audit guarantees.
Turn receipts, resource history, anchored review comments and PR states persist across sessions and host restarts; Settled workspaces and Trash give retention shape. History alteration is delete-only, export and integrity models do not exist, and no audit claim is made.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Review is a documented loop: issue stage review, diff and checks, artifacts, offers with merge or send-back buttons, and a Tray of review-ready work. Release 0.3.0 adds quoting text from a reply or review finding into the next message and a full-height reading view with an outline. The board has a key map with a help sheet. Guided-review quality and narrow-screen use were not measured.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Review is a guided loop: the palette and Review-turn button surface pending work, stacked Changes tabs with Keep/Revert/Ask-agent plus Next-unreviewed (J key in code) navigate evidence, anchored comments and Fix-with-agent request changes, and the topbar names the next shipping step. Phone viewports adapt; effort timing, missed-evidence analysis and switching costs are not measured.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
The durable issue, session transcript, artifacts and mail persist for any later agent, and a live session can be handed to another machine in an edge feature. Colleague takeover by a second person was not established.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Same-user continuity is implemented: previous conversations reopen with history and sessions move between the pi CLI and the app. Second-person takeover, ownership transfer, permissions, runtime handoff and context-loss handling do not exist in this single-owner product.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Artifact commands store immutable server-side copies of issue-linked files, including images, video, HTML and documents, which render in the issue sidebar and offers and stay readable after the worktree is gone. Each task has an artifacts page grouped into screens, documents and reports, with filters and search. Revision linking remains untested.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-07. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Diffs, documents, file previews, UI mockups, test outputs and reviewer outputs persist with the transcript and branch; per-run Changes tabs and per-hunk review carry the evidence. Screenshot capture, recordings, a cross-task gallery and prompt leakage into outputs do not exist in the pinned release.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
In the experimental Shipping path a configured validation profile runs before landing (default argv bun run test with a 10 minute timeout) and a failed validation holds the order. Lint, type, CI and spec conformance gates and independent review requirements were not found as product-enforced policy.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Verification is agent-driven and displayed, not product-enforced: the agent runs tests in terminals, CI checks display on the PR, and plan steps can route to an independent reviewer. Required gates, lint/type gates, failure blocking, requirement-conflict handling and configured or enforced policy do not exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Issues own branches and worktrees, and issue actions rebase, open a pull request with gh (pr create --fill) and merge, subject to a merge-style setting (ff-only by default, with auto-rebase before merge). Podium does not resolve branch conflicts, and PR review comments and CI response were not established.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The full GitHub loop is integrated in the topbar: own branches and worktrees, per-step commits, PR open/update through gh with templates or agent drafts, CI response with Fix-with-agent, rebase preview, and merge/reopen/branch-delete actions — all present in the pinned pr/github modules. PR-comment round-trips and GitLab review actions are the limits.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
The operator accepts work through offers and runs the merge action under a branch merge-lock; in the experimental Shipping path approval is frozen to an exact head and delivery lands on a local target branch by default. Release and deployment are not product features found in the sources.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The human user approves (Ready for review), merges (repo-allowed methods, remembered per project), reopens and deletes remote branches from the topbar, governed by GitHub merge state. Release and deploy authority do not exist in the product.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Shipping orders record approved base and head SHAs, tested integration SHA, landed ref and validation result in a durable delivery receipt, and stale approvals hold the order. Shipping is experimental. The pr action records a PR URL on the issue. Build and deployment links and rollback were not found.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Turn receipts and per-step commits link work to code, the topbar links branches to PRs with delivery state and retained transcripts, and local revert (hunk/file Keep/Revert) plus stale-approval invalidation (Keep lapses on re-edit) are built in. Build/deployment links and post-merge rollback do not exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
The shipping service records revision-specific approval, configured validation and delivery receipts. The Shipping panel is an experimental edge toggle, off by default; the separate Queues panel was removed.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-07. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Per-branch review is implemented (receipts, retained findings, anchored change requests, next-step topbar, stale-Keep invalidation), and the Projects/Settled views list reviewable work — but grouping, risk filters, exact-revision batch approval, dependency queues and check dedup do not exist. No batch queue exists.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
The public repository is licensed Apache 2.0, and the website presents Podium as an open-source agent development environment. Hosted extensions and hosted-service terms are not established.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
ThinkRail is Apache-2.0 across the public repo: desktop app, CLI host, engine library, contracts, web UI and all bundled extensions ship from one codebase with no proprietary twin or licence exception. The revision is pinned to release v0.3.2 (commit 1bc1a9b).
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Local desktop and self-hosted installs run on user-controlled machines with a documented state directory. The docs describe stopped full-state backup and automatic pre-migration database-only snapshots retaining three copies. Those snapshots omit artifacts, transcripts, uploads, configuration and secrets; no portable structured export/import contract was established.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-11. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
The core ADE runs entirely on user-controlled machines with no vendor services to keep: optional companions are the user’s git, gh, central CLI and Tailscale. Uninstall removes the binary and optionally ~/.thinkrail state. Task, context and history export formats do not exist.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Docs state repositories and native harness credentials stay on machines you control and server state lives in a documented directory. Since 0.2.0 a daily usage report is on by default and can be turned off; crash reports stay opt-in. Usage reports carry an install id, schema version, Podium version, OS, architecture, bucketed install age and machine count, session counts per harness and whether issues were used. Crash reports carry the same install id, versions, OS and architecture, a fixed error type and up to 20 stack frames, each with a Podium source file path, line and function when there is one; error messages and frames outside Podium are dropped. Neither tier sends prompts, transcripts, your code or paths outside the Podium source tree. Model-provider handling is the harness own. Hosted analytics and website analytics are separate paths.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-21. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Code, prompts and credentials stay with the user: in-process pi sends them to the user’s own providers, never to ThinkRail servers. Telemetry is basic install-ID events plus always-on error reports via PostHog; extra sharing is opt-in at first run and in Settings Privacy (or --no-analytics). Retention beyond a 30-day link expiry, training use and residency are unstated business facts.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
No Podium price is published: podium.do/pricing returns 404 and the docs list billing as not implemented. The software is open source and free to download; model and compute costs are the user's own.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
ThinkRail itself is free: Apache-2.0 source, free downloads, no accounts, no paid plan and no metered units. Model and compute spend belongs to the user’s own providers and hardware and is never billed or marked up by ThinkRail. Billing dimensions do not apply to a product with no paid offering.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Fixed ThinkRail cost is $0 for one, two or five developers (free installs, parallel workspaces included, no seats). Variable cost is the team’s own provider spend on tokens; no invented per-task averages are used. Two-person collaboration is limited by the single-user design and shared via git.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium is pre-1.0. Stable v0.3.1 (2026-11-06), an update fix, follows v0.3.0 (2026-11-05), v0.2.0 (2026-10-11) and v0.1.0 (2026-08-21), with edge and dev prerelease channels. Windows and Linux desktop are Experimental, the native iPhone app is in private beta and hosted Podium is unconfirmed. Support runs through GitHub issues, Discord and private vulnerability reporting.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Pre-1.0 beta under active development: stable v0.3.2 plus public nightlies with daily commits, free of access restrictions beyond provider credentials. Support is Discord plus GitHub issues with no committed response times and no published status history; uninstall documents exit without export.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
Podium is open-source Apache-2.0 software, and the download page calls it free and open source. Download links for macOS, Linux and Windows redirect to GitHub release assets without a login (observed by HTTP requests; not installed). No Podium charge is documented for self-hosting; agent provider usage is separate. The native iPhone app is private beta and hosted access is unconfirmed.
Checked 2026-11-06 (16 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-06. Scope and sources
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Free outright: Apache-2.0 source with free desktop and CLI downloads and no paid plan, card, trial, credit programme, gated early access or usage caps. Meaningful evaluation needs only provider credentials (JetBrains AI or own keys/local models); two-person same-work collaboration is limited by the single-user design.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources
No publishable sourced finding is available for this criterion. This does not mean the product lacks the capability.
ThinkRail
Agent cross-checkedpartial
Pricing is transparent because there is nothing to hide: free with no paid plan, no metered units, no overages, no markups, no minimums and nothing sales-gated. Model and compute economics are the user’s own provider and hardware spend, never marked up.
Checked 2026-11-12 (10 days old); agent cross-checked 2026-11-12. Scope and sources